Jet Aircraft Operations: Impact on the Air Environment

This paper is directed to those concerned with the air environment and its degradation by the burden of pollution from jet aircraft operations. A summary is presented of the results of a comprehensive air pollution study of jet aircraft operations at the Los Angeles International Airport (LAX). Included in the data obtained from this study are jet engine exhaust measurements for currently used turboprop, turbojet and turbofan engines; measurements of specific contaminants in the atmosphere inside and outside of passenger terminals and ticketing areas, and in aircraft cabins during ground operations including passenger loading and taxiing prior to takeoff; also presented are ambient air measurements in a two-mile radius of the airport. An evaluation is made of the emissions of contaminants from air transport operations and all related ground activities including motor vehicles, that contribute to the total atmospheric contaminant burden at the airport.     

Realistic Mixing Depths for Above Ground Aircraft Emissions

Analysis of vertical temperature soundings at Los Angeles International Airport (LAX) shows that a conservative height of the inversion base for pollutant containment purposes is 490 ft (150 m). This altitude is considerably less than the 3000 ft (914 m) pollution containment altitude assumed by the EPA in preparing their emission inventory for the airport. (Figure 1.) After correcting the EPA emission inventory to reflect a real world inversion height, the emission inventory for aircraft at Los Angeles International Airport is estimated to be approximately 50% less. Aircraft thus become a less significant pollution source and consideration should be given to relaxing engine emission control requirements accordingly.

This paper examines current emission control philosophy, which according to the EPA should be based upon the significance of the particular polluting source. The problem of accounting for above ground aircraft emissions is then considered. Daily inversion height data are then used to determine a realistic vertical containment altitude for aircraft emissions. Problems in obtaining good inversion data are described. Finally, aircraft emissions at Los Angeles International Airport are adjusted to reflect real world inversion conditions on those days when the inversion height is low enough to influence significantly air pollution levels. Recommendations are made for additional research leading to possible change to NO_x emission control requirements for aircraft.     

Transportation-Related Volatile Hydrocarbon Source Profiles Measured in Atlanta

Abstract

Samples representative of transportation-related hydrocarbon emissions were collected as part of the 1990 Atlanta Ozone Precursor Monitoring Study. Motor vehicle emissions were sampled in canisters beside a roadway in a tunnel-like underpass during periods of heavy traffic. Airport and aircraft emissions were approximated by canister samples obtained at a major airport facility. Three octane grades of gasoline were purchased from six major vendors in Atlanta. Canister samples were prepared using these fuels to approximate the whole gasoline and gasoline vapor composition of the fuels in use during the study. All samples were analyzed by gas chromatography/flame ionization detection (GC/FID) for their hydrocarbon content. Detailed speciated hydrocarbon profiles were developed from this source sampling and analysis program for use in the Chemical Mass Balance (CMB) model. Profiles presented and discussed here represent the hydrocarbon composition of emissions from a roadway, composite headspace gasoline at two temperatures, composite whole gasoline, whole gasoline at three octane grades, and an airport. The roadway profile is compared with similar profiles in the literature, and recommendations are made regarding its use in the CMB model. The roadway and fuel profiles are discussed in the context of the MOBILE5 model outputs. The headspace gasoline vapor profile presented here is compared with a headspace gasoline vapor profile calculated from the whole gasoline profile by means of Raoult’s law. Agreement between the measured and calculated headspace profiles is excellent. The airport profile demonstrates the importance of high molecular weight volatile hydrocarbons in airport and aircraft emissions.     

Simulation of the Environmental Impact of an Airport on the Surrounding Air Quality

It is the purpose of this study to demonstrate the procedure involved in simulating those average and maximum pollutant concentrations at or around an airport which fall under the control of the Clean Air Act. The information is useful, when planning new or expanding existing airports, when estimating the impact of airports on the surrounding air quality, and when assessing the effectiveness of control procedures. Simulation of airport air quality requires the accurate assessment of the temporal and spatial emission patterns. This involves the tabulation of air traffic density by type and engine, make and model of aircraft, and engine mode number; the use of fuel by different aircraft; the pollutant emission rates by engine model and operational mode; the allocation of emission rates to the respective runways, turn-off points, taxi-ways, and parking areas, and the time each aircraft spent in the different operational modes. The resulting emission pattern for the Honolulu International Airport reflects scheduled and unscheduled commercial and military jet and piston aircraft and nonaircraft operations. Using this and the appropriate meteorological information average and maximum surface concentrations were calculated and compared with local ambient air quality standards. The calculation of concentrations is based on a newly developed diffusion model incorporating harmonic mean wind speeds for every degree of wind direction as determined by a Parzen maximum likelihood interpolation technique, and the assumption of log-normal concentration distributions. It is shown that for some pollutants the air quality standards are substantially exceeded, and it is concluded that airports may have a considerable adverse impact on their surrounding air quality.     

