Acid and aluminum effects on freshwater zooplankton: an in situ Mesocosm study

An in situ mesocosm experiment was performed to evaluate the role of aluminum toxicity in determining zooplankton community responses to take acidification. Large plastic enclosures were suspended in East Twin Lake, Ohio, USA, and duplicates were either untreated controls (pH 8.8), acidified to pH 4.5 over a 23 day period, or acidified and also spiked with incremental additions of Al, to produce a final inorganic monomeric Al level of 180 microg/liter at pH 4.5. Zooplankton abundance and species richness declined in both acid treatments, relative to the control, as numerous acid-sensitive species were eliminated. All of the acid-sensitive species were also Al-sensitive, declining in abundance more rapidly in the acid plus Al treatment than in the acid-alone treatment. Only two small cladocerans (Bosmina longirostris and Chydorus sphaericus) were acid tolerant. Both were also tolerant of elevated Al levels.     

Acid and aluminum effects on the survival of littoral macro-invertebrates during acute bioassays

Six common macro-invertebrates were exposed to soft water at pH 4.5, with or without 200 microg liter(-1) Al added. Survivals were determined at 6, 12, 24 and 48 h and compared with neutral pH, Al-free controls. The order of acid-sensitivity among the test animals, from greatest to least (with mean 24/48 h survivals in the pH 4.5, low Al treatment in parentheses), was: Caenis sp. (2%) > Hyalella azteca (12%) > Enallagma sp. (20%) > Gyraulus sp. (55%) > Chironomidae (94%) > Hydracarina (99%). Aluminum significantly reduced the survivals of Gyraulus, Hyalella and Chironomidae. The latter group experienced no significant mortality at pH 4.5 except when Al was present. In contrast, the Hydracarina were unaffected by both acid and acid plus Al exposure, and the survivals of Enallagma and Caenis at low pH were enhanced by Al. These differential responses to the treatments indicate that both acid and Al stress may control the structure of the littoral macroinvertebrate community in acid lakes.     

Mortality, growth, swimming activity and gill morphology of brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) and Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) exposed to low pH with and without aluminum

Measurements were made of mortality, growth, swimming activity, and gill morphology of young-of-the-year brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) and Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar), exposed for 30 days to pH 5.6 +/- 0.5 (mean +/- 1 standard deviation) with and without addition of 107 +/- 57 microg liter(-1) exchangeable (labile monomeric) aluminum. The experiment was conducted in artificial stream channels adjacent to a natural stream and subject to daily and seasonal changes in temperature, light, and chemical conditions. There were no differences in survival or growth for brook trout in any treatment; Atlantic salmon survival and growth were significantly decreased in the acid + Al treatment. Scanning electron microscopy showed no damage to gills of either species in the acid treatments, but the acid + Al treatment caused slight swelling of brook trout gills near the filament tips and significant swelling and fusion of secondary lamellae of Atlantic salmon gills. The acid treatment increased swimming activity in brook trout, but both the acid and acid + Al treatments reduced activity in Atlantic salmon.     

Chemical and biological effects of acid, aluminium and lime additions to a Welsh Hill-stream

Chemical and biological responses to simultaneous additions of acid, aluminium and lime were investigated in contiguous 250m-reaches of a chronically acidic stream in Wales. Treatments were applied for 24 h, and from the upstream end were as follows: zone A-untreated, pH 5.0, 0.37 mg litre(-1) filterable Al; zone B-acidified to pH 4.5, 0.40 mg Al litre(-1) (47% of Al attributed to release from the stream bed due to acid additions); zone C-acidified to pH 4.5 and Al dosed to 0.67 mg litre(-1); zone D-dosed with limestone slurry, resulting in pH 7.2, 0.13 mg Al litre(-1). In all reaches, the chemistry of the interstitial water at depths of 0.15 and 0.3 m never fell below pH 5.5, with corresponding decreases in Al and increases in base cation concentrations. Brown trout, Salmo trutta, and crayfish, Austropotamobius pallipes, held in the stream showed decreases in plasma [Na(+)] and haemolymph [Na(+)], respectively, in all acidic zones (A, B, C): these responses were mitigated by liming (zone D). Thus both chronic and simulated episodic levels of pH and dissolved Al were sub-lethally toxic to test species of aquatic fauna. This experiment also demonstrates a stream bed source/sink of Al, and the availability of a possible refuge from acidic surface waters within the substratum.     

