Environmental Irradiation Test Facility

Results from a detailed analysis of sulfur dioxide (SO₂) reductions achievable through “deep” physical coal cleaning (PCC) at 20 coal-fired power plants in the Ohio-Indiana-Illinois region are presented here. These plants all have capacities larger than 500 MWe, are currently without any flue gas desulfurization (FGD) systems, and burn coal of greater than l%sulfur content (in 1980). Their aggregate emissions of 2.4 million tons of SO₂ per year represents 55% of the SO₂ inventory for these states. The principal coal supplies for each power plant were identified and characterized as to coal seam and county of origin, so that published coal-washability data could be matched to each supplier. The SO₂ reductions that would result from deep cleaning each coal (Level 4) were calculated using an Argonne computer model that assumes a weight recovery of 80%. Percentage reductions in sulfur content ranged from zero to 52%, with a mean value of 29%, and costs ranged from a low of $364/ton SO₂ removed to over $2000/ton SO₂ removed. Because coal suppliers to these power plants employ some voluntary coal cleaning, the anticipated emissions reduction from current levels should be near 20%. Costs then were estimated for FGD systems designed to remove the same amount of SO₂ as was achieved by PCC through the use of partial scrubbing with bypass of the remaining flue gas. On this basis, PCC was more cost-effective than FGD for about 50% of the plants studied and had comparable costs for another 25% of the plants. Possible governmental actions to either encourage or mandate coal cleaning were identified and evaluated     

Asbestos: Rationale Behind A Proposed Air Quality Standard

A computerized simulation model has been developed to compute energy requirements of a limestone slurry flue gas desulfurization (FGD) system as a function of FGD system design parameters, power plant characteristics, coal properties, and sulfur dioxide emission regulation. Results are illustrated for a "base case" plant of 500 MW, burning 3.5% sulfur coal, meeting the federal new source performance standard of 1.2 lb SO₂/10⁶ Btu. The flue gas is cleaned by an electrostatic precipitator followed by a limestone FGD system with a TCA scrubbing vessel and an optimized in-line steam reheater. The total FGD system energy requirement for this case was found to be 3.4% of the total energy input to the boiler. Sensitivity analyses were then performed in which the nominal values of ten system parameters were individually varied. This caused the total FGD system energy requirement to vary between 2.5 % and 6.1 % of the gross plant output for the range of parameters tested. The most sensitive parameters were found to be scrubbing slurry pH, which affects pumping requirements, and stack gas exit temperature, which affects reheat requirements. In all cases, FGD energy requirements were minimized when the SO₂ emission standard was met by partially bypassing the scrubber. In light of the recent Clean Air Act Amendments this option may not be feasible in the future.     

Transferable Discharge Permits for Control of SO2 Emissions from Illinois Power Plants

A large scale simulation model was employed in evaluating various policy alternatives for reducing SO₂ emissions from Illinois electric power plants for a broad range of nuclear power capacity addition scenarios. A dynamic simulation of a transferable discharge permit (TDP) program suggests a market oriented management system can assure an acceptable level of environmental quality while achieving typical cost savings of 40-60 percent over a program based on uniform decreases in existing emission standards. This cost advantage can be realized without any major decline in the demand for coal generally or indigenous coals in particular. Several options for initiating the TDP market are evaluated. The analysis concludes that initiating the market by government sales may not constitute a major financial burden on the electric utilities or their customers.     

