漓江流域δD和δ18O对蒸发的指示作用

以漓江流域为例查明不同水体之间氢氧稳定同位素组成特征,并探讨氢氧稳定同位素对漓江流域的蒸发过程指示作用.结果表明：流域内不同水体之间,氢氧稳定同位素表现出不同的组成特征,地表水和地下水,在丰水期δD值和δ¹⁸O值要比枯水期更容易富集,地下水的δD值和δ¹⁸O值分布范围较地表水小;随着水温的升高,δ¹⁸O的变化趋势比d-excess明显.从漓江上游到下游高程逐渐下降,河水线的斜率和截距也在逐渐减小,其中漓江下游河水线的斜率和截距要低于当地大气降水线,表明下游受到蒸发作用较强烈;地下河水线、地表河水线在一定程度上偏离当地大气降水线,但偏离程度较小,表明三者之间有很好的水力联系.受温度和湿度的共同影响,漓江干流丰水期河水的蒸发量占最初水体总量的0.7%~9.1%,枯水期河水的蒸发量占最初水体总量的2.6%~9.7%,丰水期的蒸发比例低于枯水期,从上游到下游蒸发比例在逐渐上升.研究区蒸发量估算值为959.40mm,与多年实测值少43.11mm,相对误差4.70%.氢氧稳定同位素对研究区降水、地表水、地下水之间的转换规律具有重要的实际意义,在今后的漓江流域水文研究中有着更加广阔的空间.     

闪电河流域“三水”氢氧同位素特征及水体转换分析

通过采集闪电河流域2020年2月至2022年2月的降水与2021年的丰(8月)和枯(10月)水期的地表水和地下水,运用稳定同位素技术,对流域“三水”的氢氧稳定同位素进行时空变化分析,探讨水体同位素与环境因子的关系,结合HYSPLIT模型追踪大气水汽来源,利用端元混合模型揭示水体转换关系.结果发现,当地降水线的斜率和截距均小于当地大气降水线,水汽主要来自西风水汽、极地气团和东亚季风环流,降水同位素有显著的温度效应;时间上,地表水与地下水同位素在季节变化上均表现出枯水期较丰水期更富集,地表水与地下水d-excess值均低于全球平均值,显现出当地强烈的蒸发作用;空间上,地表水δ¹⁸O值丰枯季节在空间上具有相同的变化特征,呈现上游至下游逐渐富集,地下水δ¹⁸O高值区空间分布不均,地下水δ¹⁸O值随埋深的增加更加贫化;地下水水线斜率最高在丰水期为7.87,与当地大气降水线和地表水水线斜率十分接近,表明丰水期“三水”存在复杂的水力联系.研究区在丰水期地表水主要接受降水的补给,其次是接受地下水的径流补给.研究结果有助于明确闪电河流域同...     

东寨港流域地表水水化学组成特征及其成因

为研究滨海地区地表水资源和红树林生态系统的水环境,利用水化学分析、数理统计和Gibbs水-岩分析模型等方法对东寨港流域内演丰西河和三江河两条河流水体的水化学组成和氢氧稳定同位素特征进行分析,揭示了演丰西河和三江河河流地表水的水化学组成特征,讨论了该区域地表水的水化学组分变化及其控制因素.结果 表明:演丰西河地表水的水化...     

伊洛河流域河水来源及水化学组成控制因素

伊洛河是黄河中游南岸重要支流,由伊河和洛河在洛阳偃师汇合而成.流域上游矿产资源开采活动较多,下游城镇密集,工农业活动分布广泛.为探究不同类型人为活动对伊洛河流域河水水化学组成的影响,分别在丰水期(8月)和平水期(12月)采集伊洛河流域干流和支流河水样品,借助水体氢氧同位素组成和阴阳离子组成的时空分布特征,阐明水体来源以及水化学组成控制因素,说明人为活动的影响途径和方式.结果表明:①洛河干流河水丰水期和平水期δD和δ~(18)O均值分别为-56‰和-7.9‰以及-55‰和-8.1‰,伊河干流河水丰水期和平水期δD和δ~(18)O均值分别为-49‰和-6.9‰以及-53‰和-7.8‰,丰水期和平水期河水主要接受当地大气降水补给;②洛河及伊河干流河水水化学类型均为HCO_3-SO_4-Ca-Mg型,丰水期干流河水Ca~(2+)和HCO~-_3当量浓度占比低于平水期,而丰水期SO_4~(2-)当量浓度占比则高于平水期,显示丰水期较多硫酸盐输入;③碳酸和硫酸参与流域内碳酸盐岩和硅酸盐岩风化过程,洛河流域碳酸盐岩风化较明显,伊河流域硅酸盐岩风化较明显;④伊洛河流域人为输入影响表现在上游河水水化学组成受到金属矿产采选活动影响,下游河水水化学组成受工业废水和城镇生活污水的影响;⑤伊洛河流域上游和下游两种不同类型人为活动是河水硫酸盐硫同位素组成空间上变化的重要原因,上游河水硫酸盐硫同位素组成偏负,证实来自硫化物矿物氧化过程产生的硫酸盐贡献较大,进而间接证实硫酸参与岩石化学风化过程.下游河水硫酸盐硫同位素值偏正,与工业废水和城镇生活污水有关.     

