Assessment of Dry Sorbenf Emission Control Technologies Part II. Applications

The injection of dry alkaline compounds into the furnace or post-furnace regions of utility boilers to reduce SO₂ is currently under development as a lower cost option to conventional flue gas desulfurization technology. Part I of this paper focused on the science and process development of the various dry sorbent technologies. Part II will address applications of these technologies, including SO₂ removals in full-scale boilers, methodologies for designing sorbent injection systems, power plant impacts, process integration issues, and cost.

Because the dry technologies use the furnace and/or ducts as the chemical contactor, potential impacts on power plant operation and reliability are as critical in assessing the commercial applicability of each technology as SO₂ removal and sorbent utilization. Consequently, the technical and economic feasibility of the various dry processes is highly site specific.     

Flue Gas Desulfurization: The State of the Art

ABSTRACT

Coal-fired electricity-generating plants may use SO₂ scrubbers to meet the requirements of Phase II of the Acid Rain SO₂ Reduction Program. Additionally, the use of scrubbers can result in reduction of Hg and other emissions from combustion sources. It is timely, therefore, to examine the current status of SO₂ scrubbing technologies. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the state of the art in flue gas desulfurization (FGD) technologies for coal-fired boilers.

Data on worldwide FGD applications reveal that wet FGD technologies, and specifically wet limestone FGD, have been predominantly selected over other FGD technologies. However, lime spray drying (LSD) is being used at the majority of the plants employing dry FGD technologies. Additional review of the U.S. FGD technology applications that began operation in 1991 through 1995 reveals that FGD processes of choice recently in the United States have been wet limestone FGD, magnesium-enhanced lime (MEL), and LSD. Further, of the wet limestone processes, limestone forced oxidation (LSFO) has been used most often in recent applications.

The SO₂ removal performance of scrubbers has been reviewed. Data reflect that most wet limestone and LSD installations appear to be capable of ~90% SO₂ removal. Advanced, state-of-the-art wet scrubbers can provide SO₂ removal in excess of 95%.

Costs associated with state-of-the-art applications of LSFO, MEL, and LSD technologies have been analyzed with appropriate cost models. Analyses indicate that the capital cost of an LSD system is lower than those of same capacity LSFO and MEL systems, reflective of the relatively less complex hardware used in LSD. Analyses also reflect that, based on total annualized cost and SO₂ removal requirements: (1) plants up to ~250 MW_e in size and firing low- to medium-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or lower) may use LSD; and (2) plants larger than 250 MW_e and firing medium- to high-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or higher) may use either LSFO or MEL.     

Technical Description of Parameters Influencing the pH Value of Suspension Absorbent Used in Flue Gas Desulfurization Systems

Abstract

As a result of the large limestone deposits available in Poland, the low cost of reagent acquisition for the large-scale technological use and relatively well-documented processes of flue gas desulfurization (FGD) technologies based on limestone sorbent slurry, wet scrubbing desulfurization is a method of choice in Poland for flue gas treatment in energy production facilities, including power plants and industrial systems. The efficiency of FGD using the above method depends on several technological and kinetic parameters, particularly on the pH value of the sorbent (i.e., ground limestone suspended in water). Consequently, many studies in Poland and abroad address the impact of various parameters on the pH value of the sorbent suspension, such as the average diameter of sorbent particles (related to the limestone pulverization degree), sorbent quality (in terms of pure calcium carbonate [CaCO₃] content of the sorbent material), stoichiometric surfeit of CaCO₃ in relation to sulfur dioxide (SO₂) absorbed from flue gas circulating in the absorption node, time of absorption slurry retention in the absorber tank, chlorine ion concentration in sorbent slurry, and concentration of dissolved metal salts (Na, K, Mg, Fe, Al, and others). This study discusses the results of laboratory-scale tests conducted to establish the effect of the above parameters on the pH value of limestone slurry circulating in the SO₂ absorption node. On the basis of the test results, a correlation equation was postulated to help maintain the desirable pH value at the design phase of the wet FGD process. The postulated equation displays good coincidence between calculated pH values and those obtained using laboratory measurements.     

