Teil III: Stoffstromanalyse

A material flow analysis is performed to check the measures of groundwater protection, especially those undertaken to reduce nitrate leaching in water protecting areas. The impacts both of direct and of indirect agricultural processes are assessed. Implementing the methodology of cost counting into the material flow analysis allows one to test whether the equalization payments (agreed on in voluntary agreements between farmers and water economy for special groundwater protecting measures as direct drilling or intercropping) are appropriate for compensating the resulting economical losses for the farmer. It is shown that this extensive production produces more profit — despite lower yields and inferior quality — due to equalization and lower production costs. However, these results strongly depend on yield estimation. Groundwater protecting measures with low input (e.g. nitrogen reduction) reduce environmental impacts on a regional and also on a global scale, while other measures such as intercropping increase them due to additional fertilizer application. So it is still difficult to choose one or the other because of weighing global against regional effects in a qualitative and quantitative way.