疏勒河上游地表水水化学主离子特征及其控制因素

在系统收集了疏勒河流域上游河水、地下水、降水和冰雪融水水样的基础上,综合运用描述性统计、Gibbs图和Piper阴阳离子三角图等方法,对疏勒河上游地表水中主离子组成特征及其控制因素进行了分析.结果表明,流域内不同水体(大气降水、河水和地下水)之间的主离子组成以及水化学类型差异显著.河水TDS的变化范围为51.7~432.3 mg·L-1,平均值为177.7 mg·L-1;河水中阳离子Ca2+、Mg2+的百分比为45%和31%,优势阴离子为HCO-3,占阴离子总量的75%,河水的水化学类型主要为HCO-3-Ca2+-Mg2+型;河水中主离子浓度值介于大气降水和地下水之间,并且十分接近地下水浓度,说明地表水同时受大气降水和地下水补给并主要依靠地下水补给;地表水样品的水化学组成落在Gibbs分布模型的中翼偏左端,表明研究区的水化学离子组成受到岩石风化作用和蒸发结晶作用的共同影响,且岩石风化作用对水化学离子组成的影响更加显著.     

丹江流域山区地表水-地下水水化学特征及其影响因素

丹江流域是南水北调中线工程重要水源涵养区,深入研究丹江流域水化学特征及其影响因素,对区域水资源保护及合理利用具有重要意义.通过对丹江流域水样采集与分析,综合运用描述性统计、Piper三线图、Gibbs图、离子比例系数法及氢氧同位素的方法,分析丹江流域水化学特征及其影响因素.结果表明,丹江流域水体整体呈弱碱性,主要水化学类型为HCO3-Ca型,中游离子质量浓度及水化学类型变化频繁.流域水体均受大气降水补给,地表水受蒸发作用影响明显,水化学组分受岩石风化溶解、离子交换和人类活动共同影响. Ca2+和Mg2+源于方解石、白云石及石膏等碳酸盐和硫酸盐矿物溶解,农业活动是水中硝酸盐的主要来源.地表水与地下水频繁转化和支流汇入影响是丹江干流空间分布特征差异化的主要原因.     

瓶装饮用水的水化学、同位素特征及其指示意义

通过对四类(天然矿泉水、纯净水、矿物质水、苏打水)36种品牌瓶装饮用水的水化学与同位素组成的分析,研究了各瓶装饮用水的水化学和同位素组成特征、水文地球化学形成作用及其水源补给循环特征。研究结果表明:瓶装饮用水的TDS变化幅度较大(7.26~638.23mg/L),纯净水和矿物质水的TDS较低(7.26~47.5mg/L),水化学类型以HCO3-Na型为主,其次为HCO3-Ca·Na型和HCO3-Ca型,Gibbs图和离子比例系数揭示了各类饮用水水源在形成过程中所发生的水化学作用;瓶装饮用水中氢氧同位素组成变化幅度较大(δD:-160.21‰~-43.96‰,δ18 O:-20.91‰~-6.00‰),其同位素组成均分布我国大气降水线附近,表明各饮用水水源主要来自于大气降水补给,西南地区水样中氢氧同位素较为贫化(δD:-160.21‰~-83.83‰,δ18 O:-20.91‰~-11.58‰),东南和华北地区则较为富集(δD:-79.68‰~-43.96‰,δ18 O:-10.9‰~-6.00‰),除东北和西北地区,其他地区氘盈余(d值)均低于全球雨水的平均值10‰,反映各水样的补给水源在形成过程中受到蒸发作用的影响;高程和温度与氢氧同位素有较好的相关性,随高度增加或温度降低,瓶装饮用水中δ18 O逐渐贫化。     

