Gill development, functional and evolutionary implications in the Pacific oyster Crassostrea gigas (Bivalvia: Ostreidae)

Development of the Crassostrea gigas gill was studied in order to better understand the feeding biology of early life stages, identify potentially critical developmental stages which may influence rearing success or recruitment to wild populations, and shed light on the evolution of the basic bivalve gill types. Larvae and juveniles were reared in an experimental hatchery, and larger specimens were obtained from a commercial hatchery. Specimens were relaxed, fixed, dried, and observed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The right and left gills developed symmetrically, via a “cavitation–extension” process from the gill buds. The inner demibranchs developed first (V-stage, 0.29–2.70 mm), in a sequential postero-anterior series of homorhabdic filaments. The outer demibranchs developed later (W-stage, from 2.70 mm), also as homorhabdic filaments, synchronously along the gill axis. The principal filaments (PF) developed from the progressive fusion of three ordinary filaments (OF), at a size of 7.50 mm, and the consequent plication was accentuated by the formation of extensive tissue junctions. Effective filament number (number of descending and ascending filaments) showed a marked discontinuity at the transition from the V- to the W- stage of the gill. Filament ciliation showed several important changes: establishment of OF ciliation in the homorhabdic condition (2.70 mm), ciliary de-differentiation of the PF in the heterorhabdic condition (7.50 mm), and establishment of a latero-frontal cirri length gradient from the plical crest to the PF base. Reversal of direction of ciliary beat is also necessary prior to adult functioning of the PF. Three major transitions were identified in C. gigas gill development, each potentially important in rearing success or wild population recruitment: (1) transition from velum to gill at settlement, (2) transition from a V- to a W-shaped gill (2.70 mm), and (3) transition from the homorhabdic to the heterorhabdic condition (7.50 mm). Complete gill development was much more prolonged than in species previously studied. The major ontogenetic differences between the C. gigas heterorhabdic pseudolamellibranch gill and the pectinid heterorhabdic filibranch gill suggest that the heterorhabdic condition evolved independently in these two bivalve families.     

Changes in feeding mechanisms during early ontogeny in juveniles of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Crepidula fecunda</Emphasis> (Gastropoda,Calyptraeidae)

Feeding in early life stages of the sedentary snail Crepidula is effected both by the use of the radula and by filtering with the gill. The present study is a contribution to the knowledge of the mechanisms of feeding by early juvenile snails of Crepidula fecunda. Experimental observations were made on specimens of known ages as they were fed constant concentrations of microalgae in the presence of a primary biological film on a glass substrate. Feeding activity was filmed under the microscope, and images were digitized for the identification and quantification of feeding structures. A morphological analysis was made of the structures associated with this process. Results showed that the radula was functional beginning in 1-day-old juveniles, and the gill functioned in respiration. Gill function in filter-feeding began in juveniles of 9 days old when dorsal and ventral ciliation had developed, as well as the food pouch. The latter structure begins activity as soon as the gill starts food collection. Osphradia appeared simultaneous with development of the filter feeding capacity by the gill. In their earliest stages after metamorphosis, the young snails begin life by radular scraping of primary biofilms, gradually shifting to filter feeding as the gill developed a critical number of filaments and cilia.     

The osphradium in Placopecten magellanicus and Pecten maximus (Bivalvia,Pectinidae): histology,ultrastructure, and implications for spawning synchronisation

The bivalve osphradium is a band of putatively sensory tissue located in the gill axis, whose function is uncertain. In the present study, extending from 1987 to 1994, anatomical, histological, and electron microscopical techniques were used to elucidate the structure and ultrastructure of the osphradium in hatchery Pecten maximus L. and Placopecten magellanicus (Gmelin) (collected from Passamaquoddy Bay, New Brunswick, Canada). The osphradium consists of two distinct regions which run longitudinally on both sides of each gill axis: the osphradial ridge, and the dorsal tuft cilia region. The osphradial ridge was largely devoid of cilia other than those of the few free nerve fibres. The dorsal tuft cilia region contained free nerve fibres and ciliary tufts, separated by undifferentiated epithelial cells. No paddle cilia were observed under isosmotic fixation conditions, although under hypotonic conditions such cilia were quite common, suggesting an artefactual nature. Most of the cells of the osphradial ridge were highly secretory, the principal products being large pigment granules (in Pecten maximus) directly secreted by the Golgi bodies, and numerous small, electron-dense vesicles. These vesicles were arranged along extensive microtubule arrays in the basal region, indicative of axonal transport. These data support and extend Haszprunar's hypothesis of the role of the osphradium in the reception of chemical spawning cues and in the synchronization of gamete emission. Together with independent data on nerve pathways, osphradial sensory modalities, and monoamine localisation, an anatomical pathway and neurophysiological mediator are postulated.     

