A field intercomparison and fundamental characterization of various dust samplers with a reference sampler

The European Economic Community Council Directive 80/779/EEC describes air quality limit values and guide values for sulfur dioxide and suspended particulates. However, article 10, paragraph 1 does not define well enough the reference method required, amongst others, for the gravimetric measurement of suspended particulates. It is explicity stated in article 10, paragraph 5 of the directive, that "the commission shall, in selected locations in the member states and in cooperation with the latter, carry out studies on the sampling...of suspended particulates. These studies shall be designed in particular to promote the harmonization of methods of sampling and analysis of these pollutants." Therefore, in a joint research program the Umweltbundesamt (grant #104 02263), the commission of European Communities (grant #84-B-6642-11-017-11-N) and the U.S. EPA (grant #2-432U-3580) funded the development of a reference dust sampler by the Fraunhofer-Institute of Toxicology and Aerosol Research (FhlTA, in Hannover, Federal Republic of Germany) in order: to study the particle size distribution of ambient air aerosol at a number of selected sites; to compare the results obtained with the reference dust sampler with those of particle samplers operated in Europe and the United States; to verify the applicability of wind tunnel results to sampling behaviour in the free atmosphere.     

A Technique for Respirable Sampling

The purpose of this paper is to describe instrumentation to aerodynamically size suspended particulates found in ambient air and to summarize results of field testing utilizing the new technique.

A four-stage, multiorifice high-volume fractionating impactor with backup filter, which can be operated as a component of the standard high-volume sampler, collects particulate matter in five separate aerodynamic size ranges: 7 micrometer (μm) or larger, 3.3 to 7 μm, 2.0 to 3.3 μm, 1.1 to 2.0 μm, and 0.01 to 1.1 μm.

Comparative field tests utilizing duplicate sampling techniques were conducted to determine the feasibility of using the size fractionator on a routine basis in field operations. Verification of the actual particle size separation was not undertaken; however, earlier tests utilizing laboratory-generated aerosols have been performed with satisfactory results.

The results of field tests indicate that the fractionator can be used to determine the aerodynamic size distribution of particulate matter. A glass fiber surface with a pH of 11.0 was found to adsorb atmospheric acid gases during sampling and thus gave erroneous mass concentration results when compared to the standard high-volume sampler. Glass fiber filters with a pH of 6.5 eliminated the acid gas adsorption.     

Metallic elements in particulates released during incense-burning at Tzu Yun Yen temple, Taichung, Taiwan

Concentrations of ambient suspended particulates were measured at Tzu Yun Yen temple (120°, 34′ 10”E; 24°, 16′, 12”N), using a Universal sampler and dry deposition plates. The temple is a characteristic incense-burning and semi-open sampling site. PM_2.5 concentrations for Period 1 (average 901μg/m3) were higher than those for Period 2 (average 701μg/m3). Results for average PM_2.5-10concentrations showed equal distributions in Period 1 and Period 2. Average ratios of PM_2.5/ PM₁₀ were higher in Period 1 (74%) than Period 2 (71%). In addition, the suspended particulate (PM₁₀) elements concentrations during Zhong Yuan Jie, and the first and 15th days of nong li for each month (Chinese lunar calendar) were all higher than during non-Zhong Yuan Jie and non-first and non-15th days. Furthermore, the dry deposition velocities of manganese in fine particulates (PM_2.5) and suspended particulates (PM₁₀) were 1.43 and 0.751cm/s, respectively, and the dry deposition velocities of cadmium in fine particulates (PM_2.5) and suspended particulates (PM₁₀) were 1.86 and 0.991cm/s, respectively.     

