Retention of sulfur dioxide by nylon filters

Based on laboratory studies, recovery efficiencies of sulfur dioxide (SO₂) were determined for nylon filters. The nylon filters used in these experiments were found to retain SO₂. A relatively uniform amount (1.7%) was recoverable from each nylon filter, independent of relative humidity. An appreciable portion of SO₂ was unrecoverable, and this increased from 5 to 16% as the RH increased from 28 to 49%. This unrecoverable SO₂ may account for previous reports of a low bias for SO₂ determinations employing filter packs using nylon filters. Additional characterization of nylon filters is recommended prior to their future deployment as an integrative sampling medium for ambient air.     

An evaluation of artifact SO42− formation on nylon filters under field conditions

The extent of SO₂ conversion on Membrana (Ghia) Nylasorb nylon filters under field conditions has been evaluated and found to be quite variable. The S-SO₄²⁻ loading on the nylon filters is higher at higher SO₂ concentrations, and on a long term basis approaches a saturatio limit of 2.5 μg S-SO₄²⁻ on a 47mm disc, at a dosage of 230 μg SO₂ approximately. The % conversion decreases as the SO₂ concentration increases. On a long term basis, at an SO₂ concentration range of 1.0–7.7 μg m⁻³, the conversion ranges from 8.2% to 2.1%. The dependence of SO₂ conversion on nylon filters on relative humidity displays a diurnal pattern. An expression has been derived to explain the observed % SO₂ conversion on nylon filters as a combined effect of the ambient SO₂ concentration and relative humidity.     

Biases in Clean Air Status and Trends Network filter pack results associated with sampling protocol

Network filter pack sampling protocol changed in 1989 from requiring a week-long daytime sample and a week-long nighttime sample to requiring a single week-long sample per week at each monitoring site. In the current study, single-filter pack weekly results are compared with weekly results aggregated from separate daytime and nighttime weekly filter pack samples collected at the monitoring site located at Egbert, Ontario, Canada. Comparisons of the concentrations resulting from the two sampling protocols for all major chemical species (SO₄²⁻, NO₃⁻, NH₄⁺, HNO₃, and SO₂) show median biases of <5 nmol m⁻³ (0.1 ppb) and median relative biases of <10%. Median relative biases have the same sign for each species, suggesting biases in the same direction. Based on median differences, composite day–night weekly sampler results generally exceed the single-sampler weekly results (in all cases except for the summer nylon filter HNO₃), and the magnitude depends on the constituent and on the season. Examination of seasonal results reveals large discrepancies in some cases, especially during summer. To use Clean Air Status and Trends Network results for trends analyses over time periods encompassing the 1989 protocol change, it may be useful to put all of the data on the same basis of sampler protocol. Algorithms derived from linear regression analyses using paired bootstrap sampling are offered to convert the recent results to the pre-1989 basis; however, they may only be appropriate for sites in the eastern US. Chemical and statistical reasoning suggests that the results of day–night weekly sampling are usually consistent with higher accuracy than single-sampler weekly results. Adjustments are indicated for summer Teflon NO₃ and nylon HNO₃, for summer and fall Teflon NH₄, and for Total SO₂ in each season. Nylon filters are also shown to have variable collection characteristics for SO₂ that are consistent with a humidity effect. A network-wide change in the SO₂ collection and/or retention characteristics of the nylon filters is found in April 1997.     

Uptake of nitrous acid and nitrogen oxides by nylon surfaces: Implications for nitric acid measurement

The interference in HNO₃ determination due to HNO₂ and NO_x retention on nylon filters has been evaluated in laboratory and field conditions. Nitrous acid is retained on nylon filters with efficiencies varying from 25% at 12ℓ min⁻¹ to 80% at 2ℓ min⁻¹, yielding NO₂⁻ ion. In ambient sampling performed during photochemical smog episodes, NO₂⁻ is oxidized to NO₃⁻ with conversion factors up to 100%, resulting in a positive bias in HNO₃ determination.NO₂ reacts heterogeneously with H₂O on nylon surfaces according to the reaction 2NO₂ + H₂O → HNO₂ + HNO₃ with a removal constant of about 1 × 10⁻⁴ ms⁻¹ at a H₂O concentration of 20,000 ppm. The resulting nitrite and nitrate are independent of the sampling flow rate, while NO₂ concentration, sampling time and exposed nylon surface area play a directly proportional role. Accordingly, the relative interference of NO₂ with respect to HNO₃ determination is almost negligible for nylon filters, usually run at relatively high flow rates, while it may be significant for nylon denuders, which are characterized by larger exposed surfaces and lower operating flow rates.     