新疆喀什三角洲地下水SO2-4化学特征及来源

"水质型"缺水问题是新疆喀什地区水资源紧缺的主要原因之一.位于喀什地区西部的喀什三角洲面积13 329 km~2,73. 2%面积的潜水和53. 2%面积的承压水SO_4~(2-)浓度超过地下水质量Ⅲ类标准,同时伴随有高TDS、高硬度等特征.运用δD、δ~(18)O-H_2O和δ~(34)S-SO_4~(2-)同位素等手段分析地下水SO_4~(2-)化学特征及来源.结果表明:①区内剥蚀山区钙质粉砂岩、钙质细砂岩和石膏等盐类矿物的溶解控制了流域水化学组成,形成了水化学类型以SO_4型为主的地表水和地下水.地下水化学类型演变方向为HCO_3·SO_4→SO_4→SO_4·Cl,山麓斜坡冲洪积砾质平原为溶滤-径流带,河流冲积平原为径流-累积带,上游至下游地下水化学成分趋向盐化;②区内地下水初始补给源主要为大气降水,且受一定蒸发作用影响.不同水文地质单元地下水δD和δ~(18)O分布特征明显,上游至下游,同位素值由低到富集,受蒸发作用由弱到强;冲积平原承压水同位素分布较离散,受到上覆潜水混合作用影响;③南部、北部山麓斜坡冲洪积砾质平原潜水SO_4~(2-)来源分别为海陆交互相和陆相蒸发岩的溶滤;河流冲积平原潜水SO_4~(2-)除了陆相蒸发岩溶滤来源外,还存在化肥淋滤的污染;承压水受蒸发岩溶滤外,还受到潜水的混合作用和细菌还原硫酸盐作用影响.     

南太行山山前平原地下水水化学以及同位素组成研究

采用环境同位素和水化学方法,通过分析南太行山山前平原不同类型水体氢氧稳定同位素(δD和δ18O)、溶解性无机碳同位素(δ~(13)C-DIC)和水化学组成特征,探讨不同水体来源以及人类活动对地下水水质的影响过程。研究区地下水氢氧同位素组成表明,区内地下水均来自大气降水,补给区和排泄区浅部含水层地下水较深部含水层地下水氢、氧同位素值均偏正,氘盈余值(d值)也偏小,显示浅部含水层地下水受蒸发作用影响。同时排泄区地下水氢、氧同位素值较补给区地下水偏正,显示排泄区地下水经历较明显的蒸发过程。研究区地下水溶解性无机碳碳同位素(δ~(13)C-DIC)组成表明,补给区和排泄区浅部含水层地下水δ~(13)C-DIC值较深部含水层δ~(13)C-DIC值均偏负,显示浅部含水层地下水无机碳更多来源于有机物分解。同时排泄区地下水δ~(13)C-DIC值较补给区地下水δ~(13)C-DIC值偏负,表明排泄区地下水溶解性无机碳受有机物分解影响较大。研究区地下水水化学组成表明,补给区地下水水化学类型以Ca-HCO3型为主,排泄区地下水水化学类型以Na-HCO3-SO4型为主。结合同位素组成特征,补给区地下水水化学组成主要受溶滤作用和人类活动的影响,排泄区地下水水化学组成则受溶滤作用、蒸发浓缩作用、阳离子交换作用和人类活动的共同控制。     

青海典型内陆河流域地表水溶解性养分组成及分布特征

为了解青海典型内陆河地表水溶解性养分组成及分布特征,对青海巴音河、格尔木河及小柴旦湖流域地表水进行了采集,分析了地表水溶解性养分的组成及含量。结果表明:巴音河流域溶解性养分N、Si可能受水库滞留效应影响;克鲁克湖有较高的NH_4~+-N含量,主要与渔业养殖有关;格尔木河流域溶解性养分含量从上游到下游有升高的趋势,可能与流域内地形差异以及水体沿途蒸发作用有关;托素湖和小柴旦湖溶解性养分含量远远高于河流,主要与湖泊水体蒸发强烈导致的养分含量浓缩有关。研究区水体溶解性养分含量均大于受限阈值,但河流DIN/SRP 10、DSi/DIN 1,表现为N相对不足,湖泊DSi/SRP 10、DSi/DIN 1,表现为Si相对不足。主成分分析表明河流、水库以及克鲁克湖为Ⅰ～Ⅱ类水体,托素湖、小柴旦湖为Ⅴ类水体。     