Jet Aircraft: A Growing Pollution Source

Pollution from jet aircraft is not a problem confined only to Los Angeles County but one which is of interest and concern wherever a major airport exists. Jet traffic at Los Angeles International Airport has increased from 80 flights daily in 1959 to nearly 1000 a day. This number will more than double in the next decade and its air pollution potential will increase in about the same proportion. The Air Pollution Control District investigated this new source of air pollution in Los Angeles County in 1959. In the absence of any previous research evidence or other information which would allow an evaluation of contaminant emissions from jet aircraft engines, it was necessary to develop original and novel test methods. These tests provided a starting point for a new study in 1968, to update the initial investigations and expand on them to include testing of emissions from a new generation of turbofan, as well as late model turbojet and turboprop engines. The primary interest of this study was to obtain as complete and comprehensive information as possible on the kinds and quantities of air contaminants emitted by jet aircraft, particularly at the Los Angeles International Airport. Equally important were the investigations on possible approaches to control of jet aircraft pollution, as well as the decisions as to the scope of the District’s legal jurisdiction in the field of aviation.     

Sulfur Dioxide Air Pollution in New York City: Statistical Analysis of Twelve Years

During the heating season SO₂ levels at three stations in New York City exhibit irregular hourly and daily variation about a long-term repeating annual sine wave which peaks in mid-January. This sine wave varies slightly in phase from station to station, but is nearly coincident in time with long term Normal Temperature observed at Central Park. During summer, SO₂ levels at these stations remain relatively constant at their lowest values. On a daily basis, SO₂ levels tend to exhibit a characteristic bimodality during the heating season. The paper concludes with suggestions for further analysis. Mathematical convenience suggests defining “pollution winter” and ”pollution summer” in agreement with the high and low regions of the sine wave. The frequency distribution for the pollution winter lies considerably above, and that for pollution summer lies considerably below the twelve year distribution for all seasons combined     

a critical review of the Effect of Air Pollution Control Regulations on Land use Planning

A study of the potential effectiveness of several strategies for reducing pollutant emissions from aircraft at a busy metropolitan airport has been carried out. This work is based on a model of emission-producing activities at the Hartsfield Atlanta International Airport and emissions from additional sources in the region surrounding the airport. A steady-state Gaussian plume dispersion model, developed previously,^1-4 was used to determine pollutant concentrations at selected receptor sites. The model of the Atlanta airport was assembled to evaluate the results of a field test of one of the strategies (engine shutdown during taxiing) performed there in late 1973. The results of that field test are reported elsewhere.^5,6 A full discussion of the interpretation of the comparison between modeled and monitored pollutant concentrations during the field test and the examination of alternative strategies noted, here are contained in the final report of this project.⁷     

Predicting Potential Sound Levels : A Case Study in an Urban Area

Allowable sound pressure levels for industrial, commercial and residential sources of noise are typically governed by state and/or local noise regulations. This paper presents a six-step methodology which was successfully applied by a supermarket in Massachusetts to secure state permission to build and operate a new 52,000 square foot store. This multiple step process included baseline noise monitoring, obtaining reference sound levels of the proposed rooftop refrigeration equipment, predicting future sound levels, and recommending soundlevel mitigation techniques. Post-construction monitoring at the store verified that actual worst-case sound levels agreed with predicted values.     

The impact of airport de-icing on a river: the case of the Ouseburn, Newcastle upon Tyne

The damaging effects of airport de-icers to adjacent waterways have been suggested by a number of studies, but none have been able to demonstrate these effects in a field situation. The Ouseburn is a part-urban and partrural catchment of varied land-use and includes a tributary which drains the Newcastle International Airport. The tributary contributes only 3-5% of the river's average flow, yet it had a disproportionately adverse impact upon the river. This paper demonstrates how this was linked to the airport's winter application of urea salt de-icers. An integrated approach involving hydrological, chemical, bacteriological and macroinvertebrate sampling was used. During cold weather, higher levels of ammonia were recorded in the tributary and downstream, and concentrations peaked during runoff events. It is suggested that hydrolysis, facilitated by urea digesting bacteria, and surface runoff is the mechanism by which ammonia enters the stream. The airport tributary had a less diverse macroinvertebrate fauna than expected and had larger numbers of bacteria which were able to utilise urea. In-situ bioassay experiments found large deaths of Gammarus pulex (L.) and low biotic indices at a site downstream of the airport tributary confluence. Together with elevated ammonia levels this suggested that urea application adversely impacted on the main stream's water quality and ecology. The airport authorities have responded by changing to a less toxic de-icer.     