High Volume Sampling: Errors Incurred during Passive Sample Exposure Periods

The current Federal EPA reference method for the determination of total suspended particulate matter (TSP) in the atmosphere is the high volume method (hi-vol).¹ The hi-vol sampler is normally operated for a 24 hr period by drawing air through an 8 X 10 in. glass fiber filter at an air sampling flow rate of between 40-60 cfm. TSP samples are presently collected in this manner every 6th day (61 samples/year). Results are used to determine compliance with existing National Primary Ambient Air Quality Standards for TSP (i.e., 260 µg/m³, maximum 24 hr average, not to be exceeded more than once a year; 75 µg/m³, annual geometric mean). However, when the sampling frequency is diminished to only 61 out of a possible 365 measurements each year, the degree of certainty associated with meeting these air quality standards is also decreased.^2,3 This partial sampling schedule also introduces other sampling errors. One such error caused by the exposure of the collection filter both prior and subsequent to the desired sampling day is the subject of the following discussion.     

Isokinetic Sampler for Continuous Airborne Aerosol Measurements

For aerosol measurements, especially those concerned with the aerosol particle size distribution, it is important to sample in isokinetic conditions. Most available instrumentation for aerosol measurements is intended for use on the ground under light wind conditions; intake air speeds rarely exceed a few meters per second. If the same instrumentation is used onboard an aircraft, the air must be decelerated 60 or more m/sec before It is sampled by individual instruments.

On The Pennsylvania State University Meteorology research aircraft, the air for all aerosol instruments is decelerated in a single isokinetic sampler located above the roof of the cabin outside the aircraft boundary layer. The air enters the sampler through a carefully designed circular intake. Its velocity is reduced as the cross section increases along a 7° conical diffuser. The expansion cone terminates in a cylindrical chamber in which the air velocity is 1/16 the aircraft speed. Behind the sampling chamber the air is accelerated in a second conical section to an end exhaust port. Exhaust porf "pumping" is used to compensate internal losses and, thus, helps preserve the isokinetic nature of the sampler.

Tubes leading to individual instruments are located in the sampling chamber and may be individually adapted to match the air sampling velocity with the local air speed inside the sampling chamber. The level of turbulence (u_rms/û) in the sampling section is =^0.05.

The sampler has been thoroughly wind tunnel and flight tested and successfully used in August and November, 1974, for field programs in the St. Louis and Tucson metropolitan areas, respectively.     

The Mass Distribution of Large Atmospheric Particles

This paper describes the results of a study to determine the total mass and the mass distribution of atmospheric aerosols, especially that mass associated with particles greater than 10 μm diameter. This study also determined what fraction of the total aerosol mass a standard high-volume air sampler collects and what fraction and size interval settle out on a dust fall plate. A special aerosol sampling system was designed for this study to obtain representative samples of large airborne particles. A suburban sampling site was selected because no local point sources of aerosols existed nearby. Samples were collected under various conditions of wind velocity and direction to obtain measurements on different types of aerosols.

Study measurements show that atmospheric particulate matter has a bimodal mass distribution. Mass associated with large particles mainly ranged from 5 to 100 μm in size, while mass associated with small particles ranged from an estimated 0.03 to 5 μm in size. Combined, these two distributions produced a bimodal mass distribution with a minimum around 5 μm diameter. The high-volume air sampler was found to collect most of the total aerosol mass, not just that fraction normally considered suspended particulate. Dust fall plates did not provide a good or very useful measure of total aerosol mass. The two fundamental processes of aerosol formation, condensation and dispersion appear to account for the formation of a bimodal mass distribution in both natural and anthropogenic aerosols. Particle size distribution measurements frequently are in error because representative samples of large airborne particles are not obtained. Considering this descrepancy, air pollution regulations should specify or be based upon an upper particle size limit.     

