Pigeon homing: new airbag experiments to assess the role of olfactory information for pigeon navigation

Summary In three series of experiments we assessed the effects of olfactory and non-olfactory information collected en route or at the release site on the initial orientation of homing pigeons. In the first experiment, pigeons were transported in open crates to two sites located in opposite directions from the home loft. They were left at the site for 1 h, then put into airtight containers filled with air from that site and brought back to the loft. From there, controls were transported back to the original site. Experimentals were transported to the opposite site. Upon arrival at the site, the olfactory mucosae of both groups were anesthetized with Gingicain. Thus in this experiment, control and experimental pigeons were exposed to different olfactory as well as to different non-olfactory information during displacement and at the site. In the second series, controls and experimentals were treated as in the first experiment, except that they were enclosed in the airtight containers at the very beginning of the experiment and were ventilated with synthetic air until arrival at the final release site. This treatment excluded the possibility to perceive olfactory information en route or at the site. In this series, the two groups differed only with respect to non-olfactory information perceived during displacement and/or at the release site. In the third series, we exposed pigeons at the loft to air collected either at the later release site (controls) or to air collected at a site located in opposite direction of the home loft (experimentals). Here the two groups differed only with respect to their exposure to air of different origin. In all three series, the pooled controls showed a directional preference that was statistically indistinguishable from the home direction. All three experimental groups were disoriented. In the first two series, the differences in the initial orientation of control and experimental pigeons were highly significant. In the third experiment, there was only very weak statistical evidence for a difference between controls and experimentals. These results suggest that more than one factor is involved in the pigeons' navigation system. According to the present experiment with synthetic air, pigeons probably gather and process non-olfactory information during the first part of their transport from the home loft to the release site. Thus, some kind of, in this case non-olfactory, route reversal seems to be involved in the homing process. In addition, the experiment involving only manipulations of airborne information indicated some olfactory component. Previous experiments at our loft did not result in disorientation of the pigeons if either only the access to airborne information had been removed or when otherwise unmanipulated pigeons had been transported in detours to the final release site. Therefore, we assume that our pigeons' navigation system relies on several cues. Deletion of one cue can be compensated by other information. Often the initial orientation of our pigeons is disturbed only when at least one cue is removed and another one provides false information.     

Can pigeons be fooled about the actual release site position by presenting them information from another site?

Summary The aim of the experiment was to test the hypothesis that pigeons depend on route- and/or site-specific airborne parameters to establish their position relative to the loft. Pigeons were transported to the release site with free access to the environmental air. They were then enclosed in large airtight containers filled with air from the release site and either transported via the loft to a release site in the opposite direction with respect to the loft (experimental birds) or via the loft back to the same site (control birds). Before release the pigeons (still inside the containers) were made anosmic by a local anesthetic applied to the olfactory membranes through the nostrils. Vanishing bearings of experimental birds were on the average in a direction opposite to home while the vanishing bearings of control birds were homeward oriented. For this initial orientation the pigeons seem to rely on airborne cues obtained at a site where they last had access to ambient air or cues obtained from the air inside the sealed containers. Irrespective of the treatment the bearings pooled with respect to north still show a residual orientation to the NE. There was no difference either in the homing speeds or in the homing times of anosmic control and experimental pigeons. We therefore have to assume further mechanisms guiding the pigeons home in addition to a possibly olfactory one.     

Pigeon homing: Olfactory orientation—a paradox

Summary In order to find out whether the different ways that pigeons are raised and maintained at the various lofts affect their orientation behavior, especially the selection of navigational factors, a group of birds was raised according to the procedures of our Italian colleagues in a wind-exposed loft on the roof. The behavior of these R-birds was then compared with that of G-birds living in a garden loft, raised and trained according to the normal Frankfurt procedure. When R-birds were made anosmic by closing the nostril with cotton during transportation and a local anesthetic was used at release, their reaction was similar to that of Italian pigeons: the deviation of their vanishing bearings from the home direction increased significantly, leading to a marked decrease in homeward orientation. In contrast, the orientation of the anosmic G-birds did not differ from that of their controls; their directional selections agreed with those of the controls of the R-group. These data indicate that the conditions of raising and maintaining homing pigeons may be of crucial importance in determining the pigeons' attitude toward olfactory input. Finally, olfactory orientation is discussed; the paradoxical finding that the G-birds, not using olfaction, oriented like the controls of the R-group that did use olfactory input, leads to the question of whether olfactory input really conveys navigational information to the birds.     