Simplified Models of U.S. Acid Rain Control Costs

Simplified algorithms are presented for estimating the cost of controlling sulfur dioxide (SO₂) emissions from existing coal-fired power plants on a state-by-state basis. Results are obtained using the detailed Utility Control Strategy Model (UCSM) to calculate the Impacts of emission reductions ranging from approximately 30 percent to 90 percent of projected 1995 emissions for 18 different scenarios and 36 states. Scenarios include the use of two dry SO₂ removal technologies (lime spray dryers and LIMB) as potential options for power plant retrofit, in addition to currently available emission control options including coal switching, coal cleaning and wet flue gas desulfurization (FGD). Technical assumptions relating to FGD system performance and the upgrading of existing cold-side electrostatic precipitators (ESP) for reduced sulfur levels are also analyzed, along with the effects of interest rates, coal prices, coal choice restrictions, plant lifetime, and plant operating levels. Results are summarized in the form of a 3-term polynomial equation for each state, giving total annualized SO₂ control cost as a function of the total SO₂ emissions reduction for each scenario. Excellent statistical fits to UCSM results are obtained for these generalized equations.     

Summary of the 1991 EPRI/EPA/DOE SO2 Control Symposium

The 1991 SO₂ Control Symposium was held December 3-6, 1991, in Washington, D.C. The symposium, jointly sponsored by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), focused attention on recent improvements in conventional sulfur dioxide (SO₂) control technologies, emerging processes, and strategies for complying with the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990. Its purpose was to provide a forum for the exchange of technical and regulatory information on SO₂ control technology. Over 800 representatives of 20 countries from government, academia, flue gas desulfurization (FGD) process suppliers, equipment manufacturers, engineering firms, and utilities attended. In all, 50 U.S. utilities and 10 utilities in other countries were represented. In 11 technical sessions, a diverse group of speakers presented 111 technical papers on development, operation, and commercialization of wet and dry FGD, Clean Coal Technologies, and combined sulfur dioxide/nitrogen oxides (SO₂/NO_x processes.     

The Bechtel Confined Zone dispersion Process for FGD Retrofit Situations Proof-of-Concept Tests

The Bechtel Confined Zone Dispersion (CZD) process for FGD retrofit situations was tested at two sites: one at a level of 5 MWe; the other at 70 MWe. The CZD process involves injecting a finely atomized slurry of hydrated lime into a straight run of duct between a boiler's air heater and its electrostatic precipitator (ESP). The effect of process variables on SO₂ removal and ESP performance was investigated for dolomitic/calcitic lime. Removals of SO₂ in excess of 50 percent were achieved for either lime type at the 5 MWe site. A very short duct length limited injection rate at the 70 MWe site, limiting sulfur removals to a maximum of 30 percent. SO₂ removal data for both sites were successfully correlated on a common basis. ESP performance was not fully acceptable during lime injection at both sites, but it is felt that optimization of ESP operations should eliminate this problem. Additional testing is recommended to further explore ESP performance and to optimize lime injection parameters. The results obtained to date continue to indicate that the CZD process is an attractive and economical candidate for FGD retrofit situations.     

Improved Spray Dry Scrubbing through Grinding of FGD Recycle Material

A laboratory size spray dry scrubbing unit consisting of a spray dryer and a pulse Jet baghouse was used to study the effect of grinding recycle waste on SO₂ removal across the spray dryer and on sorbent utilization. The equipment treats simulated flue gas with a dry flow rate of 1.5 m³ h^?1 (stp) and utilizes an ultrasonic nozzle for atomization. The apparatus was initially tested over a broad range of operating conditions; a close agreement in SO₂ removal was found with data from much larger units. The effect of grinding the FGD recycle material on the SO₂ removal across the spray dryer was found to be great. Grinding the recycle material can enhance the SO₂ removal efficiency to a level comparable to operation with a large excess of fresh lime.     