Fugitive Dust Emission Source Profiles and Assessment of Selected Control Strategies for Particulate Matter at Gravel Processing Sites in Taiwan

Abstract

Particles emitted from gravel processing sites are one contributor to worsening air quality in Taiwan. Major pollution sources at gravel processing sites include gravel and sand piles, unpaved roads, material crushers, and bare ground. This study analyzed fugitive dust emission characteristics at each pollution source using several types of particle samplers, including total suspended particulates (TSP), suspended particulate (PM₁₀), fine suspended particulate (PM_2.5), particulate sizer, and dust-fall collectors. Furthermore, silt content and moisture in the gravel were measured to develop particulate emission factors. The results showed that TSP (<100 µm) concentrations at the boundary of gravel sites ranged from 280 to 1290 µg/m³, which clearly exceeds the Taiwan hourly air quality standard of 500 µg/m³. Moreover, PM₁₀ concentrations, ranging from 135 to 550 µg/m³, were also above the daily air quality standard of 125 µg/m³ and approximately 1.2 and 1.5 times the PM_2.5 concentrations, ranging from 105 to 470 µg/m³. The size distribution analysis reveals that mass mean diameter and geometric standard deviation ranged from 3.2 to 5.7 µm and from 2.82 to 5.51, respectively. In this study, spraying surfactant was the most effective control strategy to abate windblown dust from unpaved roads, having a control efficiency of approximately 93%, which is significantly higher than using paved road strategies with a control efficiency of approximately 45%. For paved roads, wet suppression provided the best dust control efficiencies ranging from 50 to 83%. Re-vegetation of disturbed ground had dust control efficiencies ranging from 48 to 64%.     

Air Particulates Associated with the Ash Whitefly

Unusual air particulates are linked to recent heavy infestations of the ash whitefly in California using high-performance liquid chromatography, scanning electron microscopy, optical and infrared microscopy, ion chromatography and X-ray fluorescence spectrometry. The unusual particles apparently are microdroplets of ash whitefly honeydew. Most of the suspended honeydew is in microdroplets with diameters between about two and twenty microns. The microdroplets were found to contain substantial amounts of sugars, primarily the oligosaccharides stachyose and raffinose. They also contain about 1 percent potassium, mainly as K⁺ The unusual microdroplets have been found in samples of air particulates taken in many areas of California after 1988.

Using a receptor model, the suspended honeydew was calculated to add as much as 40 microgm/M³ to PM₁₀ mass. The highest levels of suspended honeydew occurred between late August and early November.     

Sizing of atmospheric particulates with a high volume cascade impactor

This article describes the development of a high volume cascade impactor with a sampling rate of 20 ft³/min that can be powered by high volume blowers in common use for air sampling. With this impactor it is now possible to collect enough sample of atmospheric particulates in a 24 hour period to conveniently determine an aerodynamic size distribution of suspended particulates by gravimetric analysis. The impactor has four stages and an after-filter and separates particles from the air stream by inertial impaction. The effective cutoff diameters for the stages are 7.0, 3.3, 2.0, and 1.1 microns. The after-filter traps the submicron material.     

The Relationship between “Soiling Index” and Suspended Particulate Matter Concentrations

Experimental relationships between the mass concentration of suspended particulate matter and the optical density of particulates collected on paper tape have been determined for the atmospheric aerosol and for aerosols of constant optical properties. Simultaneous samples were obtained on membrane filters (for gravimetric analysis) and on Whatman No. 4 paper tape (for optical evaluation). Sampling procedures were adopted which ensured that the efficiency of sampling was the same in both cases.

Consistent relationships between mass concentrations of suspended particulate matter and optical density expressed in terms of per cent transmittance or per cent reflectance were found for dispersions of coal, limestone, fly ash, and a coal-limestone mixture.

For atmospheric aerosol samples collected on the roof of the Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, the relationship between mass concentration and per cent transmittance or per cent reflectance was found to be linear over the range of values observed. The correlation coefficients were ?0.93 (for concentration versus per cent transmittance) and ?0.89 (for concentration versus per cent reflectance).     