Pigeon homing in relation to geomagnetic,gravitational, topographical,and meteorological conditions

Summary Experienced homing pigeons were released at sites unfamiliar to them and with magnetic and gravity anomalies as well as in areas with rather normal fields throughout the FRG (41 releases when sunny, 14 when overcast; Figs. 1–3). The second-order release data were subjected to both univariate and multivariate statistical analysis (stepwise regression, factor analysis). The magnetic field strength and its gradients within the 1-km circle around the release site were determined from aeromagnetic maps of the anomalies of magnetic total intensity. Analogous variables were derived from gravity anomaly maps. It was tested whether the pigeons fly along that gradient to minimize the difference between the magnetic or gravity field at the release site and the loft at maximum rate. Further independent variables described magnetic K index, day-to-day variations of the magnetic components, topography, meteorological conditions, the number of the releases the pigeons had done, and the distance.Over magnetic anomalies widely varying in strength (departing – 250 nT to 300 nT from normal 600 m above ground), extent, and distance from loft, the pigeons vanished with less deviation from the homeward direction and faster than they did in areas with less irregular fields under sunny conditions; this is in contrast to other studies on magnetic anomalies, except one. At sites of gravity anomalies (15–49 mgal), the pigeons were significantly less homeward oriented and homed slower than at less anomalous sites (–9 to 14 mgal).Variables related to gravity were best predictors in 8 and and second predictors in 3 out of 15 regression analyses of the navigational parameters for the releases under sun. Six times the (absolute) amount of the gravity difference between the release site and the loft was selected first (Figs. 7B, C, 8B, C). The results suggest gravity to be involved in navigation as the pigeons' distance measure. Homeward directedness declined with increasing amount of the gravity gradient in the first 12 releases under sunny skies as well as when overcast (Fig. 8A). A preferred compass direction towards north-northeast was determined, being closest to the grand mean vector of the ascending gravity gradient (Fig. 6). The analyses failed to show directional preferences as assumed by the hypotheses tested. Temperature and degree of cloud cover provided some information for predicting mean vector lengths and mean vanishing times, respectively. The surface wind component in the homeward direction was correlated with median homing performances.     

Initial orientation of homing pigeons at the magnetic equator with and without sun compass

Summary To test the present hypotheses concerning the functioning of the bird's magnetic compass, pigeons reared near the magnetic and geographic equator (Fortaleza, NE Brasil) were released 300 km NW of their home in the horizontal field at the magnetic equator. Pigeons released in the morning and in the afternoon were roughly homeward oriented whereas pigeons released at noon with the sun near the zenith vanished close to magnetic north. According to the Wiltschko model of the magnetic compass they should not be able to pick up specific directions. A considerable number of young and inexperienced pigeons returned home against a continuously blowing trade wind. This result contradicts the hypothesis of olfactory navigation as currently discussed.     

Geographical and temporal variability in pigeon homing

Summary Young homing pigeons from the same German stocks were housed in two lofts, one in southern Germany, near Munich, and one in Italy, near Pisa. In the course of 1 year, two synchronized releases at sites 22–25 km NNW and SSE from each of the lofts were conducted every month. The pigeons that returned were released a second time at a site about 75 km east of home.Both initial homeward orientation and homing success were considerably better in Italy than in Germany. Annual cycles, with maxima in summer and minima in winter, were observed in both countries. They were most pronounced in initial orientation in Italy and in homing performance in Germany. Correlations between homing parameters and ambient temperature correspond to the annual cycles, but they do not indicate that the geographical and seasonal differences in homing behaviour are directly caused by actual temperature at the time of release.Our findings (together with earlier ones) suggest that environmental conditions may be variably conducive to the homeward orientation of pigeons according to spatial and temporal variations in the climate.     