A Computer Plot for a High Temperature Psychrometric Chart

This paper presents results of multivariate regression models developed to estimate the properties and cost of U.S. coals washed for varying degrees of sulfur removal using commercially available physical coal preparation processes. The models allow washed coal characteristics to be predicted from information on coal origin, heating value, ash, and sulfur content. The models were developed by first "processing" each of the 710 coals in the U.S. Bureau of Mines (USBM) coal washability data base through a coal preparation plant computer model which optimizes plant performance to achieve a desired washed coal quality. Washability data are adjusted to account for the inefficiencies of coal washing equipment, and the actual coal sizes treated by various plant wash streams. Since different plant designs may be capable of achieving a given level of sulfur removal, three nominal levels of plant complexity (Levels 2, 3, 4) were included to identify the most economical alternative. The washed coal characteristics thus derived were then analyzed using standard statistical techniques to develop regression equations linking washed coal properties and cost to raw coal properties for each of 18 geographical regions encompassing the entire U.S. These regression models are incorporated in the Advanced Utility Simulation Model (AUSM) to estimate the economic potential of coal washing as a sulfur abatement strategy, in conjunction with other options available to coal-fired power plants. Modeling results for Pennsylvania showed that washed coals frequently were selected as part of a cost-effective control strategy, accounting for 10 to 30 percent of the total emissions reduction, and that "local coal" restrictions significantly increase the use of washed coal as an SO₂ control strategy. Hypothetical requirements for mandatory coal cleaning, however, were found to be costly and ineffective.     

Assessment of Dry Sorbent Emission Control Technologies Part I. Fundamental Processes

The utility and industrial sectors continue to come under pressure from both national and local regulatory groups to reduce sulfur dioxide emissions. With a trend in the utility industry for life extension, retrofit technologies are likely to play an important role in any SO₂ emission reduction strategy. Potential retrofit technologies include, singly and in combination: coal switching or cleaning, wet or dry FGD, conversion to fluidized bed, and dry sorbent injection. The diversity within the utility industry in terms of unit size, unit age, fuel use, financial base, and geographic location dictates the need for a variety of technologies to address SO₂ emission control. Dry injection processes involving the injection of dry powders into either the furnace or post-furnace region offer the potential for low capital cost retrofitable technologies. However, compared to wet FGD processes, the dry calcium based processes will likely have lower SO₂ removal efficiencies and may pose more plant-wide integration issues that need to be addressed from both an applications and R&D perspective.

This paper provides a critical assessment of dry injection technologies, in two parts. Part 1 focuses on sorbent processes and science. An assessment of the different dry sorbent processes and the effect of process parameters is provided. Emphasis is placed on process limitations and potential avenues to enhance SO₂ removal. Part 2 will deal with applications of the technology, addressing cost, scale-up, and integration issues.

Much of the data included in this paper was presented at the 1986 Joint Symposium on Dry SO₂ and Simultaneous SO₂/NO_x Control Technologies, sponsored by the Electric Power Research Institute and the Environmental Protection Agency and held in June 1986. This paper provides both an overview and an evaluation of the technology, based largely on our analysis of the data and interpretations discussed at this symposium.     

Supply Curves for Using Powder River Basin Coal to Reduce Sulfur Emissions

Abstract

Supply curves were prepared for coal-fired power plants in the contiguous United States switching to Wyoming's Powder River Basin (PRB) low-sulfur coal. Up to 625 plants, representing ～44% of the nameplate capacity of all coal-fired plants, could switch. If all switched, more than $8.8 billion additional capital would be required and the cost of electricity would increase by up to $5.9 billion per year, depending on levels of plant derating. Coal switching would result in sulfur dioxide (SO₂) emissions reduction of 4.5 million t/yr. Increase in cost of electricity would be in the range of 0.31-0.73 cents per kilowatt-hour. Average cost of S emissions reduction could be as high as $1298 per t of SO₂. Up to 367 plants, or 59% of selected plants with 32% of 44% nameplate capacity, could have marginal cost in excess of $1000 per t of SO₂. Up to 73 plants would appear to benefit from both a lowering of the annual cost and a lowering of SO₂ emissions by switching to the PRB coal.     

Development of Federal Air Standards to Reduce Sulfur Dioxide Emissions from New Industrial Boilers

Federal new source performance standards to control air emissions of sulfur dioxide from new industrial boilers were proposed by EPA on June 19, 1986. These standards would require boiler owners to reduce SO₂ emissions by 90 percent and meet an emission limit of 1.2 lb/MM Btu of heat input for coal-fired boilers and 0.8 lb/MM Btu for oil-fired boilers. In developing these standards, several regulatory options were considered, from standards that could be met by firing low sulfur fuels to standards that would necessitate flue gas treatment. The environmental, economic, and cost impacts of each option were analyzed. National impacts were estimated by a computer model that projects the population of new boilers over the 5-year period following proposal, predicts the compliance strategy that will be used to comply with the particular option (always assuming that the lowest cost method of compliance will be selected), and estimates the resulting emission reductions and costs. Impacts on specific industries and on model boilers were also analyzed. This paper focuses on these analyses and their results. The Agency's conclusions from these analyses, which led to the decision to establish percent reduction standards, are provided, and the proposed SO₂ standards are summarized. The proposed standards also include an emission limit for particulate matter from oil-fired boilers (0.1 lb/MM Btu). However, this article focuses only on the SO₂ standards.     