Effects of Sorbent Injection on Participate Properties: Part I. Low-Temperature Sorbent Injection

Abstract

This article is the first of a two-part series dealing with the effects of sorbent injection processes on particulate properties. Part I reviews the effects on particulate properties of low-temperature sorbent injection processes (those processes that treat flue gas at temperatures near 300 °F). Part II reviews the effects on particulate properties of high-temperature sorbent injection processes (those processes that involve sorbent injection into the combustion or economizer sections of a boiler). In this article, we review what is currently known about the effects of the low-temperature sorbent injection processes on electrical resistivity, particulate mass loading, particulate size distribution, particulate morphology and cohesivity.

Mixtures of ash and sorbent produced by low-temperature sorbent injection processes are typically less cohesive than most types of fly ash. At temperatures within 30 °F of the water dew point, the combination of low cohesivity and low electrical resistivity of the ash and sorbent mixtures can cause electrical reentrainment in electrostatic precipitators. Deliquescent additives such as calcium chloride cause the water to be retained on the particle surface, thereby increasing cohesivity.

Sorbent injection has been reported to increase the particulate mass loading by a factor of 1.8 to 10, depending upon the reagent ratio and the coal sulfur content. Conventional and in-duct spray drying processes tend to shift the particle size distribution toward larger particles, while dry injection processes tend to shift the particle size distribution toward smaller particles.     

A theoretical assessment of pollutant deposition to individual land types during a regional-scale acid deposition episode

A mesoscale model of pollutant transport, transformation and deposition was used to perform a detailed analysis of acidic deposition to the states of New York and Ohio during a 3-day springtime deposition episode. This model can be used to assess the roles of wet and dry deposition to individual land types in the removal of pollutants from the atmosphere. Over two-thirds (67 %, Ohio; 78 %, New York) of the acidic deposition during this rainy period fell as wet deposition, primarily in the form of H₂SO₄. Dry deposition of SO₂ accounted for 70–75 % of the total dry acidic deposition in both areas, and most of the remaining dry deposition occurred as HNO₃. Over both deposition areas, particulate sulfate deposition accounted for <1 % of the total acid deposition. Due to the highly surface-specific nature of the dry deposition process, individual land types displayed unique patterns of pollutant uptake. Water surfaces absorbed primarily SO₂, while rougher forested areas absorbed a larger proportion of HNO₃ vapor. Urban areas, with their associated material surfaces, were found to absorb significantly less acid in the dry form, and during dry periods most of this deposition may occur as HNO₃ vapor, although considerable uncertainty exists regarding the treatment of rainfall-wetted surfaces. These model results suggest that dry pollutant fluxes to individual surface types will show significant variability from any ‘averaged’ flux estimates over larger areas encompassing numerous land types.     

An Assessment

Extensive research has determined that adipic acid, when used as an additive to a limestone flue gas desulfurization (FGD) system, will improve the performance of the system. Both SO₂ removal and limestone utilization can be greatly increased by the buffering effect of adipic acid. Successful testing in laboratory, bench, pilot, prototype, and full scale systems has demonstrated the benefits of this technology for new and retrofit applications. Although adipic acid does degrade in the scrubber, no significant operating problems or environmental impacts have been identified. Economic estimates have shown the adipic acid enhanced limestone FGD system to be economically attractive when compared to conventional FGD systems. In addition, further research is underway to decrease the cost of using additives in FGD systems.     

Investigation of a Mercury Speciation Technique for Flue Gas Desulfurization Materials

Abstract

Most of the synthetic gypsum generated from wet flue gas desulfurization (FGD) scrubbers is currently being used for wallboard production. Because oxidized mercury is readily captured by the wet FGD scrubber, and coal-fired power plants equipped with wet scrubbers desire to benefit from the partial mercury control that these systems provide, some mercury is likely to be bound in with the FGD gypsum and wallboard. In this study, the feasibility of identifying mercury species in the FGD gypsum and wallboard samples was investigated using a large sample size thermal desorption method. Potential candidates of pure mercury standards including mercuric chloride (HgCl₂), mercurous chloride (Hg₂Cl₂), mercury oxide (HgO), mercury sulfide (HgS), and mercuric sulfate (HgSO₄) were analyzed to compare their results with those obtained from FGD gypsum and dry wallboard samples. Although any of the thermal evolutionary curves obtained from these pure mercury standards did not exactly match with those of the FGD gypsum and wallboard samples, it was identified that Hg₂Cl₂ and HgCl₂ could be candidates. An additional chlorine analysis from the gypsum and wallboard samples indicated that the chlorine concentrations were approximately 2 orders of magnitude higher than the mercury concentrations, suggesting possible chlorine association with mercury.     