Evaluation of the Use of Diffusive Air Samplers for Determining Temporal and Spatial Variation of Volatile Organic Compounds in the Ambient Air of Urban Communities

Abstract

The Houston-Galveston metropolitan area has a relatively high density of point and mobile sources of air toxics, and determining and understanding the relationship between emissions and ambient air concentrations of air toxics is important for evaluating potential impacts on public health and formulating effective regulatory policies to control this impact, both in this region and elsewhere. However, conventional ambient air monitoring approaches are limited with regard to expense, siting limitations, and representative sampling necessary for adequate exposure assessment. The overall goal of this multiphase study is to evaluate the use of simple passive air samplers to determine temporal and spatial variability of the ambient air concentrations of selected volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in urban areas. Phase 1 of this study, reported here, was a field evaluation of 3M organic vapor monitors (OVMs) involving limited comparisons with commonly used active sampling methods, an assessment of sampler precision, a determination of optimal sampling duration, and an investigation of the utility of a simple modification of the commercial sampler. The results indicated that a sampling duration of 72 hr exhibited generally low bias relative to automated continuous gas chromatography measurements, good overall precision, and an acceptable number of measurements above detection limits. The modified sampler showed good correlation with the commercial sampler, with higher sampling rates, although lower than expected.     

Performance Characteristics of PM10 Samplers under Calm Air Conditions

ABSTRACT

The size range of airborne particles that is closely related to specific deposition regions in the human respiratory tract and excess lung burden of these deposited particles is associated with disease. Size-selective sampling, therefore, needs to be performed to assess the related health risks. Performance criteria applied to these samplers must be well characterized in order to provide accurate and reliable results. The PM₁₀ samplers that have been used in place of the total suspended particulate samplers for the collection of ambient air particles are more relevant to potential inhalation hazards. In order to be certified, a PM₁₀ sampler must meet reliable performance specifications, primarily the aerosol penetration test with liquid and solid particles in a wind tunnel (wind speeds of 2, 8, and 24 km/hr). This testing is intended to assure reasonable accuracy in aerosol measurements. However, the sampler performance under calm air conditions has not been well studied.

In the present study, the sampling heads of three devices—the Harvard impactor, the Personal Environmental Monitor (PEM), and the Sierra Andersen model 241 dichotomous sampler PM₁₀ inlet head—were tested for aerosol separation efficiency. With the consideration of bias and imprecision of the measurements, five specimens of each type of sampler were chosen for performance testing, repeating the tests 5 times for each specimen. An ultrasonic atomizing nozzle was used to nebulize potassium sodium tartrate tetrahydrate and dioctyl phthalate particles as the solid and liquid challenge aerosols, respectively. The aerosol number concentrations and size distributions upstream and downstream of the samplers were measured by using an aerosizer calibrated against a settling velocity chamber. The results showed that among the samplers tested, the dichotomous sampler PM₁₀ inlet head had the best fit to the PM₁₀ convention, while the other two samplers not only appeared to have a steeper separation-curve slope but also had significant particle bounce when challenged with solid particles. Analysis of variance also confirmed the superiority of the dichotomous samplers. Surface-coating with oil or grease greatly reduced the problem of particle bounce.     

Some Applications of Microscopy to Air Pollution

The microscope as it has been and is now applied to air pollution work is discussed. A summary of the most common particulate sampling equipment is presented and distinctions as to the area of usage (suspended, or settled particulates) are made in each instance. Actual cases are discussed in which the polarizing microscope was used to determine identities and source of particulate pollutants. Particles from such sources as power plants, feed mills, and combustion sources are discussed and photomicrographs of known samples and unknown particles causing complaints are presented and compared as part of the discussion. References are given which deal with sampling equipment and microscopic analysis of various particulates.     

Measurement of BTEX (benzene,toluene, ethybenzene,and xylene) levels at urban and semirural areas of Algiers City using passive air samplers

The study presents the levels of air pollution by aromatic organic compounds BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, o-, m-, and p-xylenes) in the city of Algiers. The sampling was carried out using Radiello passive sampler. Three sampling campaigns were carried out in roadside, tunnel, urban background, and semirural sites in Algiers. In order to determine the diurnal mean levels of air pollution by BTEX to which people are exposed, a modified passive sampler was used for the first time. In addition, monitoring of pollution inside vehicles was also made. In the spring of 2009, more than 27 samplings were carried out. In the background and road traffic sites the Radiello sampler was exposed for 7 days, whereas the time exposure was reduced to 1 day in the case of the vehicle as well as the tunnel. The results indicate that average benzene concentrations in the roadside and inside vehicle exceed largely the limit value of 5 μg m^?3 established by the European Community (EC). On the other hand, it has been noticed that the concentration levels of other BTEX are relatively high. Also, in order to identify the origin of emission sources, ratios and correlations between the BTEX species have been highlighted. This study shows that road traffic remains the main source of many local emission in Algiers.