Advanced Concepts in FGD Technology: The SHU Process with Cooling Tower Discharge

The growing awareness of ecological issues in Europe, reinforced by the public debate surrounding acid rain, has led to the enactment of laws and regulations in West Germany relating to emissions from large coal fired combustors.

Flue gas desulfurization (FGD) units have been compulsory for new coal fired power plants in West Germany for about 12 years. The new legislation enacted in 1983, to be met by the middle of 1988, applies not only to new plants but, unlike in the United States, also to. existing power plants (>30MW).

The law currently specifies a residual SO2 emission level of 400 mg/Nm³ (0.311b MM/BTU) for large power plants (>100 MW), but a level of 200 mg/Nm³ (0.15 lb MM/BTU) is already under discussion in some cases. The legally binding emission standards stipulate that none of the daily averages, calculated on the basis of half hour averages may exceed the concentration allowed. SO2 removal efficiencies of 90 percent to 95 percent are normally provided. Since 1983, more than 35,000 MW of retrofit FGD units have been installed in Germany to meet this SO₂ standard.

The regulations also do not allow for the ponding of calcium sulfite scrubber sludge, but stipulate the production of gypsum from limestone slurry processes. Additionally the regulations require flue gases to have a minimum temperature in the stack of 72° C (162°F) after desulfurization. Treated flue gases do not have to be reheated if discharged via a cooling tower.     

Emissions of Sulfur Trioxide from Coal-Fired Power Plants

Abstract

Emissions of sulfur trioxide (SO₃) are a key component of plume opacity and acid deposition. Consequently, these emissions need to be low enough to not cause opacity violations and acid deposition. Generally, a small fraction of sulfur (S) in coal is converted to SO₃ in coal-fired combustion devices such as electric utility boilers. The emissions of SO₃ from such a boiler depend on coal S content, combustion conditions, flue gas characteristics, and air pollution devices being used. It is well known that the catalyst used in the selective catalytic reduction (SCR) technology for nitrogen oxides control oxidizes a small fraction of sulfur dioxide in the flue gas to SO₃. The extent of this oxidation depends on the catalyst formulation and SCR operating conditions. Gas-phase SO₃ and sulfuric acid, on being quenched in plant equipment (e.g., air preheater and wet scrubber), result in fine acidic mist, which can cause increased plume opacity and undesirable emissions. Recently, such effects have been observed at plants firing high-S coal and equipped with SCR systems and wet scrubbers. This paper investigates the factors that affect acidic mist production in coal-fired electric utility boilers and discusses approaches for mitigating emission of this mist.     

Investigation of aerosol and gas emissions from a coal-fired power plant under various operating conditions

The concentrations of fine particles and selected gas pollutants in the flue gas entering the stack were measured under several common operation modes in an operating coal power plant producing electricity. Particle size distributions in a diameter range from 10 nm to 20 μm were measured by a scanning mobility particle sizer (SMPS), and the flue gas temperature and concentrations of CO₂ and SO₂ were monitored by a continuous emission monitoring system (CEMS). During the test campaign, five plant operating modes were studied: soot blowing, bypass of flue-gas desulfurization (FGD), reheat burner operating at 0% (turned off), 27%, and 42% (normal condition) of its full capacity. For wet and dry aerosols, the measured mode sizes were both around 40 nm, but remarkable differences were observed in the number concentrations (#/cm³, count per square centimeter). A prototype photoionizer enhanced electrostatic precipitator (ESP) showed improved removal efficiency of wet particles at voltages above +11.0 kV. Soot blowing and FGD bypass both increased the total particle number concentration in the flue gas. The temperature was slightly increased by the FGD bypass mode and varied significantly as the rating of reheat burner changed. The variations of CO₂ and SO₂ emissions showed correlations with the trend of total particle number concentration possibly due to the transitions between gas and particle phases. The results are useful in developing coal-fired power plant operation strategies to control fine particle emissions and developing amine-based CO₂ capture technologies without operating and environmental concerns associated with volatile amine emissions.