Noise Control Legislation

The national Environmental Protection Agency is expected to issue its recommendations on noise legislation some time during the latter part of 1973. This agency will assume primary responsibility for enforcing noise limits on new products, such as vehicles, construction equipment, electrical equipment, etc. Primary responsibility for community noise control will remain with local governments. Local EPA’s, now involved in air and water pollution, will be given the additional responsibility to enforce anti-noise legislation.This legislation will cover noise emissions fromvehicles, industries, construction equipment, residential air conditioners, and power equipment, and the noises that pervade multifamily dwellings. Responsibility for controlling aircraft noise will be shared with the FAA.

The noise ratings used in this legislation must be capable of easy measurement and yet correlate well with subjective response. For most noises the decibel level read on the A-scale of a sound level meter (dBA) is adequate. For aircraft noise a more complex rating scale must be used which includes consideration of the duration of the noise and the presence of a pure tone (engine whine). For still other noises (industries, construction) some consideration must be given to the total daily exposure time of the noise, along with its dBA rating.

New community noise ordinances will draw on the research and experience associated with the present Chicago, III., ordinance. Some modifications of this ordinance are expected, however, to improve enforcement procedures and to lower vehicle noise levels, which are considered the worst of all the community noise pollutants.     

The impact of NOx,CO and VOC emissions on the air quality of Zurich airport

To study the impact of emissions at an airport on local air quality, a measurement campaign at the Zurich airport was performed from 30 June 2004 to 15 July 2004. Measurements of NO, NO₂, CO and CO₂ were conducted with open path devices to determine real in-use emission indices of aircraft during idling. Additionally, air samples were taken to analyse the mixing ratios of volatile organic compounds (VOC). Temporal variations of VOC mixing ratios on the airport were investigated, while other air samples were taken in the plume of an aircraft during engine ignition. CO concentrations in the vicinity of the terminals were found to be highly dependent on aircraft movement, whereas NO concentrations were dominated by emissions from ground support vehicles. The measured emission indices for aircraft showed a strong dependence upon engine type. Our work also revealed differences from emission indices published in the emission data base of the International Civil Aviation Organisation. Among the VOC, reactive C₂–C₃ alkenes were found in significant amounts in the exhaust of an engine compared to ambient levels. Also, isoprene, a VOC commonly associated with biogenic emissions, was found in the exhaust, however it was not detected in refuelling emissions. The benzene to toluene ratio was used to discriminate exhaust from refuelling emission. In refuelling emissions, a ratio well below 1 was found, while for exhaust this ratio was usually about 1.7.     

Environmental Protection Agency Announces 1971–72 Chronological Schedule of Training Courses

Following are the chronological dates of course offerings of the Institute for Air Pollution Training, Office of Manpower Development, Environmental Protection Agency.

Courses are offered this Fiscal Year at nine regional centers as well as at the Institute headquarters at Research Triangle Park, North Carolina.

In addition to regular advanced courses offered each year, a three-weeks basic course “Principles and Practice of Air Pollution Control,” Course #452, will be offered nine times each year.     

Aircraft measurement of ozone turbulent flux in the atmospheric boundary layer

In May 1995, the “Chimie-Creil 95” experiment was undertaken in the north of France. The field data are first used to validate the methodology for airborne measurement of ozone flux. A certain number of methodological problems due to the location of the fast ozone sensor inside the airplane are, furthermore discussed. The paper describes the instrumentation of the ARAT (Avion de Recherche Atmosphérique et de Télédétection), an atmospheric research and remote-sensing aircraft used to perform the airborne measurements, the area flown over, the meteorological conditions and boundary layer stability conditions. These aircraft measurements are then used to determine ozone deposition velocity and values are proposed for aerodynamic, bulk transfer coefficients (ozone and momentum). The paper also establishes the relationship between the normalised standard deviation and stability parameters (z/L) for ozone, temperature, humidity and vertical velocity. The laws obtained are then presented.     