Biochemical responses of the mycorrhizae in Pinus massoniana to combined effects of Al, Ca and low pH

Biochemical responses of Pinus massoniana, with and without the inoculation mycorrhizal fungus Pisolithus tinctorius at the root, to artificial acid rain (pH 2.0) and various Ca/Al ratios were investigated. Some enzymes associated with the nutritive metabolism, such as acid phosphatase, alkaline phosphatase, nitrate reductase, mannitol dehydrogenase and trehalase, in the roots, stems and leaves of plant were obviously inhibited by the artificial acid rain and Al. After treatment with pH 2.0 + Ca/Al (0/1 or 1/10) artificial acid rain, the protein content in the organs was decreased. However, the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and peroxidase (POD) and glutathione (GSH) concentrations were induced. It demonstrated that acid rain and Al could induce oxygen radicals in plant. Compared with the treatments with lower pH or Al, respectively, the combination of lower pH and Al concentration was more toxic to P. massoniana. Al toxicity could be ameliorated by the addition of Ca and the amelioration was the most when the ratio was 1/1 among the various Ca/Al ratio. Infection with mycorrhizal fungus P. tinctorius at the root of P. massoniana increased the ability of the plant to resist the toxicity of artificial acid rain and Al stress.     

Phytoplankton succession during acidification with and without increasing aluminum levels

An in situ mesocosm experiment was performed to investigate the role of aluminum in controlling phytoplankton community succession during lake acidification. Large (2000 liter) mesocosms were suspended in mesotrophic East Twin Lake, Ohio, USA. Duplicates were either untreated controls (pH 8.8), acidified to pH 4.5 over 23 days, or acidified and spiked with 200 microg/liter Al in incremental additions. Filamentous blue greens, diatoms and other chrysophytes became extinct in both acid treatments, but declined most rapidly where Al levels were also increased. The large desmid Closterium and the filamentous chlorophyte Mougoetia became dominant in the Acid treatment. In the Acid + Al treatment, these algae also became dominant, but the species with greatest biomass was the dinoflagellate Peridinium inconspicuum. Acidification (with or without added Al) also resulted in a significant shift in the algal size spectrum to larger (> 20 microm) cells.     

Effects of repeated application of carbaryl on zooplankton communities in experimental ponds with or without the predator Chaoborus

Zooplankton communities with or without Chaoborus larvae were established in outdoor experimental ponds, to which the insecticide carbaryl was applied repeatedly at 10 or 100 microg litre(-1). In the ponds without Chaoborus, Cladocera dominated, but the species composition differed among the treatments. A large-sized Cladocera Daphnia galeata dominated the controls, the medium-sized cladocerans Diaphanosoma brachyurum and Moina micrura became dominant in the low-dose treatment, and the small-sized Bosmina fatalis increased in the high-dose treatment. These results indicated differential sensitivity to carbaryl among the cladocerans, and that smaller Cladocera were more tolerant of the chemical than the larger one. In the ponds with Chaoborus, rotifers dominated the zooplankton, probably because Chaoborus released rotifers from competition with cladocerans and calanoid copepods, which were eliminated by the Chaoborus predation. No effects of low-dose carbaryl treatment were detected on zooplankton communities in the Chaoborus ponds. The dominance by rotifers, organisms tolerant to carbaryl, minimized the effects. Thus, Chaoborus altered the zooplankton community responses to the chemical application by changing community structure. Repeated application of high-dose carbaryl did affect the rotifer community, decreasing the dominance of Polyarthra trigla and increasing that of Keratella valga. These rotifer species may differ in their sensitivity to carbaryl.     