Implications: The measurement of the fine particle size distributions in the exhaust gas under several common operating conditions of a coal-fired power plant revealed different response relations between aerosol number concentration and the operating condition. A photo-ionizer enhanced ESP was demonstrated to capture fine particles with higher efficiency compared to conventional ESPs, and the removal efficiency increased with the applied voltage. The characteristic information of aerosols and main gaseous pollutants in the exhaust gas is extremely important for developing and deploying CO₂ scrubbers, whose amine emissions and operating effectiveness depends greatly on the upstream concentrations of fine particles, SO₂, from the power plant.     

Flue Gas Desulfurization: The State of the Art

ABSTRACT

Coal-fired electricity-generating plants may use SO₂ scrubbers to meet the requirements of Phase II of the Acid Rain SO₂ Reduction Program. Additionally, the use of scrubbers can result in reduction of Hg and other emissions from combustion sources. It is timely, therefore, to examine the current status of SO₂ scrubbing technologies. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the state of the art in flue gas desulfurization (FGD) technologies for coal-fired boilers.

Data on worldwide FGD applications reveal that wet FGD technologies, and specifically wet limestone FGD, have been predominantly selected over other FGD technologies. However, lime spray drying (LSD) is being used at the majority of the plants employing dry FGD technologies. Additional review of the U.S. FGD technology applications that began operation in 1991 through 1995 reveals that FGD processes of choice recently in the United States have been wet limestone FGD, magnesium-enhanced lime (MEL), and LSD. Further, of the wet limestone processes, limestone forced oxidation (LSFO) has been used most often in recent applications.

The SO₂ removal performance of scrubbers has been reviewed. Data reflect that most wet limestone and LSD installations appear to be capable of ~90% SO₂ removal. Advanced, state-of-the-art wet scrubbers can provide SO₂ removal in excess of 95%.

Costs associated with state-of-the-art applications of LSFO, MEL, and LSD technologies have been analyzed with appropriate cost models. Analyses indicate that the capital cost of an LSD system is lower than those of same capacity LSFO and MEL systems, reflective of the relatively less complex hardware used in LSD. Analyses also reflect that, based on total annualized cost and SO₂ removal requirements: (1) plants up to ~250 MW_e in size and firing low- to medium-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or lower) may use LSD; and (2) plants larger than 250 MW_e and firing medium- to high-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or higher) may use either LSFO or MEL.     

From Air Repair to EM: A&WMA’s Publications through a Century of Change

Abstract

This paper analyzes the natural desulfurization process taking place in coal-fired units using Greek lignite. The dry scrubbing capability of Greek lignite appears to be extremely high under special conditions, which can make it possible for the units to operate within the legislative limits of sulfur dioxide (SO₂) emissions. According to this study on several lignite-fired power stations in northern Greece, it was found that sulfur oxide emissions depend on coal rank, sulfur content, and calorific value. On the other hand, SO₂ emission is inversely proportional to the parameter y _CO2max, which is equal to the maximum carbon dioxide (CO₂) content by vol ume of dry flue gas under stoichiometric combustion. The desulfurization efficiency is positively correlated to the molar ratio of decomposed calcium carbonate to sulfur and negatively correlated to the free calcium oxide content of fly ash.     