Aircraft emissions and local air quality impacts from takeoff activities at a large International Airport

Real time number concentrations and size distributions of ultrafine particles (UFPs, diameter <100 nm) and time integrated black carbon, PM_2.5 mass, and chemical species were studied at the Los Angeles International Airport (LAX) and a background reference site. At LAX, data were collected at the blast fence (∼140 m from the takeoff position) and five downwind sites up to 600 m from the takeoff runway and upwind of the 405 freeway. Size distributions of UFPs collected at the blast fence site showed very high number concentrations, with the highest numbers found at a particle size of approximately 14 nm. The highest spikes in the time series profile of UFP number concentrations were correlated with individual aircraft takeoff. Measurements indicate a more than 100-fold difference in particle number concentrations between the highest spikes during takeoffs and the lowest concentrations when no takeoff is occurring. Total UFP counts exceeded 10⁷ particles cm⁻³ during some monitored takeoffs. Time averaged concentrations of PM_2.5 mass and two carbonyl compounds, formaldehyde and acrolein, were statistically elevated at the airport site relative to a background reference site. Peaks of 15 nm particles, associated with aircraft takeoffs, that occurred at the blast fence were matched with peaks observed 600 m downwind, with time lags of less than 1 min. The results of this study demonstrate that commercial aircraft at LAX emit large quantities of UFP at the lower end of currently measurable particle size ranges. The observed highly elevated UFP concentrations downwind of LAX associated with aircraft takeoff activities have significant exposure and possible health implications.     

Simulating industrial emissions using Atmospheric Dispersion Modeling System: Model performance and source emission factors

In this paper, the Gaussian Atmospheric Dispersion Modeling System (ADMS4) was coupled with field observations of surface meteorology and concentrations of several air quality indicators (nitrogen oxides (NO_X), carbon monoxide (CO), fine particulate matter (PM₁₀) and sulfur dioxide (SO₂)) to test the applicability of source emission factors set by the European Environment Agency (EEA) and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) at an industrial complex. Best emission factors and data groupings based on receptor location, type of terrain and wind speed, were relied upon to examine model performance using statistical analyses of simulated and observed data. The model performance was deemed satisfactory for several scenarios when receptors were located at downwind sites with index of agreement d values reaching 0.58, fractional bias “FB” and geometric mean bias “MG” values approaching 0 and 1, respectively, and normalized mean square error “NMSE” values as low as 2.17. However, median ratios of predicted to observed concentrations “Cp/Co” at variable downstream distances were 0.01, 0.36, 0.76 and 0.19 for NO_X, CO, PM₁₀ and SO₂, respectively, and the fraction of predictions within a factor of two of observations “FAC2” values were lower than 0.5, indicating that the model could not adequately replicate all observed variations in emittant concentrations. Also, the model was found to be significantly sensitive to the input emission factor bringing into light the deficiency in regulatory compliance modeling which often uses internationally reported emission factors without testing their applicability.

Implications In the absence of site-specific source emission factors, the use of internationally reported emission factors without testing their validity may generate significant errors. Instead, recorded field measurements and meteorological data may be combined with atmospheric transport and dispersion models to better estimate source emissions, particularly in regulatory compliance studies. In this context, lower model performance is expected at higher wind speeds for most indicators such as CO, PM₁₀, and SO₂.     

Association between long-term occupational noise exposure and obesity

Noise exposure has been linked to several health outcomes including obesity. This cross-sectional study examined the association between occupational noise exposure and body mass index as a measure of general obesity in 913 textile workers (totally from nine factories) in Yazd city, Iran, from winter to summer of 2018. The sound pressure level (dBA) at each working station was measured by a calibrated sound level meter. The long-term noise exposure score of each worker (as dBA.year) was calculated by multiplying the working history in each unit to its corresponding noise level. Models were adjusted for personal, behavioral, environmental, and family history factors. In total, 81.05% (n?=?740) of the participants were exposed to noise levels higher than 85 dBA. The direct association was found for the fully adjusted model (β?=?0.002; 95% CI: 0.001: 0.004). For the model with past year noise exposure, a 10.6% increase in odds was observed for each 5 dBA increase in noise exposure (95% CI: 1.005: 1.216). We found a 0.1% increase in the odds of being overweight in mixed-gender analysis (95% CI: 1.001:1.002) for each 5 dBA.year in the fully adjusted model. Occupational noise exposure should be regarded as a risk factor for cardiometabolic outcomes in industrial workers.