Complex biological responses to the experimental acidification of Little Rock Lake, Wisconsin, USA

Acidification can affect aquatic organisms directly through hydrogen ion toxicity, and indirectly through disrupted food web dynamics and altered abiotic conditions. Field populations from selected taxa were studied during the Little Rock Lake whole-basin acidification experiment to illustrate patterns whose timing suggests direct (i.e. immediate) or indirect (i.e. delayed or non-uniform) responses to pH change. As the treatment basin was acidified to pH 5.6, 5.2 and 4.7, immediate changes consistent with a direct pH response were observed for species representing several trophic levels. For other taxa (e.g. littoral invertebrates associated with filamentous algal mats, several species of pelagic zooplankton), indirect mechanisms induced by food web changes were more likely explanations for abundance patterns. The results presented here suggest that the responses of aquatic ecosystems to acidification involve a complex interplay between direct pH effects and subsequent indirect interactions.     

Growth responses of birch and Sitka spruce exposed to acidified rain

Seedlings of birch and Sitka spruce were grown on a range of British soils for 2 years and exposed to simulated acid rainfall treatments of pHs 5.6, 4.5, 3.5 and 2.5. Both species developed visible leaf injury patterns when exposed to the pH 2.5 treatment. In Sitka spruce this leaf injury was followed by high needle loss during the first winter and greater mortality. Generally, height growth of Sitka spruce was unaffected by treatments, but acid rainfall at pH 2.5 increased the height of birch. Mean height of both species was strongly affected by soil type. Significant soils x treatment effects on the heights of both species indicated that on some soils plant growth responses to the treatments did not fit the general pattern. Hence, while the results indicate that generally ambient acidities of rainfall in the UK are unlikely to adversely affect the growth of birch or Sitka spruce, plants growing on some soils may be susceptible to injury.     

Changes in gill morphology of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) smolts due to addition of acid and aluminum to stream water

One-year-old Atlantic salmon smolts were held in three artificial channels adjacent to a softwater (mean sp. cond. 30 microS cm(-1), circumneutral stream. Water in one channel was untreated (mean pH 6.25); the others received additions of acid (to mean pH 5.6), or acid plus aluminum (to mean pH 5.5; mean exchangeable Al 158 microg litre(-1)). Gills were sampled after 16 and 23 days of exposure for morphometric examination. On primary lamellae, chloride cells were more numerous in both experimental treatments than in controls. In contrast, numbers of chloride cells on secondary lamellae were elevated only in fish exposed to acid without added Al. Chloride cell size and shape also varied with time and treatment. Fewer gill mucous cells were found in fish exposed to acid plus Al than in controls. Chloride cell proliferation and structural changes may represent an attempt to compensate for increased ionic effluxes with low pH stress by increasing uptake. However, if Al concentrations are high, chloride cells do not proliferate along the secondary lamellae, or proliferating cells are damaged and lost. This may limit the potential to increase ionic uptake.     

Effects of organic fertilizers on soil physicochemistry and on the yield and botanical composition of forage over 3 years

Organic wastes have been reported to reduce saturation of the exchange complex by Al in Al-rich acid soils. For 3 years, the main soil fertility properties were studied in plots sown with mixed pasture species. These plots were fertilized with cattle slurry, dairy sludge (DS), or granulated broiler litter (BL) in comparison with mineral fertilizer. Al saturation levels were low after the initial inorganic liming treatment (19.00-33.71%) but tended to rise under all treatments (21.09-61.37%) except BL (8.45-30.98%), which was also associated with the highest average soil pH and the highest average levels of exchangeable Ca2+, Mg2+, and K+. Treatment DS performed similarly to mineral fertilizer in most respects, but it led to greater available P levels. Under the dry conditions of the second and third years of the study, BL and DS treatments were associated with significantly greater forage yields than the other treatments. Under DS treatment, available P levels were too low to allow the maintenance of mixed pasture, clover being eliminated by the less P-dependent species.     