Implications The vehicle fleet in Algeria is growing rapidly since the 1990s following economic growth and is responsible for the increasing air pollution in large cities. Because there are no data collection of BTEX carried out by national air quality network, all environmental and transportation policies are based on European emissions standards, but national emission standards are currently not in place. This work will contribute to the analysis of real emissions of BTEX in Algiers, for the development of management and for assessment of population exposure variation depending on the location in the city of Algiers.     

Visibility and Mass Concentration in a Nonurban Environment

Considerable interest is currently directed toward atmospheric visibility and its relationship to particle size and mass concentration. Previous work has been limited to heavily polluted urban areas, and visibility studies have not included particle size characterization. An air sampling program was carried out in a nonurban, low pollution area to relate: (a) total particulate mass concentration measured with a high-volume sampler, (b) particulate mass size distribution measured with aerodynamic size selective samplers, and (c) visual range measured by the integrating nephelometer. For low suspended particulate mass concentrations, the following relationship was defined between visual range (L_v) and mass concentration (M ? μg/m³):     

Spatial Factors Influencing Winter Primary Particle Sampling and Interpretation

ABSTRACT

Aerosol samplers collect material that is locally generated as well as that transported from upwind; knowing the extent of the area from which the sample is drawn is necessary for proper interpretation of sampler data. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) PM_2.5 monitoring guidelines recognize a conceptual hierarchy of sampler spatial representation, but provide no objective measures of a site’s spatial representativeness. A case study of a sampler tributary area in central California provides insights into the factors that determine a sampler’s spatial representation. Winter diurnal cycles of fine particle concentrations at places of habitation ranging from urban cores to small farm towns show a marked cycle that can be linked to local human activity. Assessment of the possible causes of the observed cycles leads to the hypothesis that local sources dominate primary particle mass in winter samples. The hypothesis was tested using a simple model to relate routine 24-hr PM₁₀ and PM_2.5 samples to a sampler’s surroundings. Model results indicate that even minor sources very close to a sampler will overwhelm any regional component in a sample. The results for the cases studied also demonstrate that, in winter, most coarse (PM_10-2.5) particles collected are less than 2 hr old, and most primary fine (PM_2.5) particles are less than 4 hr old. Even on days that are not truly “stagnant,” samplers are very strongly influenced by their immediate surroundings (distances less than 10 km), and only weakly influenced by regional emissions.

The implications for interpretation of sample analyses are as follows: 1. Typical PM sampling networks are unlikely to represent regional conditions;

2. Similarity of samples in time and space between widely separated samplers probably arises from sampling analogous local environments rather than a uniformly mixed regional air mass;

3. Even weak sources near a sampler will prevent regionally representative samples, so that “background” specification in models can be strongly skewed by misapplication of sampler data;

4. Source-receptor relationships within a single modeling grid cell can cause measured and modeled source impacts at a sampler to diverge by orders of magnitude, even for grid cells as small as 1 km; and

5. Differential deposition of coarse and fine particles will skew source apportionment by chemical tracers unless the tracers and the source emissions have the same size distribution.

     

Continuous Determination of Carbon Monoxide and Hydrocarbons in Air by a Modified Infrared Analyzer

The original goals of this project¹ were to establish the shape of a smoke curve for fine suspended particulates in New York City comparable to the International Smoke Curve used in British and other European practice, and to relate two commonly used reporting units of surface concentration, μg/m³ (European practice) and Coh/1000 lineal feet (United States practice), to each other. While not directly a goal of the project, it was essential in the course of work to study the relationship between particulate density readings taken for one hour and two hour sampling periods. Progress toward achievement of these goals is presented in the following pages.     