Development and Pilot Plant Evaluation of Silica- Enhanced Lime Sorbents for Dry Flue Gas Desulfurization

EPA’s efforts to develop low cost, retrofitable flue gas cleaning technology include the development of highly reactive sorbents. Recent work addressing lime enhancement and testing at the bench-scale followed by evaluation of the more promising sorbents in a pilot plant are discussed here.

The conversion of Ca(OH)₂ with SO₂ increased several-fold compared with Ca(OH)₂ alone when Ca(OH)₂ was slurrled with fly ash first and later exposed to SO₂ in a laboratory packed bed reactor. Ca(OH)₂ enhancement increased with the increased fly ash amount. Dlatomaceous earths were very effective reactivity promoters of lime-based sorbents. Differential scanning calorimetry of the promoted sorbents revealed the formation of a new phase (calcium silicate hydrates) after hydration, which may be the basis for the observed Improved SO₂ capture.

Fly ash/lime and diatomaceous earth/lime sorbents were tested in a 100 m³/h pilot facility incorporating a gas humidifier, a sorbent duct injection system, and a baghouse. The inlet SO₂ concentration range was 1000-2500 ppm. With once-through dry sorbent injection into the humidified flue gas [approach to saturation 10–20°C (18–36°F) in the baghouse], the total SO₂ removal ranged from 50 to 90 percent for a stoichiometric ratio of 1 to 2. Recycling the collected solids resulted in a total lime utilization exceeding 80–90 percent. Increased lime utilization was also investigated by the use of additives.     

Investigation of aerosol and gas emissions from a coal-fired power plant under various operating conditions

The concentrations of fine particles and selected gas pollutants in the flue gas entering the stack were measured under several common operation modes in an operating coal power plant producing electricity. Particle size distributions in a diameter range from 10 nm to 20 μm were measured by a scanning mobility particle sizer (SMPS), and the flue gas temperature and concentrations of CO₂ and SO₂ were monitored by a continuous emission monitoring system (CEMS). During the test campaign, five plant operating modes were studied: soot blowing, bypass of flue-gas desulfurization (FGD), reheat burner operating at 0% (turned off), 27%, and 42% (normal condition) of its full capacity. For wet and dry aerosols, the measured mode sizes were both around 40 nm, but remarkable differences were observed in the number concentrations (#/cm³, count per square centimeter). A prototype photoionizer enhanced electrostatic precipitator (ESP) showed improved removal efficiency of wet particles at voltages above +11.0 kV. Soot blowing and FGD bypass both increased the total particle number concentration in the flue gas. The temperature was slightly increased by the FGD bypass mode and varied significantly as the rating of reheat burner changed. The variations of CO₂ and SO₂ emissions showed correlations with the trend of total particle number concentration possibly due to the transitions between gas and particle phases. The results are useful in developing coal-fired power plant operation strategies to control fine particle emissions and developing amine-based CO₂ capture technologies without operating and environmental concerns associated with volatile amine emissions.

Implications: The measurement of the fine particle size distributions in the exhaust gas under several common operating conditions of a coal-fired power plant revealed different response relations between aerosol number concentration and the operating condition. A photo-ionizer enhanced ESP was demonstrated to capture fine particles with higher efficiency compared to conventional ESPs, and the removal efficiency increased with the applied voltage. The characteristic information of aerosols and main gaseous pollutants in the exhaust gas is extremely important for developing and deploying CO₂ scrubbers, whose amine emissions and operating effectiveness depends greatly on the upstream concentrations of fine particles, SO₂, from the power plant.     