Ammonia effects on microinvertebrates and fish in outdoor experimental streams

Laboratory data on ammonia effects, the US EPA national water quality criteria for ammonia, and ammonia site-specific criteria were evaluated in four outdoor experimental streams (one control and three treatment streams) over a 76-week period. Calculated un-ionised ammonia concentrations varied daily and seasonally according to pH and temperature changes. Populations of four major microinvertebrate taxonomic groups (cladocerans, copepods, rotifers and protozoans) were monitored during a 4-week period early in the study, and six fish species (fathead minnows, bluegills, channel catfish, white suckers, walleyes, and rainbow trout) were tested for various time intervals, from 4 to 26 weeks, throughout the 76-week study period. Copepods and rotifers were unaffected in all three treatment streams, based on comparisons with the control stream. Cladoceran and protozoan populations were reduced in at least two treatment streams, but because of large variability, effects were considered to be inconclusive. However, complete mortality of cladocerans did occur in the high and medium treatments when placed in in situ biomonitor chambers. All six fish species were affected in one or more treatments. Generally, the fish effect values agreed with most laboratory effect values. Of 12 fish groups tested, one channel catfish group and one white sucker group were affected below the recommended protection levels of the national and site-specific criteria. The lowest effect concentrations tested for the other ten groups occurred above the criteria levels.     

The effects of simulated acid rain on the growth of three herbaceous species grown on a range of British soils

Seedlings of winter barley, perennial ryegrass and white clover were grown on a range of British soils for 21-24 weeks and exposed to simulated acid rainfall treatments of pHs 5.6, 4.5, 3.5 and 2.5. Whilst leaves of white clover developed leaf lesions after 18 weeks of exposure to the pH 2.5 treatments, there were no signs of visible injury to the other two species. At harvest, it was noted, for all species, that there was a large amount of variation in the sizes of individual plants and this made it difficult to detect differences between the treatments for plants on an individual soil. However, in combined analyses for all soils, it was found that the treatments had substantial effects on the yields of plants. The yields of both winter barley and clover were highly correlated with rainfall pH, showing substantial reductions in the more acid rains as compared to the pH 5.6 (control) treatment. In contrast, plants of perennial ryegrass produced higher yields of shoots at the most acid (pH 2.5) as compared to the other treatments. It was noted that the pH 2.5 treatment resulted in a generally lower soil pH at the termination of the experiment.     

Short-term physiological responses to a severe acid stress in three macroinvertebrate species: a comparative study

The present study focuses on the sensitivity among freshwater invertebrate species to acidic stress. Three common macroinvertebrate species in the Vosges Mountains (North-Eastern France), Gammarus fossarum (Amphipoda), Hydropsyche pellucidula (Trichoptera) and Dinocras cephalotes (Plecoptera) were exposed for 24, 72 and 120 h to natural acidified water (pH=4.73+/-0.08, [Ca2+]=39.1+/-0.6 micromol l(-1), [Al(tot)]=28.4+/-1 micromol l(-1)). Short-term exposure to acid stress caused significant decreases both in survival rate and haemolymph ions ([Cl-] and [Na+]). The relative sensitivity to a natural acidic stress slightly differed among the species and was in the following order: G. fossarum, as the most sensitive, then H. pellucidula and D. cephalotes. Results of this study confirm the interest of in situ tests to assess the toxicity of short-term acid exposure. Finally, our results reinforce the hypothesis that transient acidification can offset the recovery of sensitive species of macroinvertebrates in streams chemically recovering from acidification either through liming or declining deposition.     

Aluminum binding to ion exchange sites in acid-sensitive versus acid-tolerant cladocerans

Two acid-sensitive cladocerans, Daphnia galeata mendotae and D. retrocurva, and one acid-tolerant one, Bosmina longirostris, were exposed for 24 h to pH 5.0 and 200 microg liter(-1) total Al. The entire procedure was replicated on three dates in summer 1989. Mortality rates were determined, and the extent of Al binding to ion exchange sites determined using hematoxylin staining. Both daphnids consistently experienced near 100% mortalities, while mortalities for B. longirostris were always near zero. The daphnids showed marked Al binding at the maxillary glands, the site of ion exchange, while B. longirostris showed no noticeable Al binding.     