Particulate and Sulfur Dioxide Concentration Measurements in Patras,Greece

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to obtain a better assessment of the Patras, Greece, air quality, in terms of the primary pollutants total suspended particulates (TSPs) and sulfur dioxide (SO₂), because limited and short-duration measurements have been conducted in the past. Installation and operation of a mobile air monitoring station at two different locations in the Patras downtown area and one location in the outskirts of the city was undertaken and covered the periods July 1, 1994-January 30, 1995; March 18-August 23, 1995; and April 19-July 27, 1996, respectively. For both pollutants measured at each location, the monthly average concentrations and typical weekly variation of daily averages, as well as the diurnal variations and frequency concentration distributions in each month of the monitoring periods, were calculated and are presented in bar diagrams. The annual and winter period medians and the annual 98th percentile were also calculated and are compared with the limit and guide values provided by the European Economic Community Council Directive 80/779/EEC. In addition, comparison of SO₂ values is made with the limit values adopted by the more recent Directive 1999/30/EC. It was found that the TSP and SO₂ levels at all locations were very low and were lower than the levels found in Thessaloniki and Athens, Greece. An attempt to explain what had been measured is also undertaken. The data presented are considered essential for future reference and comparison purposes.     

Estimating dust emission from a sandbank on the downstream Jhuoshuei River under strong wind conditions

An empirical emission model based on experimental data was proposed. The total suspended particulates (TSP) emission model obtained by using stepwise multiple-regression analysis was significant (p<0.001); moreover, the relatively high value of R-squared (R²=0.85), which indicated that four parameters included in the model (air temperature, soil silt content, soil moisture content, and wind speed) accounted for the particulate emissions from a sandbank. The results of the multiple-regression analysis demonstrated that the TSP emission factors increased with increase in air temperature, soil silt content and wind speed, but were inversely affected by the soil moisture content. The model equation verified the experimental results and proved itself to be an important tool in predicting the dust emissions from a sandbank under strong wind conditions.     

Characterization of particulate emissions from Australian open-cut coal mines: Toward improved emission estimates

Given the significance of mining as a source of particulates, accurate characterization of emissions is important for the development of appropriate emission estimation techniques for use in modeling predictions and to inform regulatory decisions. The currently available emission estimation methods for Australian open-cut coal mines relate primarily to total suspended particulates and PM₁₀ (particulate matter with an aerodynamic diameter <10 μm), and limited data are available relating to the PM_2.5 (<2.5 μm) size fraction. To provide an initial analysis of the appropriateness of the currently available emission estimation techniques, this paper presents results of sampling completed at three open-cut coal mines in Australia. The monitoring data demonstrate that the particulate size fraction varies for different mining activities, and that the region in which the mine is located influences the characteristics of the particulates emitted to the atmosphere. The proportion of fine particulates in the sample increased with distance from the source, with the coarse fraction being a more significant proportion of total suspended particulates close to the source of emissions. In terms of particulate composition, the results demonstrate that the particulate emissions are predominantly sourced from naturally occurring geological material, and coal comprises less than 13% of the overall emissions. The size fractionation exhibited by the sampling data sets is similar to that adopted in current Australian emission estimation methods but differs from the size fractionation presented in the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency methodology. Development of region-specific emission estimation techniques for PM₁₀ and PM_2.5 from open-cut coal mines is necessary to allow accurate prediction of particulate emissions to inform regulatory decisions and for use in modeling predictions.

Implications: Development of region-specific emission estimation techniques for PM₁₀ and PM_2.5 from open-cut coal mines is necessary to allow accurate prediction of particulate emissions to inform regulatory decisions and for use in modeling predictions. Comprehensive air quality monitoring was undertaken, and corresponding recommendations were provided.