Toxic effects of acetochlor, methamidophos and their combination on nifH gene in soil

Toxic effects of two agrochemicals on nifH gene in agricultural black soil were investigated using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis （DGGE） and sequencing approaches in a microcosm experiment. Changes of soil nifH gene diversity and composition were examined following the application of acetochlor, methamidophos and their combination. Acetochlor reduced the nifH gene diversity （both in gene richness and diversity index values） and caused changes in the nifH gene composition. The effects of acetochlor on nifH gene were strengthened as the concentration of acetochlor increased. Cluster analysis of DGGE banding patterns showed that nifH gene composition which had been affected by low concentration of acetochlor （50 mg/kg） recovered firstly. Methamidophos reduced nifH gene richness that except at 4 weeks. The medium concentration of methamidophos （150 mg/kg） caused the most apparent changes in nifH gene diversity at the first week while the high concentration of methamidophos （250 mg/kg） produced prominent effects on nifH gene diversity in the following weeks. Cluster analysis showed that minimal changes of nifH gene composition were found at 1 week and maximal changes at 4 weeks. Toxic effects of acetochlor and methamidophos combination on nifH gene were also apparent. Different nifH genes （bands） responded differently to the impact of agrochemicals： four individual bands were eliminated by the application of the agrochemicals, five bands became predominant by the stimulation of the agrochemicals, and four bands showed strong resistance to the influence of the agrochemicals. Fifteen prominent bands were partially sequenced, yielding 15 different nifH sequences, which were used for phylogenetic reconstructions. All sequences were affiliated with the alpha- and beta-proteobacteria, showing higher similarity to eight different diazotrophic genera.     

Arsenic uptake by arbuscular mycorrhizal maize （Zea mays L.） grown in an arsenic-contaminated soil with added phosphorus

The effects of arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungus (Glomus mosseae) and phosphorus (P) addition (100 mg/kg soil) on arsenic (As) uptake by maize plants (Zea mays L.) from an As-contaminated soil were examined in a glasshouse experiment.Non-mycorrhizal and zero-P addition controls were included.Plant biomass and concentrations and uptake of As,P,and other nutrients,AM colonization,root lengths,and hyphal length densities were determined.The results indicated that addition of P significantly inhibited root colonization and development of extraradical mycelium.Root length and dry weight both increased markedly with mycorrhizal colonization under the zero-P treatments,but shoot and root biomass of AM plants was depressed by P application.AM fungal inoculation decreased shoot As concentrations when no P was added,and shoot and root As concentrations of AM plants increased 2.6 and 1.4 times with P addition,respectively.Shoot and root uptake of P,Mn,Cu,and Zn increased,but shoot Fe uptake decreased by 44.6%,with inoculation, when P was added.P addition reduced shoot P,Fe,Mn,Cu,and Zn uptake of AM plants,but increased root Fe and Mn uptake of the nonmycorrhizal ones.AM colonization therefore appeared to enhance plant tolerance to As in low P soil,and have some potential for the phytostabilization of As-contaminated soil,however,P application may introduce additional environmental risk by increasing soil As mobility.     

Potential of plant polyphenol oxidases in the decolorization and removal of textile and non-textile dyes

In this study an effort has been made to use plant polyphenol oxidases; potato （Solanum tuberosum） and brinjal （Solanum melongena）, for the treatment of various important dyes used in textile and other industries. The ammonium sulphate fractionated enzyme preparations were used to treat a number of dyes under various experimental conditions. Majority of the treated dyes were maximally decolorized at pH 3.0. Some of the dyes were quickly decolorized whereas others were marginally decolorized. The initial first hour was sufficient for the maximum decolorization of dyes. The rate of decolorization was quite slow on long treatment of dyes. Enhancement in the dye decolorization was noticed on increasing the concentration of enzymes. The complex mixtures of dyes were treated with both preparations of polyphenol oxidases in the buffers of varying pH values. Potato polyphenol oxidase was significantly more effective in decolorizing the dyes to higher extent as compared to the enzyme obtained from brinjal polyphenol oxidase. Decolorization of dyes and their mixtures, followed by the formation of an insoluble precipitate, which could be easily removed simply by centrifugation.     

Removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge by low costing chemical method and recycling in agriculture

ＲｅｍｏｖａｌｏｆｈｅａｖｙｍｅｔａｌｓｆｒｏｍｓｅｗａｇｅｓｌｕｄｇｅｂｙｌｏｗｃｏｓｔｉｎｇｃｈｅｍｉｃａｌｍｅｔｈｏｄａｎｄｒｅｃｙｃｌｉｎｇｉｎａｇｒｉｃｕｌｔｕｒｅＷｕＱｉｔａｎｇ，ＮｙｉｒａｎｄｅｇｅＰａｓｃａｓｉｅ，ＭｏＣｅｈｕｉＦ...     

Organochlorine pesticides in soils under different land usage in the Taihu Lake region, China

A field study was conducted in the Taihu Lake region, China in 2004 to reveal the organochlorine pesticide concentrations in soils after the ban of these substances in the year 1983. Thirteen organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) were analyzed in soils from paddy field, tree land and fallow land. Total organochlorine pesticide residues were higher in agricultural soils than in uncultivated fallow land soils. Among all the pesticides, ΣDDX (DDD, DDE and DDT) had the highest concentration for all the soil samples, ranging from 3.10 ng/g to 166.55 ng/g with a mean value of 57.04 ng/g and followed by ΣHCH, ranging from 0.73 ng/g to 60.97 ng/g with a mean value of 24.06 ng/g. Dieldrin, endrin, HCB and α-endosulfan were also found in soils with less than 15 ng/g. Ratios of p,p'-(DDD DDE)/DDT in soils under three land usages were: paddy field ＞ tree land ＞ fallow land, indicating that land usage inlfuenced the degradation of DDT in soils. Ratios of p,p'-(DDD DDE)/DDT ＞1, showing aged residues of DDTs in soils of the Taihu Lake region. The results were discussed with data from a former study that showed very low actual concentrations of HCH and DDT in soils in the Taihu Lake region, but according to the chemical half-lives and their concentrations in soils in 1980s, the concentration of DDT in soils seemed to be underestimated. In any case our data show that the ban on the use of HCH and DDT resulted in a tremendous reduction of these pesticide residues in soils, but there are still high amounts of pesticide residues in soils, which need more remediation processes.     

Single and joint effects of pesticides and mercury on soil urease

The influence of two pesticides including chlorimuron-ethyl and furadan and mercury （Hg） on urease activity in 4 soils （meadow burozem and phaeozem） was investigated. The soils were exposed to various concentrations of the two pesticides and Hg individually and simultaneously. Results showed that there was a close relationship between urease activity and organic matter content in soil. Chlorimuron-ethyl and furadan could both activate urease in the 4 soils. The maximum increment of urease activity by chlorimuronethyl was up to 14%-18%. There was almost an equal increase （up to 13%-21%） in the urease activity by furadan. On the contrary, Hg markedly inhibited soil urease activity. A logarithmic equation was used to describe the relationship （P〈0.05） between the concentration of Hg and the activity of soil urease in the 4 tested soils. Semi-effect dose （ED50） values by the stress of Hg based on the inhibition of soil urease in the 4 soils were 88, 5.5, 24 and 20 mg/kg, respectively, according to the calculation of the corresponding equations. The interactive effect of chlorimuron-ethyl or furadan with metal Hg on soil urease was mainly synergic at the highest tested concentrations.     