Direct observations of feeding structures and mechanisms in bivalve molluscs using endoscopic examination and video image analysis

A new technique is described for observing the structures and mechanisms of suspension feeding in bivalves using endoscopic examination and video image analysis. This method permits direct in vivo observations of whole, intact structures of relatively undisturbed specimens. No surgical alterations of shell or tissue are required for most species. Pallial organ activity can be recorded for future observations and analysis. Using this technique we examined three bivalve species, each with different degrees of mantle fusion:Mya arenaria L.Mytilus edulis L., andPlacopecten magellanicus (Gmelin). The specimens were collected between April and September 1990 at various locations in Trinity Bay, Newfoundland, Canada. Particle retention by the gill and transport of material to the palps was observed, and velocity of particles moving on the gill was determined. We demonstrate that the endoscope-video-analysis system is an efficient and affordable technique suitable for studies of pallial organ function and mechanisms of feeding.     

Ontogenetic changes in gill morphology and potential significance for food acquisition in the scallop <Emphasis Type="Italic">Placopecten</Emphasis><Emphasis Type="Italic">magellanicus</Emphasis>

Sources of mortality in both wild and cultured populations of marine bivalves during postlarval stages remain largely unknown, but may be partly associated with the inability to meet energetic demands during intense morphogenesis. The development of the gills in postsettlement scallops (Placopecten magellanicus) from 0.35 to 14 mm in shell height (SH) was investigated using scanning electron microscopy to determine the degree of size-specific differentiation of the gills and evaluate potential ontogenetic constraints in food acquisition. Key transitional stages in morphogenesis, likely to exert pronounced effects on feeding function, were identified and correlated with scallop size. The gill was initially homorhabdic, with unreflected inner demibranchs forming a basket-like structure maintained by ciliary junctions. Gill reflection, immediately followed by accelerated proliferation of gill filaments and formation of outer demibranchs, occurred at ~1 mm SH. Outer demibranchs were fully formed at ~2 mm SH. Suspension-feeding is probably rather inefficient prior to attaining 1-2 mm sizes. The onset of the heterorhabdic, adult form of the gill, which allows bidirectional particle transport and the potential for selection and for volume regulation of ingested material on the gill, occurred fairly late in development, at ~3.3-5.0 mm SH. Full development of gill plication was delayed until scallops attained ~7 mm. Gill differentiation in this species is thus relatively protracted and punctuated by critical transitional stages, which may be important in determining feeding and growth capacity of postlarval wild and cultured populations.     

Gill morphogenesis in the oyster Ostrea chilensis

Despite the importance of the gills in the acquisition of food by suspension-feeding bivalve mollusks, there is almost no information on gill organogenesis. By means of a series of stereoscan electron micrographs, this paper describes gill development in the Chilean oyster, Ostrea chilensis, from the brooded larval stages to 1-month-old spat. A single gill rudiment was observed on each side of the mantle at a shell length of 320 μm, and the rudiments increased in number and size until the end of the brooding period. During metamorphosis the gill filaments increased in number from 5 or 6 to between 7 and 9. The loss of the velum and the absence of functional gill filaments during metamorphosis are consistent with previous observations of weight loss during this critical period of the life history, because the newly settled juvenile lacks the ability to remove particles from suspension. The end of metamorphosis (100% of spat with dissoconch edge) was reached 36 h after larval settlement, when the gill filaments began to grow cilia, which increased in density and differentiated as the spat developed and acquired the capability of suspension-feeding, accounting for the increase in body weight previously recorded during this stage. The larval rudiments gave rise to the inner demibranchs. The outer demibranchs were observed 10 days after settlement, located between the inner demibranch and the mantle. In 1-month-old spat, the gill did not show differentiation between primary and secondary filaments, indicating that the heterorhabdic condition characteristic of adult oysters had yet to be attained. Received: 11 December 1998 / Accepted: 21 August 2000     