Simultaneous removal of NOx,SO2, and Hg from flue gas in FGD absorber with oxidant injection (NaClO2)– full-scale investigation

ABSTRACT

This article presents the results of an industrial-scale study (on 400 MW_e lignite fired unit) of simultaneous NO_x, SO₂, and Hg^T removal in FGD absorber with oxidant injection (NaClO₂) into flue gas. It was confirmed that the injection of sodium chlorite upstream the FGD (Flue Gas Desulfurization) absorber oxidize NO to NO₂, Hg⁰ to Hg²⁺, and enhancing NO_x and Hg^T removal efficiency from exhaust gas in FGD absorber. Mercury removal efficiency grows with the rise of degree of oxidation NO to NO₂ and was limited by the phenomenon of re-emission. For NO_x removal the most critical parameters is slurry pH and temperature. There was no negative effect on sulfur dioxide removal efficiency caused by oxidant injection in tested FGD absorber. Based on the data provided, NO_x and Hg^T emissions can be reduced by adjusting the FGD absorber operating parameters combined with oxidant injection.     

Elevational patterns of sulfur deposition at a site in the Catskill Mountains,New York

In this paper we report measurements of SO^2-₄ fluxes in throughfall and bulk deposition across an elevational transect from 800 to 1275 m on Slide Mountain in the Catskill Mountains of southeastern New York State. The net throughfall flux of SO^2-₄ (throughfall-bulk deposition), which we attribute to cloud and dry deposition, increased by roughly a factor of 13 across this elevational range. Part of the observed increase results from the year-round exposure of evergreen foliage at the high-elevation sites, compared to the lack of foliage in the dormant season in the deciduous canopies at low elevations. Comparison of the net throughfall flux with estimates of cloud deposition suggests that both cloud deposition and dry deposition increased with elevation. Dry deposition estimates from a nearby monitoring site fall within the measured range of net throughfall flux for SO^2-₄. The between-site variation in net throughfall flux was very high at the high-elevation sites, and less so at the lower sites, suggesting that studies of atmospheric deposition at high-elevations will be complicated by extreme spatial variability in deposition rates. Studies of atmospheric deposition in mountainous areas of the eastern U.S. have often emphasized cloud water deposition, but these results suggest that elevational increases in dry deposition may also be important.     

Flue gas desulfurization: the state of the art

Coal-fired electricity-generating plants may use SO2 scrubbers to meet the requirements of Phase II of the Acid Rain SO2 Reduction Program. Additionally, the use of scrubbers can result in reduction of Hg and other emissions from combustion sources. It is timely, therefore, to examine the current status of SO2 scrubbing technologies. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the state of the art in flue gas desulfurization (FGD) technologies for coal-fired boilers. Data on worldwide FGD applications reveal that wet FGD technologies, and specifically wet limestone FGD, have been predominantly selected over other FGD technologies. However, lime spray drying (LSD) is being used at the majority of the plants employing dry FGD technologies. Additional review of the U.S. FGD technology applications that began operation in 1991 through 1995 reveals that FGD processes of choice recently in the United States have been wet limestone FGD, magnesium-enhanced lime (MEL), and LSD. Further, of the wet limestone processes, limestone forced oxidation (LSFO) has been used most often in recent applications. The SO2 removal performance of scrubbers has been reviewed. Data reflect that most wet limestone and LSD installations appear to be capable of approximately 90% SO2 removal. Advanced, state-of-the-art wet scrubbers can provide SO2 removal in excess of 95%. Costs associated with state-of-the-art applications of LSFO, MEL, and LSD technologies have been analyzed with appropriate cost models. Analyses indicate that the capital cost of an LSD system is lower than those of same capacity LSFO and MEL systems, reflective of the relatively less complex hardware used in LSD. Analyses also reflect that, based on total annualized cost and SO2 removal requirements: (1) plants up to approximately 250 MWe in size and firing low- to medium-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or lower) may use LSD; and (2) plants larger than 250 MWe and firing medium- to high-sulfur coals (i.e., coals with a sulfur content of 2% or higher) may use either LSFO or MEL.     

