Reproductive interference via interspecific pairing in an amphipod species complex

Many species experience reproductive interference defined as interspecific mating interactions that reduce the fitness of individuals in at least one of the species. We examined reproductive interference among three cryptic amphipod species that co-occur in the vegetated zone of lakes. Because these animals form precopulatory pairs and males commonly have indiscriminant mating behavior, we predicted that (1) there would be interspecific pairing, (2) interspecific pairing would be more common when conspecifics were rare, and (3) interspecific pairing would be more common in species combinations where males are larger than females. Using color phenotypes to distinguish species, a novel discovery reported here, we conducted experiments to evaluate patterns of interspecific pairing. In a no-choice experiment (i.e., amphipods had access to mates of only one species), we observed a low rate (5 %) of interspecific pairing and 80 % of these cases involved males that were larger than females. In a second experiment where individuals had access to conspecific mates at varying relative abundance, only 0.04 % of the pairs observed were between heterospecifics, suggesting that the interspecific pairing observed in the no-choice experiment was an artifact of not having access to conspecific mates. Our results suggest that at least one sex has sufficient species-recognition abilities to circumvent the formation of interspecific pairs; therefore, reproductive interference may be minimal in these species.