PM2.5 chemical source profiles for vehicle exhaust, vegetative burning, geological material, and coal burning in Northwestern Colorado during 1995

PM_2.5 (particles with aerodynamic diameters less than 2.5 μm) chemical source profiles applicable to speciated emissions inventories and receptor model source apportionment are reported for geological material, motor vehicle exhaust, residential coal (RCC) and wood combustion (RWC), forest fires, geothermal hot springs; and coal-fired power generation units from northwestern Colorado during 1995. Fuels and combustion conditions are similar to those of other communities of the inland western US. Coal-fired power station profiles differed substantially between different units using similar coals, with the major difference being lack of selenium in emissions from the only unit that was equipped with a dry limestone sulfur dioxide (SO₂) scrubber. SO₂ abundances relative to fine particle mass emissions in power plant emissions were seven to nine times higher than hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) abundances from geothermal springs, and one to two orders of magnitude higher than SO₂ abundances in RCC emissions, implying that the SO₂ abundance is an important marker for primary particle contributions of non-aged coal-fired power station contributions. The sum of organic and elemental carbon ranged from 1% to 10% of fine particle mass in coal-fired power plant emissions, from 5% to 10% in geological material, >50% in forest fire emissions, >60% in RWC emissions, and >95% in RCC and vehicle exhaust emissions. Water-soluble potassium (K⁺) was most abundant in vegetative burning profiles. K⁺/K ratios ranged from 0.1 in geological material profiles to 0.9 in vegetative burning emissions, confirming previous observations that soluble potassium is a good marker for vegetative burning.     

A Device for Measuring Volatile Organic-Carbon Emissions from Cooling-Tower Water

A manual method for measuring reduced sulfur compounds in kraft pulp mill and sulfur recovery plant emissions was evaluated. The method involves removing SO₂ from the gas stream (if present) with a citric acid-potassium citrate buffer that passes reduced sulfur compounds; thermal oxidation of all reduced sulfur compounds to SO₂; collection of the SO₂ in H₂O₂; and a titrimetric analysis of the H₂O₂ for SO₄ ^2?. A heated filter removes alkaline particulate matter that would produce a negative interference if absorbed by the buffer. When used at kraft pulp mills, the method agrees closely with Reference Method 16, provided that nonregulated reduced sulfur compounds, such as carbonyl sulfide, are not present in the emissions. At sulfur recovery plants, nonregulated reduced sulfur compounds, such as thiophene, are likely to be present in the emissions and will produce a positive bias in the results obtained with this method. The precision of the method ranges from 1 to 7 percent relative standard deviation.     

The Relationship of Carbon Dioxide Emissions with Coal Rank and Sulfur Content

Carbon dioxide emissions, on an equivalent energy basis, were calculated for 504 North American coals to explore the effects of coal rank and sulfur content on CO₂ emissions. The data set included coals ranging in rank from lignite through low-volatile bituminous from 15 U.S. states and Alberta, Canada. Carbon dioxide emissions were calculated from the carbon content and gross calorific value of each coal. The lowest CO₂ emissions are calculated for the high-volatile bituminous coals (198 to 211 lbs CO₂/MMBtu) and the highest for lignites and subbituminous coals (209 to 224 lbs CO₂/MMBtu). The lower CO₂ emissions from the high-volatile bituminous coals result in part from their generally higher sulfur content. However, even at equivalent sulfur contents the high-volatile bituminous coals give lower CO₂ emissions than the lower-rank coals. On average, the lowerrank coals produce 5 percent more CO₂ upon combustion than the highvolatile bituminous coals, on the basis of gross calorific value. This difference increases to 9 percent on the basis of estimated net calorific value. The net calorific value is better indicator of power plant energy production than the gross calorific value. The difference in CO₂ emissions resulting from the use of high-volatile bituminous coals and lower-rank coals is of the same order of magnitude as reductions expected from near-term combustion efficiency improvements. These results are useful to those interested in current and future CO₂ emissions resulting from coal combustion.     