Association of bacteria with larvae of the gutless protobranch bivalve Solemya reidi (Cryptodonta: Solemyidae)

Rod-shaped bacteria were consistently observed by transmission electron microscopy in the locomotory test of larvae and in the perivisceral cavity of post-larvae of Solemya reidi, a gutless protobranch bivalve known to possess intracellular chemoautotrophic bacterial symbionts in the adult gill. Bacteria develop within granular vesicles in the larval test, where they either remain to be ingested at metamorphosis, or are released into the space separating the test and embryo, to be subsequently ingested through the larval mouth. In either case, bacteria lie within the perivisceral cavity following metamorphosis. Bacteria were not seen either in or on gametes or in gills of juveniles. It is hypothesized that these bacteria represent a transmission stage of the gill symbionts present in adult S. reidi and are not evident in gametes or gills of juveniles due to cryptic packaging within granular vesicles. Perpetuation of this symbiosis would therefore be assured through vertical transmission, as is typical of other marine invertebrate-bacteria endosymbioses.Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institution Contribution No. 602     

Larval development of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lightiella magdalenina</Emphasis> (Crustacea,Cephalocarida)

The larval development of the newly discovered cephalocarid from Mediterranean sea, Lightiella magdalenina, was analysed using light and scanning electron microscopy. Twenty-nine larval specimens, divided into 15 metanaupliar and 2 juvenile stages of development, were found. The first six metanaupliar stages had an even number (6, 8, 10, 12, 14 and 16) of trunk segments including telson. The condition of 20 trunk segments, typical of the adult, was reached after another 4 stages by the addition of a single segment per stage. At this tenth stage, the larvae had an incomplete number of trunk limbs. Another five stages were needed to complete the cephalic appendage development, passing from the metanaupliar to the juvenile stage, characterized by loss of the naupliar enditic process of the second antenna. Trunk limbs development was completed during the last two juvenile stages. According to the ontogenetic data reported for Hutchinsoniella macracantha and Lightiella incisa, these seventeen stages probably do not represent the complete developmental series. Nevertheless, they allow us to clarify the main features of cephalocarid ontogeny and show specific differences in the development of both the trunk segments and appendages.     

New observations of the gills of Placopecten magellanicus (Mollusca: Bivalvia), and implications for nutrition

The organization, general anatomy, and surface microanatomy of all regions of the gills of a representive bivalve mollusc, Placopecten magellanicus Gmelin, were studied using stereo-microscopic, histological, and scanning electron microscopic techniques. Individuals were collected in May and November 1985 from Chamcook Bay, New Brunswick, Canada. In addition to correcting earlier accounts of this structure, a number of new observations are reported. The orientation of the ciliated spurs appears to be responsible for the sinusoidal arrangement of the gill filaments. Micrographs showing the structure of the dorsal respiratory expansion are presented. The entire abfrontal surface of the principal filament, including the dorsal respiratory expansion, is densely ciliated and mucosecretory. These characteristics may aid in the establishment of a respiratory current and in the prevention of gill damage during escape responses. All nonciliated regions of the gill filaments are covered with microvilli, thus greatly increasing the surface area of the gill. The feeding mechanism is discussed in relation to the dorsal and ventral ciliated tracts. Symbiotic ciliate protozoans are constantly dislodged from the gill filaments and transported via the ventral mucus string to the buccal region. The nutritional implications of these observations are discussed.     