Biomonitoring of sporadic acidification of rivers on the basis of release of preloaded cadmium from the aquatic bryophyte Fontinalis antipyretica Hedw

A technique is proposed for biomonitoring of sporadic acidification events in rivers. Individuals of the bioindicator species are pre-incubated with a chemical marker, then transplanted to the test location for the period of interest, then analysed for marker content; acidification events are inferred on the basis of the degree of reduction in marker concentration. To assess the validity of the proposed technique, we performed laboratory trials with the aquatic bryophyte Fontinalis antipyretica Hedw. as bioindicator species, and cadmium (Cd) as marker. The bryophytes were pre-incubated with a Cd solution, obtaining saturation concentrations in the extracellular compartment and near-saturation concentrations in the intracellular compartment. In a first series of experiments, Cd-preloaded bryophyte apices were maintained for 1-30 h in water of different pH; the results clearly indicated that the amount of Cd released is dependent on pH. In a second series of experiments, Cd-preloaded bryophyte apices were maintained for 1-24 h in water with various combinations of pH and aluminium (Al) concentration (Al being a highly toxic element that is typically mobilized in acid waters). In these experiments, pH again had a marked effect on the amount of Cd released, while Al concentration had no consistent effects. To facilitate data analysis, Davidson-type equations were fitted to the results of the second series of experiments, allowing prediction of medium acidity on the basis of Cd concentration remaining in the extracellular and intracellular compartments.     

Effects of acidic solutions on element dynamics in the monsoon evergreen broad-leaved forest at Dinghushan,China

BACKGROUND: Soil metal dynamics are affected by acid deposition. Little knowledge is available about the process in the lateritic soils under the monsoon forest in south China. METHODS: Samplings of Acmera acuminatissima, Cryptocarya concinna and Schima superba were grown from October, 2000 to July, 2002 in pots with a natural acid lateritic forest soil from Dinghushan. Pots were watered weekly with an acid solution (pH 3.05, 3.52, 4.00 or 4.40) or with tap water. Fe, Mn, Cu and Al were measured in soils, leachates and sapling leaves. RESULTS: Soil extractable Fe and leachate Al and Mn concentrations increased with a decreasing treatment pH. Soil reactive Al exhibited the opposite trend and decreased over time. The Ca/Al and Mg/ (Al+Mn) ratios did not decrease in the leaves of Schima superba, but decreased with a decreasing treatment pH for Cryptocaria concinna. Both ratios only decreased in the pH 3.05 treatment for Acmena CONCLUSIONS: Cu will not be toxic for plants since soil extractable Cu was not high and Fe will not be toxic either given that its root uptake was inhibited by Mn. Acid rains will lead to increased Mn and Al mobility in soil. Cryptocaria concinna will be the most sensible species to these changes (nutrient deficiency and direct Mn toxicity), while Schima superba should retain a good growth.     

Effects of acid rain on growth and nutrient concentrations in Scots pine and Norway spruce seedlings grown in a nutrient-rich soil