     

An analysis of continuous black carbon concentrations in proximity to an airport and major roadways

Black carbon (BC), a constituent of particulate matter, is emitted from multiple combustion sources, complicating determination of contributions from individual sources or source categories from monitoring data. In close proximity to an airport, this may include aircraft emissions, other emissions on the airport grounds, and nearby major roadways, and it would be valuable to determine the factors most strongly related to measured BC concentrations. In this study, continuous BC concentrations were measured at five monitoring sites in proximity to a small regional airport in Warwick, Rhode Island from July 2005 to August 2006. Regression was used to model the relative contributions of aircraft and related sources, using real-time flight activity (departures and arrivals) and meteorological data, including mixing height, wind speed and direction. The latter two were included as a nonparametric smooth spatial term using thin-plate splines applied to wind velocity vectors and fit in a linear mixed model framework. Standard errors were computed using a moving-block bootstrap to account for temporal autocorrelation. Results suggest significant positive associations between hourly departures and arrivals at the airport and BC concentrations within the community, with departures having a more substantial impact. Generalized Additive Models for wind speed and direction were consistent with significant contributions from the airport, major highway, and multiple local roads. Additionally, inverse mixing height, temperature, precipitation, and at one location relative humidity, were associated with BC concentrations. Median contribution estimates indicate that aircraft departures and arrivals (and other sources coincident in space and time) contribute to approximately 24–28% of the BC concentrations at the monitoring sites in the community. Our analysis demonstrated that a regression-based approach with detailed meteorological and source characterization can provide insights about source contributions, which could be used to devise control strategies or to provide monitor-based comparisons with source-specific atmospheric dispersion models.     

Real-Time Measurements of Jet Aircraft Engine Exhaust

Abstract

Particulate-phase exhaust properties from two different types of ground-based jet aircraft engines—high-thrust and turboshaft—were studied with real-time instruments on a portable pallet and additional time-integrated sampling devices. The real-time instruments successfully characterized rapidly changing particulate mass, light absorption, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) content. The integrated measurements included particulate-size distributions, PAH, and carbon concentrations for an entire test run (i.e., “run-integrated” measurements). In all cases, the particle-size distributions showed single modes peaking at 20–40nm diameter. Measurements of exhaust from high-thrust F404 engines showed relatively low-light absorption compared with exhaust from a turboshaft engine. Particulate-phase PAH measurements generally varied in phase with both net particulate mass and with light-absorbing particulate concentrations. Unexplained response behavior sometimes occurred with the real-time PAH analyzer, although on average the real-time and integrated PAH methods agreed within the same order of magnitude found in earlier investigations.     

Impact of roadside noise barriers on particle size distributions and pollutants concentrations near freeways

Increasing epidemiological evidence has established an association between a host of adverse health effects and exposure to ambient particulate matter (PM) and co-pollutants, especially those emitted from motor vehicles. Although PM and their co-pollutants dispersion profiles near the open freeway have been extensively characterized by means of both experimental measurements and numerical simulations in recent years, such investigations near freeways with roadside barriers have not been well documented in the literature. A few previous studies suggested that the presence of roadside structures, such as noise barriers and vegetation, may impact the decay of pollutant concentrations downwind of the freeway by limiting the initial dispersion of traffic emissions and increasing their vertical mixing due to the upward deflection of airflow. Since the noise barriers are now common roadside features of the freeways, particularly those running through populated urban areas, it is pertinent to investigate the impact of their presence on the particles and co-pollutants concentrations in areas adjacent to busy roadways. This study investigated two highly trafficked freeways (I-710 and I-5) in Southern California, with two sampling sites for each freeway, one with and the other without the roadside noise barriers. Particle size distributions and co-pollutants concentrations were measured in the immediate proximity of freeways and at different distances downwind of the freeways. The results showed the formation of a “concentration deficit” zone in the immediate vicinity of the freeway with the presence of roadside noise barrier, followed by a surge of pollutant concentrations further downwind at 80–100 m away from freeway. The particle and co-pollutants concentrations reach background levels at farther distances of 250–400 m compared to 150–200 m at the sites without roadside noise barriers.     

An Emission Sampling Probe Installed,Operated, and Retrieved from Ground Level

The “Teepee” type wood residue incinerator, similar to many other sources, requires sampling at the point where the emissions enter the atmosphere. Because the location of the emission point is hazardous and unpleasant for the operation of a sampling probe, a portable, tilt-up column was developed which permitted installation, operation, and retrieval of the sampling train from ground level. The sampling train developed permitted determination of the size distribution and weight of the particulate emitted by this highly variable source.