The Magnitude of Bias in the Measurement of PM25 Arising from Volatilization of Particulate Nitrate from Teflon Filters

ABSTRACT

Because the Federal Reference Method for PM₂₅ specifies the collection of ambient particles on Teflon filters, we have examined the loss of a known volatile species, particulate nitrate, during sampling. Data are presented from two studies in southern California for which parallel samples were collected by different methods. Differences in collected nitrate are modeled using an evaporation model based on the work of Zhang and McMurry. The average nitrate obtained from sampling with Teflon filters was 28% lower on average than that measured by denuded nylon filters. In contrast, cascade impactor samples were within 5% of the denuded nylon filter on average. A simple model is presented that accounts for the particulate nitrate loss from Teflon filters either by scavenging nitric acid and ammonia in the sampler inlet or by heating the filter substrate during sampling. The observed magnitude of loss is explained by any of the following situations: (1) 100% nitric acid and ammonia vapor loss in the inlet, (2) 5 °C heating of the filter substrate above ambient temperature during sampling, or (3) a combination of these factors, such as 50% vapor loss in the inlet and 3 °C heating of the filter.     

Evaluation of the filter pack for long-duration sampling of ambient air

A 14-week filter pack (FP) sampler evaluation field study was conducted at a site near Bondville, IL to investigate the impact of weekly sampling duration. Simultaneous samples were collected using collocated filter packs (FP) from two independent air quality monitoring networks (CASTNet and Acid-MODES) and using duplicate annular denuder systems (ADS). Precision estimates for most of the measured species are similar for weekly ADS and composited FPs. There is generally good agreement between the weekly CASTNet FP results aggregated from weekly daytime and weekly nighttime samples and those aggregated from daily 24 h Acid-MODES samples; although SO₂ is the exception, and CASTNet concentrations are higher than Acid-MODES. Comparison of weekly ADS results with composited weekly FP results from CASTNet shows good agreement for SO^2-₄. With the exception of the two weeks where the FP exceeded the ADS, both HNO₃ and the sum of particulate and gaseous NO^-₃ show good agreement. The FP often provides good estimates of HNO₃, but when used to sample atmospheres that have experienced substantial photochemical reactivity, FP HNO₃ determinations using nylon filters may be biased high. It is suggested that HNO₂ or some other oxidized nitrogen compound can accumulate on a regional scale and may interfere with the FP determination of HNO₃. FP particulate NO^-₃ results are in fair agreement with the ADS. Since FP SO₂ results are biased low by 12–20%, SO₂ concentration in the CASTNet data archive should be adjusted upward. Nylon presents problems as a sampling medium in terms of SO₂ recovery and specificity for HNO₃. Additional comparative sampler evaluation studies are recommended at several sites over each season to permit comprehensive assessment of the concentrations of atmospheric trace constituents archived by CASTNet.     

Sampling of carbonaceous particles in the atmosphere—II

A laboratory study was conducted to test the ability of various sorbents to remove vapor-phase atmospheric carbonaceous materials otherwise retained by sorption on quartz filters, a ‘positive artifact’ in sampling atmospheric particulate C. A dual quartz filter strategy, in which the C recovered from the after-filter is used to correct for the positive artifact, was also assessed. Sorbents such as activated Al₂O₃ and quartz fiber can reduce by up to 60% the positive artifact in sampling at 20 ℓ min⁻ with 47-mm Pallflex 2500 QAO quartz filters. On the assumption, defended herein, that a quartz fiber profilier was unlikely to influence the ratio of C retained by sorption on downstream tandem quartz filters, the dual filter strategy permitted correction for this positive artifact within, on average, 12%. Conclusions from an initial study suggesting extensive loss by volatilization of previously collected particulate C are reassessed.     

