Sensitivity Analysis of Dispersion Models for Point and Area Sources

The body of information presented in this paper is directed to air quality managers in industry and government contemplating modeling emissions from complex sources under the bubble concept.

Point and area source algorithms of PAL, RAM, and ISC-ST were analyzed to show the effect of various input assumptions on model output. Several important parameters were varied individually; receptor grid spacing, emission release height, area source size and source type. Each of these parameters was varied over a range of values while all other modeling parameters, both physical and meteorological, were held constant. The outputs of each model are plotted for easy comparison.

Results indicate that it would be inappropriate to make certain assumptions regarding source characteristics without knowing the behavior of each model. The graphs show how the model predictions can vary for different input parameters when applied to point and area sources. The paper presents general rules of thumb for evaluating model results for many applications such as the bubble concept, emissions banking, offsets, and new source reviews. The results serve as a guide in selecting and using models for both point and area sources.