Isolation and preliminary characterization of a 3-chlorobenzoate degrading bacteria

A study was conducted to compare the diversity of 2-, 3-, and 4-chlorobenzoate degraders in two pristine soils and one contaminated sewage sludge. These samples contained strikingly different populations of mono-chlorobenzoate degraders. Although fewer cultures were isolated in the uncontaminated soils than contaminated one, the ability of microbial populations to mineralize chlorobenzoate was widespread. The 3- and 4-chlorobenzoate degraders were more diverse than the 2-chlorobenzoate degraders. One of the strains isolated from the sewage sludge was obtained. Based on its phenotype, chemotaxonomic properties and 16S rRNA gene, the organism S-7 was classified as Rhodococcus erythropolis. The strain can grow at temperature from 4 to 37℃. It can utilize several （halo）aromatic compounds. Moreover, strain S-7 can grow and use 3-chlorobenzoate as sole carbon source in a temperatures range of 10-30℃ with stoichiometric release of chloride ions. The psychrotolerant ability was significant for bioremediation in low temperature regions. Catechol and chlorocatechol 1,2-dioxygenase activities were present in cell free extracts of the strain, but no （chloro）catechol 2,3- dioxygenase activities was detected. Spectral conversion assays with extracts from R. erythropolis S-7 showed accumulation of a compound with a similar UV spectrum as chloro-cis,cis-muconate from 3-chlorobenzoate. On the basis of these results, we proposed that S-7 degraded 3-chlorobenzoate through the modified ortho-cleave pathway.     

Alterations of organ histopathology and metallolhionein mRNA expression in silver barb, Puntius gonionotus during subchronic cadmium exposure

Common silver barb,Puntius gonionotus,exposed to the nominal concentration of 0.06 mg/L Cd for 60 d,were assessed for histopathological alterations(gills,liver and kidney),metal accumulation,and metallothionein(MT)mRNA expression.Fish exhibited pathological symptoms such as hypertrophy and hyperplasia of primary and secondary gill lamellae,vacuolization in hepatocytes,and prominent tubular and glomerular damage in the kidney.In addition,kidney accumulated the highest content of cadmium,more than gills and liver.Expression of MT mRNA was increased in both liver and kidney of treated fish.Hepatic MT levels remained high after fish were removed to Cd-free water.In contrast,MT expression in kidney was peaked after 28 d of treatment and drastically dropped when fish were removed to Cd-free water.The high concentrations of Cd in hepatic tissues indicated an accumulation site or permanent damage on this tissue.     

Sorption of 1-naphthol by plant cuticular fractions

The contribution of aliphatic-rich plant biopolymer to sorption of hydrophobic organic compounds is significantly important because of their preservation and accumulation in the soil environment,but sorption mechanism is still not fully understood.In this study, sorption of 1-naphthol by plant cuticular fractions was examined to better understand the contributions of respective fraction.Toward this end,cuticular materials were isolated from the fruits of tomato by chemical method.The tomato cuticle sheet consisted of waxes (6.5 wt%),cuticular monomer (69.5 wt%),and polysaccharide (24.0 wt%).Isotherms of l-naphthol to the cuticular fractions were nonlinear (N value (0.82-0.90)) at the whole tested concentration ranges.The KodKow ratios for bulk cuticle (TC1),dewaxed cuticle (TC2),cutin (TC4),and desugared cuticle (TC5) were larger than unity,suggested that tomato bulk cuticle and cutin are much powerful solption medium.Sorption capability of cutin (TC4) was 2.4 times higher than the nonsaponifiable fraction (TC3).The 1-naphthol interactions with tomato cuticular materials were governed by both hydrophobic-type interactions and polar (H-bonding) interactions. Removal of the wax and polysaccharide materials from the bulk tomato cuticle caused a significant increase in the sorption ability of the cuticular material.There was a linear negative trend between K_(oc) values and the amount of polysaccharides or fraction's polarities ((N O)/C);while a linear positive relationship between K_(oc) values and the content of cutin monomer (linear R~2=0.993) was observed for present in the cuticular fractions.Predominant sorbent of the hydrophobic organic compounds (HOCs) in the plant cuticular fraction was the cutin monomer,contributing to 91.7% of the total sorption of tomato bulk cuticle.     

Seed selections for crystallization of calcium phosphate for phosphorus recovery

Seed induces and promotes the crystallization of calcium phosphate, and acts as carrier of the recovered phosphorus （P）. In order to select suitable seed for P recovery from wastewater, three seeds including Apatite （AP）, Juraperle （JP） and phosphate-modified Juraperle （M-JP） were tested and compared. Batch and fixed-bed column experiments of seeded crystallization of calcium phosphate were undertaken by using synthetic wastewater with 10 mg/L P phosphate. It shows that AP has bad enduring property in the crystallization process, while JP has better performance for multiple uses, and M-JP is a hopeful seed for P recovery by crystallization of calcium phosphate.