Indoor-outdoor Carbon Monoxide Concentrations at Four Sites in Riyadh,Saudi Arabia

Abstract

Nylon filters are a popular medium to collect atmospheric fine particles in different aerosol monitoring networks, including those operated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Interagency Monitoring of Protected Visual Environments (IMPROVE) program. Extraction of the filters by deionized water or by a basic aqueous solution (typically a mixture of sodium carbonate and sodium bicarbonate) is often performed to permit measurement of the inorganic ion content of the collected particles. Whereas previous studies have demonstrated the importance of using a basic solution to efficiently extract gaseous nitric acid collected using nylon filters, there has been a recent movement to the use of deionized water for extraction of particles collected on nylon filters to eliminate interference from sodium ion (Na⁺) during ion chromatographic analysis of inorganic aerosol cations. Results are reported here from a study designed to investigate the efficiency of deionized water extraction of aerosol nitrate (NO₃ ^?) and sulfate from nylon filters. Data were obtained through the conduct of five field experiments at selected IMPROVE sites. Results indicate that the nylon filters provide superior retention of collected fine particle NO₃ ^?, relative to Teflon filters, and that deionized water extraction (with ultrasonication) of collected NO₃ ^? and sulfate is as efficient, for the situations studied, as extraction using a basic solution of 1.7 mM sodium bicarbonate and 1.8 mM sodium carbonate.     

Use of Two Different Acidic Aerosol Samplers To Measure Acidic Aerosols in Hsinchu,Taiwan

ABSTRACT

Acidic aerosol concentrations measured by an annular denuder system (ADS) and a honeycomb denuder system (HDS) in Hsinchu, Taiwan, were compared. Aerosols were also sampled by a MOUDI (micro-orifice uniform deposit impactor) and analyzed by an ion chromatograph to determine the size distributions of different species. Using the measured aerosol size distribution, theoretical analysis showed that positive HNO₃ artifact due to volatiliza-tion of NH₄NO₃ is generally negligible for both samplers.4 3Comparing two different denuder samplers, the average concentration of HNO₃ measured by the ADS was found3to be lower than that measured by the HDS, while the difference between the two samplers for the average concentration of other species was found to be within ±15%. A possible cause of the difference in HNO₃ con-3centrations is due to a greater loss of HNO₃ in the cyclone3 used by the ADS than in the impactor used by the HDS. The study also showed incomplete absorption of the evaporated HCl and HNO₃ from the particles on the Teflon3filter by the first nylon filter in the filter pack of the ADS. Collection efficiency and capacity of HCl and HNO₃ by3the nylon filters need further investigation.     

Performance Characterization and Optimization of the AgNO3-Filter/FMA Fluorimetric Method for Atmospheric H2S Measurements

This sensitive, albeit precarious, method for measuring ppb-ppt (V/V) concentrations of H₂S was examined for various sources of potential error within the procedure. Filter preparation, filter storage, filter extraction, fluorimetric reagent stabilities, matrix differences between standards and samples, and possible interferences from other sulfur-containing compounds were separately studied for their effects on the analytical performance of the method. The overall method showed no Interference from SO₂, CS₂, COS, CH₃SH, CH₃SCH₃, and SO₄ ^-2. To minimize bias and obtain a reliable estimate of precision, the method should be calibrated with H₂S standards rather than liquid bisulfide standards. The measurement precision is a function of the quantity of H₂S collected as Ag₂S and/or AgSH on the impregnated filters. Because of the method’s linear dynamic range, sufficient air should be sampled to achieve filter loadings of 15 to 35 ng S/filter. A quality control method based on fluorescein mercuric acetate (FMA) is presented that ensures data quality while reducing the otherwise frequent need for fluori-metric calibration.     

Comparing field performances of denuder techniques in the high Arctic

A field evaluation between two annular denuder configurations was conducted during the spring of 2003 in the marine Arctic at Ny-Ålesund, Svalbard. The IIA annular denuder system (ADS) employed a series of five single-channel annular denuders, a cyclone and a filter pack to discriminate between gas and aerosol species, while the EPA-Versatile Air Pollution Sampler (VAPS) configuration used a single multi-channel annular denuder to protect the integrity of PM_2.5 sample filters by collecting acidic gases. We compared the concentrations of gaseous nitric acid (HNO₃), nitrous acid (HONO), sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and hydrochloric acid (HCl) measured by the two systems. Results for HNO₃ and SO₂ suggested losses of gas phase species within the EPA-VAPS inlet surfaces due to low temperatures, high relative humidities, and coarse particle sea-salt deposition to the VAPS inlet during sampling. The difference in HNO₃ concentrations (55%) between the two data sets might also be due to the reaction between HNO₃ and NaCl on inlet surfaces within the EPA-VAPS system. Furthermore, we detected the release of HCl from marine aerosol particles in the EPA-VAPS inlet during sampling contributing to higher observed concentrations. Based on this work we present recommendations on the application of denuder sampling techniques for low-concentration gaseous species in Arctic and remote marine locations to minimize sampling biases. We suggest an annular denuder technique without a large surface area inlet device in order to minimize retention and/or production of gaseous atmospheric pollutants during sampling.     