The effects of artificially applied acid precipitation on growth and nutrient concentrations of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) and Norway spruce (Picea abies [L.] Karst.) seedlings were investigated in a long-term acid irrigation experiment in field conditions. Seedlings of northern and southern origin were planted in boxes containing peat and composted soil rich in nutrients, and sprinkler irrigated with water acidified with nitric and sulphuric acids to pH 3 or pH 4 for periods varying from two to three and a half growing seasons during 1986-1989. Water irrigated (pH 5.4-7.6) and non-irrigated groups of seedlings were also included in the experiment. At the end of the experiment needles, main and lateral shoots and roots were collected from the seedlings for the determination of height growth and biomass partitioning, and for the analysis of S, N, Mg, P, K, Ca, Mn and Fe concentrations. The treatment effects compared to the irrigated control were studied using multivariate analyses of variance and covariance. In the pine seedlings the total dry matter production increased by 25-70% compared with the irrigated controls when the total wet deposition to the seedlings exceeded 67 kg S ha(-1) and 36 kg N ha(-1) (e.g. after two growing seasons' exposure of the pH 3 treatment). The increase was mainly due to an increase in needle dry weight (54-72% greater at pH 3) and root weight (20-65% greater at pH 3), whereas the height growth or shoot weight growth were less affected. The northern provenance pine seedlings responded more clearly to the pH 3 irrigation than the southern ones. The treatments had no consistent effects on any of the growth variables studied in the spruce seedlings, however. The pines had higher root and foliage Ca concentrations as a result of the acid irrigation, whereas in spruce, acid rain decreased the Ca concentration in needles and shoots. Root Mn and Fe concentrations were higher in both species as a result of the pH 3 treatment. A higher soil conductivity and Ca concentration resulted from the prolonged pH 3 treatment. The results strongly support the hypothesis that the long-term growth and nutrient allocation response of conifers to acid precipitation is dependent both on the tree species and on the nutritional status of the soil.     

Changes in trace metal concentrations in lake water and biota during experimental acidification of Little Rock Lake, Wisconsin, USA

Little Rock Lake, a small (18 ha), low-alkalinity (25 microeq litre(-1), pH 6.1) seepage lake in northern Wisconsin, was divided into two basins by a flexible, inert barrier and, beginning in spring 1985, the north basin was acidified in three 2-year steps to pH 5.6, 5.1 and 4.7. The annual average pH of the reference basin remained near 6.1. As part of a comprehensive programme to determine the chemical and biological responses to acidification, minor metals (Al, Fe, Mn) and trace metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn) in lake water (0.4 microm pore filtered samples), periphyton, zooplankton, and yellow perch (Perca flavescens) were measured. At pH 5.6, dissolved Mn and Fe increased in the acidified basin. At pH 5.1 and 4.7, dissolved Al, Fe, Mn, Cd and Zn were elevated in the acidified basin. At pH 4.7, dissolved Pb in the acidified basin became elevated over reference basin levels. Dissolved Cu remained similar in both basins down to pH 4.7. Cd burdens in periphyton collected on artificial substrates were lower in the treatment basin at pH 5.1 (1.8 microg g(-1) dry wt.) than in the reference basin at pH 6.1 (7.5 microg g(-1) dry wt.), but Al and Fe burdens in periphyton were similar in both basins. Likewise, Cd levels in muscle tissue of perch from the treatment basin at pH 4.7 were lower (26 ng g(-1) dry wt.) than in the reference basin at pH 6.1 (36 ng g(-1) dry wt.); Al and Fe burdens were similar in perch muscle tissue from both basins. Levels of Cd and Fe in zooplankton from the acidified basin at pH 4.7 were approximately equal to 2x higher than in animals from the reference basin. In both basins of the lake, Al and Cd levels in lake biota decreased with increasing trophic level, demonstrating that food chain biomagnification does not occur for these metals.     

Influence of some additives to aluminium species distribution in aluminium coagulants

Aluminium ions hydrolyse and polymerise into different species in water. Main aluminium species in aluminium coagulant solutions are monomeric Al species (Al1) and polymeric Al species Al13O4(OH)24(7+) (Al13). The aluminium species distribution in coagulant solutions can be influenced by many parameters. This paper studies influences of concentrations of total aluminium species (Al(t)) and other species--OH-, polysilicic acid and ferric species, which were added in aluminium coagulant solutions, on the aluminium species distribution through 27Al nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis. Results show that only Al1 and no Al13 exist in coagulant solutions at higher Al(t) concentrations (over 1 mol l(-1)), while both species exist at lower Al(t) concentrations (0.1 mol l(-1)). The increase of OH/Al value (molar ratio) increases the concentration of Al13 in coagulant solutions, while the addition of polysilicic acid and ferric species decreases the concentration of Al13.