Regional effects and efficiency of flue gas desulphurization in the Carpathian Basin

Although sulphur emissions (mainly as SO₂) have been continuously decreasing over the last 20 years in most western industrialized countries, localized SO₂ problems still exist in conjunction with strong local emission, meteorological, and topographical factors. In this study, the effect of supplementary installed flue gas desulphurization (FGD) units at high-capacity power plants on regional air pollution in the Carpathian Basin is investigated. The dispersion and accumulation of the SO₂ air pollutant are studied with the regional three-dimensional on-line atmosphere-chemistry model REMOTE. The changes in the SO₂ air pollution are investigated by parallel simulations in a case study, where the single modified parameter is the SO₂ emission rate. The results show that FGD units significantly reduce the horizontal and the vertical dispersion of the emitted SO₂, and its transboundary transport, too. Beside the SO₂ removal efficiency, the dispersion and accumulation also depend on the seasonal weather conditions. During winter, the dispersion and accumulation are higher than in other seasons. Due to this phenomenon, higher SO₂ removal efficiency is needed to guarantee similar air quality features like in the other seasons.     

Sulfur Dioxide and Nitrogen Oxides Emissions from U.S. Pulp and Paper Mills, 1980–2005

Abstract

Comprehensive surveys conducted at 5-yr intervals were used to estimate sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and nitrogen oxides (NO_x) emissions from U.S. pulp and paper mills for 1980, 1985, 1990, 1995, 2000, and 2005. Over the 25-yr period, paper production increased by 50%, whereas total SO₂ emissions declined by 60% to 340,000 short tons (t) and total NO_x emissions decreased approximately 15% to 230,000 t. The downward emission trends resulted from a combination of factors, including reductions in oil and coal use, steadily declining fuel sulfur content, lower pulp and paper production in recent years, increased use of flue gas desulfurization systems on boilers, growing use of combustion modifications and add-on control systems to reduce boiler and gas turbine NO_x emissions, and improvements in kraft recovery furnace operations.     

Eliminating Reheat from Existing FGD Systems

The Clean Air Act Amendments of the early 1970_s required coal burning utilities to reduce their emissions of sulfur dioxide. Lime or limestone based wet systems were employed for flue gas desulfurization (FGD). These systems reduced flue gas temperatures to below acid dew point conditions. Concerned about the prospect of ductwork exposed to a saturated, acid-rich environment, most utilities turned to stack gas reheat (SGR) to increase flue gas temperatures. By 1980, 82 percent of all FGD facilities employed SGR. Today there are about 130 FGD systems of which 101 employ some form of stack gas reheat.     

Product Gudie/1987

A computer program has been written to determine the cost of building and operating wet scrubbers on individual coal fired utilities in the states where emissions are likely to affect the acid rain problem in the eastern United States. The program differs from many other estimates since it calculates the cost for each of 831 individual sites. The capital costs for installing scrubbers on the top fifty sulfur oxide emitting plants will be about $20 billion. This will result in an increase in the cost of electricity on an average of 0.88 cents/kWh and a reduction of sulfur oxide emissions from 1980 of 7,100,000 tons per year. An additional reduction of at least 1,000,000 tons per year can be obtained by requiring all plants burning oil to burn low sulfur oil. These figures assume utilities will use least emissions dispatching and will use local coals containing at least 3.5 percent sulfur. The use of local coals should result in a further saving of at least 0.2 cents/kWh. This should make available a large supply of low sulfur coal which could reduce emissions of sulfur oxides by up to 1,000,000 tons per year. The SO₂ reductions will be continued for at least the next thirteen years and have a very significant effect through the year 2010.     

Impact of Free Calcium Oxide Content of Fly Ash on Dust and Sulfur Dioxide Emissions in a Lignite-Fired Power Plant

Abstract

Emitted pollutants from the Agios Dimitrios lignite-fired power plant in northern Greece show a very strong linear correlation with the free calcium oxide content of the lignite ash. Dust (fly ash) emissions are positively correlated to free calcium oxide content, whereas sulfur dioxide (SO₂) emissions are negatively correlated. As a result, at present, the Agios Dimitrios Power Plant operates very strictly within the legislative limits on atmospheric particulate emission. In the present study, the factors to be considered in assessing the impact of lignite combustion on the environment are presented and evaluated statistically. The ash appears to have a remarkable SO₂ natural dry scrubbing capability when the free calcium oxide content ranges between 4 and 7%. Precipitator operating problems attributable to high ash resistivity can be overcome by injecting sulfur trioxide to reduce the ash resistivity, with, of course, a probable increase in operating costs.