The development of sun compass orientation in young homing pigeons

Summary A series of clock-shift experiments with young homing pigeons of various ages was performed to determine at what age they normally learn sun compass orientation. The response of untrained pigeons to shifting of their internal clock seems to depend on their age. When the clock-shifted birds were tested at an age of 11 weeks and younger, their departure bearings did not differ significantly from those of controls (Fig. 1, diagrams on the right); in tests with birds 12 weeks and older the characteristic deviation indicating the use of the sun compass was observed (Figs. 2 and 3). Birds that had participated in a short training program, however, used the sun compass at 8 weeks, the earliest age tested (Fig. 1, diagrams on the left). These findings show that the time of development of the sun compass strongly depends on flying experience. Within the first months of a bird's life, it seems to take place after the bird has been confronted with the need to orient, either spontaneously during extended exercise flights around its loft or imposed by training releases.The departure bearings of the very young, inexperienced birds that did not rely on the sun compass, however, were already oriented homeward. This indicates that the ability to navigate develops independently of the sun compass, before the sun compass is learned.Dedicated to Prof. Dr. F.W. Merkel for his 70th birthday     

Pigeon navigation: Charcoal filter removes relevant information from environmental air

Summary Homing pigeons were displaced and kept until they were released in airtight containers ventilated with environmental air that could be passed through: (a) a filter made of fiberglass paper retaining large portions of the solid and liquid aerosol particles, (b) an additional filter consisting of activated charcoal, or (c) no filter (controls). Before its release, each bird was taken out of the container, and its olfactory epithelium was immediately anesthetized by lidocaine (Xylocaine). Thus, neither experimentals nor controls were able to smell while their initial orientation behavior was being observed.The controls' initial bearings were better homeward-oriented than those of pigeons ventilated with charcoal-filtered air in 14 of 17 releases conducted in Italy and Germany, at distances of 24–155 km. In the final analysis, the bearings of the charcoal-filter birds did not show any relation to the direction toward home, whereas those of the controls did. Pigeons ventilated with air that had passed through only the paper filter did not behave noticeably differently from control pigeons.It is concluded that the material bases of olfactory navigation in pigeons are substances dispersed in the atmosphere, most probably in a molecular state.     

Magnetic compass mediates nocturnal homing by the alpine newt, Triturus alpestris

Experiments were carried out to investigate the use of magnetic compass cues in the nocturnal homing orientation of the alpine newt Triturus alpestris. Tests were carried out at a site 9 km to the east–northeast of the breeding pond. Newts were tested at night in an outdoor circular arena that provided an unimpeded view of celestial cues, in one of four symmetrical alignments of an earth-strength magnetic field. In tests carried out under partly cloudy skies newts exhibited homeward magnetic compass orientation. Because the moon was visible in some trials, but obscured by clouds in others, we investigated whether the presence of the moon contributed to the scatter in the distribution of magnetic bearings. When the moon was visible, the distribution of magnetic bearings was more scattered than when the moon was obscured by clouds, although in neither case was the distribution significant due, in part, to the small sample sizes. Moreover, when the moon was visible, newts oriented along a bimodal axis perpendicular to the moon azimuth, suggesting that the presence of the moon may have affected the newts behavior. To provide a more rigorous test of the role of magnetic compass cues when celestial cues were unavailable, nocturnal tests were carried out during the following migratory season under total overcast. In the absence of celestial compass cues, the distribution of magnetic bearings exhibited highly significant orientation in the homeward direction. These findings indicate that newts are able to orient in the homeward direction at night using the magnetic compass as the sole source of directional information. Moon light altered the newts behavior. However, this apparently resulted from the asymmetrical distribution of moon light in the testing arena, rather than the use of an alternative compass.     

Pigeon homing: a comparison between groups raised under different conditions

Summary The homing ability of a group of pigeons raised under conditions of continuous exposure to windborne information was compared to that of another group subjected to exposure to winds only during the time spent in pre-test training flights. The results of release experiments at sites that were unfamiliar to the pigeons show that both bird groups, which had been made temporarily anosmic, had impaired initial homeward orientation and homing ability. These results, which do not entirely concur with the recent findings of Wiltschko and his coworkers, show that the raising and training procedures we used do not influence the nature of the cues used in pigeon homing. If the exposure of birds to wind-borne information is reduced, this does not bring into play any effective non-olfactory mechanisms of navigation; it simply hinders the development of the olfactory map and impairs the homing ability. Offprint requests to: S. Benvenuti     

Homing behaviour in the sleepy lizard (Tiliqua rugosa): the role of visual cues and the parietal eye

To investigate how visual cues are integrated into a navigational strategy for homing in the Australian sleepy lizard (Tiliqua rugosa), lizards were displaced beyond their home range, either with full access to visual cues or with no access to visual cues during the displacement. Homeward orientation was significantly worse when lizards were denied visual cues during the displacement than when they were not. However when lizards were displaced with their field of view restricted to the sky, their homeward orientation was equally as good as that of lizards displaced with no visual restriction. These experiments suggest that sleepy lizards use celestial cues to determine the compass bearing of the outward journey, and reverse this bearing to orient in the homeward direction (course reversal). In a subsequent experiment, lizards oriented randomly with respect to home when the parietal eye was entirely covered with a patch during the displacement and return, while control lizards fitted with a sham parietal eye patch were well oriented towards home. In both groups, the lateral eyes were unobstructed and had complete access to visual cues including celestial cues and landmarks. These results suggest that the parietal eye plays a highly significant role in sleepy lizard homing, perhaps mediating a sky polarization compass sense.     