Full-Scale Evaluation of Mercury Control with Sorbent Injection and COHPAC at Alabama Power E.C. Gaston

Abstract

The overall objective of this project was to determine the cost and impacts of Hg control using sorbent injection into a Compact Hybrid Particulate Collector (COHPAC) at Alabama Power’s Gaston Unit 3. This test is part of a program funded by the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) to obtain the necessary information to assess the costs of controlling Hg from coal-fired utility plants that do not have scrubbers for SO₂ control. The economics will be developed based on various levels of Hg control.

Gaston Unit 3 was chosen for testing because COHPAC represents a cost-effective retrofit option for utilities with existing electrostatic precipitators (ESPs). COHPAC is an EPRI-patented concept that places a high air-to-cloth ratio baghouse downstream of an existing ESP to improve overall particulate collection efficiency. Activated carbons were injected upstream of COHPAC and downstream of the ESP to obtain performance and operational data.

Results were very encouraging, with up to 90% removal of Hg for short operating periods using powdered activated carbon (PAC). During the long-term tests, an average Hg removal efficiency of 78% was measured. The PAC injection rate for the long-term tests was chosen to maintain COHPAC cleaning frequency at less than 1.5 pulses/bag/hr.     

Wintertime wet and dry deposition in northern Michigan

Wet and dry deposition were monitored at the University of Michigan Biological Station in rural northern Michigan for three winters. Dry deposition was measured by both the conventional bucket method and by measuring increases in concentration in exposed, elevated snow samples. Average results of the two methods were in reasonable agreement. The cumulative wet and dry deposition quantities are in good agreement with snowpack accumulations until the first thaw period. Dry deposition to snow accounts for less than 15% of the total H⁺, SO²⁻₄, NO⁻₃ and NH⁺₄ and approximately 25% of the Ca ²⁺, Mg ²⁺, Na⁺, K⁺ and Cl⁻ during an average precipitation year. Snowpack measurements were also made under deciduous and red pine canopies. Decreases in H⁺ and NO⁻₃ were observed under the red pine canopy.     

Modeling of Dry Injection Flue Gas Desulfurization

Dry processes for controlling sulfur dioxide emissions by injecting sodium based sorbents in the ductwork ahead of a bag filter are effective and more simple alternatives to conventional FGD processes. This paper presents a fundamental kinetic model of the dry injection process. Experimental data from pilot scale tests are reported. The model is shown to be applicable to the dry injection process. However, further experimental work is recommended to get a better understanding of the reaction mechanisms.     

Assessing Sorbents for Mercury Control in Coal-Combustion Flue Gas

Abstract

Sorbent injection for Hg control is one of the most promising technologies for reducing Hg emissions from power-generation facilities, particularly units that do not require wet scrubbers for SO₂ control. Since 1992, EPRI has been assessing the performance of Hg sorbents in pilot-scale systems installed at full-scale facilities. The initial tests were conducted on a 5000-acfm (142-m³/min) pilot baghouse. Screening potential sorbents at this scale required substantial resources for installation and operation and did not provide an opportunity to characterize sor-bents over a wide temperature range.

Data collected in the laboratory and in field tests indicate that sorbents are affected by flue gas composition and temperature. Tests carried out in actual flue gas at a number of power plants also have shown that sorbent performance can be site-specific. In addition, data collected at a field site often are different from data collected in the laboratory, with simulated flue gas mixed to match the major components in the site’s gas. To effectively estimate the costs of Hg sorbent systems at different plants, a measure of sorbent performance in the respective flue gases must be obtained. However, injection testing at multiple facilities with large pilot systems is not practical.

Over the past five years, fixed-bed characterization testing, modeling studies, and bench-scale injection testing have been undertaken to develop a low-cost technique to characterize sorbent performance in actual flue gas and subsequently to project normalized costs for Hg removal prior to full-scale demonstration. This article describes the techniques used and summarizes field-testing results from two plants burning Powder River Basin (PRB) coal for commercial activated carbon and several other sorbent types. Full-scale projections based on the results and data collected on larger-scale systems also are included.