Characterization of Several Integrative Sampling Methods for Nitric Acid,Sulphur Dioxide and Atmospheric Particles

Laboratory and field experiments were performed to evaluate integrative measurement methods for atmospheric nitrates, sulphate and sulphur dioxide. Denuder tubes and several filter media were tested under laboratory and field conditions. Effects of sampling variables such as temperature and relative humidity, flow rates, concentration, loading capacity and artifacts due to NO, NO₂ and SO₂ were also evaluated. The integrative filter sampling method and the ion chromatographic analytical procedure gave a measurement precision (relative standard deviation) of ±11.5 percent for particulate NO₃ ^? on Teflon and ±15.6 percent for gaseous HNO₃ on nylon; for both these constituents, the detection limit was about 0.1 μ m^?3.     

The Aerosol Research and Inhalation Epidemiology Study (ARIES): PM25 Mass and Aerosol Component Concentrations and Sampler Intercomparisons

ABSTRACT

The Aerosol Research and Inhalation Epidemiology Study (ARIES) was designed to provide high-quality measurements of PM₂₅, its components, and co-varying pollutants for an air pollution epidemiology study in Atlanta, GA.

Air pollution epidemiology studies have typically relied on available data on particle mass often collected using filter-based methods. Filter-based PM_2.5 sampling is susceptible to both positive and negative errors in the measurement of aerosol mass and particle-phase component concentrations in the undisturbed atmosphere. These biases are introduced by collection of gas-phase aerosol components on the filter media or by volatilization of particle phase components from collected particles. As part of the ARIES, we collected daily 24-hr PM_2.5 mass and speciation samples and continuous PM_2.5 data at a mixed residential-light industrial site in Atlanta. These data facilitate analysis of the effects of a wide variety of factors on sampler performance. We assess the relative importance of PM_2.5 components and consider associations and potential mechanistic linkages of PM_2.5 mass concentrations with several PM_2.5 components.

For the 12 months of validated data collected to date (August 1, 1998-July 31, 1999), the monthly average Federal Reference Method (FRM) PM_{2 5} mass always exceeded the proposed annual average standard (12-month average = 20.3 ± 9.5 ug/m³). The particulate SO₄ ^2- fraction (as (NH₄)₂SO₄) was largest in the summer and exceeded 50% of the FRM mass. The contribution of (NH₄)₂SO₄ to FRM PM_2.5 mass dropped to less than 30% in winter. Particu-late NO₃ ^- collected on a denuded nylon filter averaged 1.1 ± 0.9 ug/m³. Particle-phase organic compounds (as organic carbon × 1.4) measured on a denuded quartz filter sampler averaged 6.4 ± 3.1 ug/m³ (32% of FRM PM_{2 5} mass) with less seasonal variability than SO₄ ^2-.     

Measurement of Trace Levels of Atmospheric Sulfur Dioxide with a Gold Film Sensor

The mercury translation principle, wherein S(IV) reacts with Hg(l) to produce Hg(ll) and Hg(O), was utilized to measure trace levels of SO₂ with a conductometric gold film sensor. One approach involved impregnated glass fiber filters containing mercurous salts. The second and more successful approach utilized a porous membrane reactor where the reaction occurs in the interstitial liquid-gas interface as the sample gas flows inside and a dilute solution of Hg₂(NO₃)₂ flows outside the porous PTFE membrane tube. The first approach attained a LOD of 200 pptv SO₂(g), however, batch to batch reproducibility of the filters was poor and the filters could not be stored more than two days. The membrane reactor method provided better translation efficiency and highly reproducible results, with an LOD of 50 pptv SO₂(g). An intercomparlson of this method with an independent method relying on completely different chemistry showed good agreement for the measurement of subppbv levels of ambient SO₂. Both mercury translation methods were essentially unaffected by H₂S or CH₃SH.     