Do bearing magnets affect the extent of deflection in clock-shifted homing pigeons?

When released after clock-shift, homing pigeons fail to orient towards the home direction but display a consistent deflection of their initial orientation due to the difference between the real sun azimuth and the computed azimuth according to the subjective time of each single bird. It has been reported that the size of the observed deflection is frequently smaller than expected and a discussion on the possible factors affecting the size of deflection has emerged. Some authors have proposed that the major factor in reducing the deflection after clock-shift is the simultaneous use of both the magnetic and the sun compasses, giving true and erroneous information, respectively, about the home direction. Therefore, a magnetic disturbance, by impeding the use of the geomagnetic information in determining the home direction, is presumed to increase the size of the deflection up to the levels of the expectation. To test this hypothesis, we released three groups of clock-shifted birds from unfamiliar locations (unmanipulated pigeons, pigeons bearing magnets on their head, and pigeons bearing magnets on their back) together with a group of unshifted control birds. As no difference in the orientation of the three groups emerged, we were not able to confirm the hypothesis of the role of the magnetic compass in reducing the expected deflection after clock-shift.Communicated by W. Wiltschko     

Orientation behavior of homing pigeons at the Gernsheim anomaly

Pigeons were released at four release sites within the Gernsheim anomaly, a magnetic 'hill' with a peak 199 nT above the regional reference field and gentle 'slopes' to all sides, situated 44 km south of the Frankfurt loft. Local magnetic conditions at the sites differed in total intensity and in direction and steepness of the intensity gradient. At all sites, the pigeons were well oriented, showing counterclockwise deviations from the home directions that were most pronounced in the western part of the anomaly. There was no systematic difference in orientation behavior or homing performance between the sites within the anomaly and a control site outside. No effect of the local gradient direction was found, nor did the difference in intensity between home loft and the release site affect behavior. This argues against the use of magnetic navigational factors. However, pigeons released for the first time within the anomaly tended to have longer mean vectors with increasingly steeper gradients, which could mean that the birds might somehow have realized the anomalous nature of the local magnetic conditions and ignored them, relying on non-magnetic cues instead.Communicated by R. Gibson     

Variation in homeward orientation performance in the sleepy lizard (Tiliqua rugosa): effects of sex and reproductive period

Sleepy lizards are monogamous skinks which show high pair fidelity. This study reveals inter- and intrasexual differences in homeward orientation performance in this lizard. Male and female lizards were displaced during three phases of the spring activity period, the pre-pairing, pairing/mating, and post-pairing periods. All groups (with the exception of post-pairing males) were significantly oriented homewards, but males were significantly better oriented towards home than females during the pairing period. Furthermore, males were significantly better homeward oriented during the pre-pairing and pairing periods than in the post-pairing period. Similar results were observed for rate of movement away from the release site. In sleepy lizards, sex-based differences in homing behaviour are unlikely to be attributable to differences in the area of familiarity, or availability of orientation mechanisms. However differences in homing motivation may explain these differences. Males may miss mating if absent from the home range during the pre-pairing and pairing periods, while females may still be able to obtain a mating even when absent. Females however may be more motivated than males to return to the familiar home range during the post-pairing period to ensure efficient feeding during internal embryo development. Received: 16 February 1998 / Accepted after revision: 28 March 1998     

Homing behavior of wood thrushes (Hylocichla mustelina)

Summary Using the wood thrush (Hylocichla mustelina) as an example of a typical nocturnal migrant, we employed radio telemetry to follow breeding birds during the course of homing movements following displacements. Seven thrushes were displaced over distances of 6.5 to 17.3 km in a variety of directions from their nesting territories. The thrushes moved in a series of short flights (mean = 2.1 km) performed primarily at dawn. Consequently, the birds took several days to home from even these relatively short displacements. Thrushes flew under clear and solid overcast skies and even in light rain. The pooled individual flights of the birds were significantly oriented in the homeward direction (Fig. 2). Their orientation relative to home did not improve significantly as they progressed toward the goal. Three of the birds were documented to have returned to their home territories. The detailed tracks of the birds preclude the possibility that they homed by random search.     

