Implementing comprehensive plans: indicators for a task-sheet based performance evaluation process |
| |
Authors: | Georg Philipp Mueller Anna M Hersperger |
| |
Institution: | Swiss Federal Research Institute WSL, Birmensdorf, Switzerland |
| |
Abstract: | Evaluation in spatial planning aims to raise effectiveness of plans as well as efficiency in planning processes. Given that research regarding evaluation of performance and especially plan implementation is sparse, this study presents a minimal set of indicators for a task-sheet based performance evaluation approach for Swiss cantonal comprehensive plans. Thematic task-sheets are a promising characteristic of cantonal comprehensive plans. They translate the comprehensive planning strategy into concrete evaluable tasks. The presented indicators allow assessing procedural efficiency of coordination and implementation of planning tasks (performance). We argue that if task-sheets comply with certain plan quality characteristics, a task-sheet based performance evaluation approach can support the effectiveness of plans and promote the objectives of the planning strategy. We point out plan content and characteristics necessary for effective execution of our approach. As a result, our findings can serve as a framework for designing evaluation processes for comprehensive planning documents beyond Switzerland. |
| |
Keywords: | plan performance evaluation plan quality evaluation indicator development benchmarking Switzerland |
|