Effect of Flue Dust on the Vanadium Oxide Catalyst Utilized by the Contact Oxidation Process

Concepts for controlling SO₂ from fossil fuels can be separated into two main categories: (1) Residual and vacuum gas oil desulfurization and (2) Flue gas desulfurization. The Kiyoura-T.I.T. process confines itself to the desulfurization of flue gas. It employs vandium oxide as a catalyst which oxidizes the sulfur dioxide to trioxide, followed by a gaseous phase reaction of ammonia. The end product, ammonium sulfate is removed by an electrostatic precipitator. (The details were presented at annual meetings of APCA in 1966 and 1967 as 1 and II.) Flue gas is passed through cyclone and dust filter to remove dust. Under normal operating conditions almost all of the dust is removed at the filters. The author carried out experiments to determine whether there was any effect on the activity of the catalyst, assuming that a portion of the dust escapes into the stream along the flue. It has been generally accepted that in fuel oil firing steam power plants, about 100 mg./nm³ of dust including carbon, hydrocarbon, and ash are normally contained in the flue stream. The carbon and hydrocarbon is oxidized readily at the filters and exists only as ash. An amount of ash equivalent to the amount assumed to have settled on the catalyst over a period of 3–12 months, was placed on the catalyst, and experiments were carried out. The SO₂ conversion efficiency was measured and found to be over 93%. The results showed that at the actual operational temperature of 450°C, ash had practically no effect at all.     

Sorption of SO2 on Ground Nahcolite Ore

Large quantities of nahcolite ore, a naturally occurring mineral containing between 70 and 90% sodium bicarbonate are known to occur in the Green River Formation of the Piceance Creek Basin of northwestern Colorado.¹ Deposits occur in two major forms, as either bedded or disseminated ore. In the latter case, the host rock is oil shale, a dolomitic marlstone containing kerogen material. Bench and pilot scale studies have shown finely divided nahcolite ore to be an effective SO₂ sorbent in baghouse filters.² These studies form the basis of the nahcolite ore injection process as a means for controlling SO₂ emissions to the environment.³ Although there have been published investigations of reactions of SO₂ with Na₂CO₃and NaHCO_3, ⁴ no reference could be found to a systematic study of nahcolite ore reacting with SO₂.     

Measurements of nitric acid and ammonium salts in lower Bavaria

Nitric acid and ammonium-containing particulate species were measured by the annular denuder-filter pack technique at Manndorf, a rural site in South Germany, in July 1990. The analyses of filter packs indicated that nitrate was present as ammonium salt which mostly dissociated during sampling. Moreover, due to the NH⁺₄/NO⁻₃ ratios higher than unity found in back-up filters, NH₄Cl was assumed to represent an appreciable fraction of the total particulate ammonium. Finally, the molar ratios NH⁺₄/SO²⁻₄ found on front (Teflon) filters, suggested a large predominance of (NH₄)₂SO₄ among the different forms of sulphate. The concentration levels of gaseous HNO₃ observed in the daytime were characterised by a maximum after midday, whereas particulate nitrate showed five times out of eight days an opposite trend with early afternoon minima. The total nitrate (HNO₃+NH₄NO₃) showed in turn a diurnal pattern similar to that of sulphate. These findings led to the conclusion that a significant HNO₃ production pathway involved the thermal dissociation of NH₄NO₃ rather than the reaction of NO₂ with OH radical.     

Carbon Disulfide and Hydrogen Sulfide Removal with a Peat Biofilter

ABSTRACT

Simultaneous removal of H₂S and CS₂ was studied with a peat biofilter inoculated with a Thiobacillus strain that oxidizes both compounds in an acidic environment. Both sulfurous gases at concentrations below 600 mg S/m³ were efficiently removed, and the removal efficiencies were similar, 99%, with an empty bed retention time (EBRT) of more than 60 sec. Concentrations greater than 1300-5000 mg S/m³ caused overloading of the filter material, resulting in high H₂SO₄ production, accumulation of elemental sulfur, and reduced removal efficiency. The highest sulfur removal rate achieved was 4500 g-S/day/m³ filter material. These results indicate that peat is suitable as a biofilter material for the removal of a mixture of H₂S and CS₂ when concentrations of gases to be purified are low (less than 600 mg/m³), but it is still odorous and toxic to the environment and humans.     

Description and intercomparison of techniques to measure n and s compounds in the Western Atlantic Ocean experiment

The data set of N and S compound measurements from WATOX-85 has been examined in detail to assess that data quality and suitability for use in addressing the goals of the Western Atlantic Ocean Experiment. Accuracy estimates for particulate SO₄²⁻ and NO₃⁻, SO₂ and HNO₃ have been made on the basis of the investigators' estimates and the results of intercomparisons. Intercomparisons of ground-based particulate SO₄²⁻ and all filter SO₂ and HNO₃ measurements show them to be consistent with the 20% accuracies quoted by the investigators. Ground-based particulate NO₃⁻ and aircraft particulate SO₄²⁻ show inconsistencies such that the accuracies can be no better than 28% and the aircraft particulate NO₃ has an accuracy of no better than 60%.