Orientation of homing pigeons at magnetic anomalies

Summary Young homing pigeons released at a site on the edge of a magnetic anomaly and then in the center of the anomaly show better orientation at the anomalous site than birds released there for the first time. To test the possibility that this improvement is the result of birds learning to obtain navigational information at magnetic anomalies, several groups of pigeons were trained at a series of different anomalies, in different directions from their home loft. When these birds were than tested at an unfamiliar anomaly they were disoriented. They showed no evidence of having learned to obtain navigational information at magnetic anomalies. It is suggested that the disorientation seen at anomalies may be due to a disturbance of position-fixing information at the release site.     

The scent of dominance: female field crickets use odour to predict the outcome of male competition

Pheromones may convey information about mate quality and social status. In the field cricket Gryllus integer, females mount the males for copulation, such that males cannot coerce females to mate. We examined whether virgin G. integer females preferred the scent of potentially dominant males to that of subordinate males. First, we collected pheromones by confining males on filter paper. Next, we offered filter paper from each of two size-matched males and control paper to females that had never been exposed to males, and measured the time spent by the female on each kind of paper. Finally, dominance status of the males in each size-matched pair was determined by pitting the two males against one another in agonistic contests. When offered filter paper from subsequently dominant versus subsequently subordinate males, females spent more time on the paper from the dominant male than the subordinate male, and much less time on control paper. Thus, pheromones may inform female G. integer about a male's potential to achieve dominant social status. Male pheromones were also associated with the female's tendency to mount a male. In contrast to cockroaches, where females prefer the scent of subordinate males (presumably to avoid risk of injury), female crickets prefer the scent of potentially dominant males and are more likely than males to wound their mating partners.     

Does reproductive state affect a lizard's behavior toward predator chemical cues?

We examined how reproductive state affected shifts in behavior of adult female Podarcis sicula toward chemical cues from a natural snake predator (Coronella austriaca). The oviparous P. sicula lizards do not experience a major physical burden during reproduction, but gravid females substantially increase duration of basking. Therefore, gravid lizards are likely to experience a greater risk of mortality because they are exposed to predators for longer periods. Both gravid and non-gravid females shifted patterns of locomotion when confronted with snake chemical cues, but the change was notably larger when females were non-gravid. When non-gravid, lizards responded to predator scent by increasing the number of stand-ups and starts, while such a response was not observed when females were gravid. By contrast, gravid lizards clearly reduced the time spent basking in the presence of predator scent, whereas no change in basking behavior was observed when females were non-gravid. Thus, females exhibit differential behavioral responses to predator scents that is dependent on reproductive state.     

Pigeon homing: Different effects of olfactory deprivation in different countries

Summary This study compares the orientation of untreated pigeons and pigeons subjected to olfactory deprivation at two lofts near Pisa, Italy, at a loft at Ithaca, New York, USA, and at a loft at Frankfurt a.M., FRG. The experimental birds were rendered anosmic by nasal plugs until Gingicain, a local anaesthetic, was applied shortly before release. The Italian and American control pigeons appeared to orient towards home equally well, while the control pigeons in Germany frequently preferred directions that deviated significantly from the home direction. The effect of olfactory deprivation was small in the USA and in Germany; it was significantly larger in Italy, indicating that Italian pigeons depend on olfactory information to a much greater extent. These findings suggest that there are important regional differences in the strategies and cues pigeons use to navigate. The varied roles of olfactory information, and the reasons for these differences are discussed.     

Homeward paths of displaced juvenile alligators as determined by radiotelemetry

Summary To test their ability to home without searching or wandering, 19 juvenile alligators were radiotracked after displacement to areas 1–10 home range diameters beyond their areas of familiarity. Movement rates varied inversely with vegetation density, and in some cases habitat barriers appeared to deflect an alligator's homeward path. However, failures to home occurred only in those cases where major habitat barriers separated an alligator from its home site. In all other cases the alligators headed directly homeward; at least 10 of these completed their homeward journeys. The orienting ability of the alligators was neither dependent on the conditions under which they were displaced, nor the environmental conditions prevailing after release. These observations support the hypothesis that alligators possess a true navigational ability.