Effects of temperature on morphological landmarks critical to growth and survival in larval Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua)

The morphology and function of structures important to energy acquisition were studied from spawning to the stage of transformation of larva to pelagic juvenile in Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua L., from December 1991 to July 1992. Fertilized eggs produced by adult fish from two genetically discrete populations (Newfoundland and Scotian Shelf) were raised under similar conditions in the laboratory at temperatures of 5 and 10°C. Subsamples of larvae were removed from cultures daily for 10 d, and then less frequently, and fixed for light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Nine functional morphological landmarks important to feeding, respiration and locomotion were chosen from observation of 280 ind. These landmarks defined 12 major developmental stages, from hatching to the pelagic juvenile stage. One of the feeding landmarks, intestinal stage, varied as a function of age and size and the variance in development was higher at 10°C than at 5°C; Newfoundland larvae developed more complex intestines than did Scotian Shelf larvae. In addition, Newfoundland larvae had significantly higher growth rates than those of Scotian Shelf larvae. Despite the higher growth rates and greater structural complexity of the intestine in Newfoundland larvae, the rate of yolk utilization was not significantly different between Newfoundland and Scotian Shelf larvae. Staging of respiratory landmarks showed that the gill arches were probably used preferentially in feeding while respiration was cutaneous. The gills, operculum and gill rakers developed late in larval life and accompanied the transition from cutaneous to branchial respiration. In the yolk-sac period, development of feeding and respiratory structures may be largely genetically controlled. During exogenous feeding, extrinsic factors also become important, as shown by the size and age-independent variation in intestinal development of larval cod raised at different temperatures.     

Energy substrates for eggs and prefeeding larvae of the dolphinCoryphaena hippurus

Changes in the chemical composition of developing dolphin (Coryphaena hippurus) eggs and prefeeding yolksac larvae were determined in order to estimate probable dietary requirements of first-feeding larvae. Daily dry matter, protein nitrogen (PN), non-protein nitrogen (NPN), lipid, gross energy content, fatty acid and amino acid profiles from Day 1 to Day 2 eggs and Day 1 to Day 3 larvae were compared. Lipid was the primary endogenous energy source accounting for the daily caloric deficit through both the egg and larval stages, except over the day of hatching. The catabolism of lipid by embryos (0.078 cal d^–1) was greater than that by yolksac larvae (0.036 cal d^–1). The higher demand for energy by embryos was related to a greater rate of protein synthesis during the egg stage. The ratio of PN:NPN increased during egg development without change in total nitrogen content, but was constant throughout the yolksac larvae period. The lipid content per embryo did not decrease over the hatching period (Day 2 to 3, postspawning). However, there was a loss in amino acid content not totally accounted for by sloughing of the chorion at hatching. This loss, as protein, accounted for 0.053 cal of gross energy, which represented 70% of the total estimated energy needs of the fish over this period. Loss of non-essential amino acids (25%) was higher than that of essential amino acids (13%). Proline and tyrosine accounted for 32% of the total loss of amino acids at this time. The only preferential use of fatty acids over any period was a small but significant drop in the content of C22:6n-3 prior to the onset of feeding (Day 5, postspawning). It is speculated that the pattern of energy-substrate use of first-feeding dolphin larvae will reflect the pattern of endogenous energy use during the egg and prefeeding yolksac larval stages. Diets or feeding regimens with lipid as the primary energy source, and containing a fatty acid profile similar to that of eggs or yolksac larvae, should be useful in culturing this species, at least during the early feeding stages.     

New observations of the gills of Placopecten magellanicus (Mollusca: Bivalvia), and implications for nutrition

The internal anatomy and microanatomy of the gill of Placopecten magellanicus Gmelin collected in May and November 1985 from Chamcook Bay, New Brunswick, Canada, was studied using thin-section light microscopy and transmission electron microscopy. Most of the spurs show no evidence of organic union, and hence do not participate in vascular exchange. However, the dorsal bend shows both ciliary and organic interfilamentar union. The internal structure and the hemocytes of the dorsal respiratory expansion are presented. The epithelium consists of three distinct cell types, bounded by apical microvilli. All regions of the gill contain an epithelial basal membrane, which is greatly convoluted in the interconnecting vessels of the dorsal respiratory expansion. The significance of these observations is discussed in relation to possible roles in respiration, transmembrane transport and nutrition. The apical surface of all ciliated cells is covered with an acellular matrix composed of clear spherical vesicles, which may serve a mechanical function for which mucus would be unsuited. The significance of the abundance of mucocytes on the abfrontal surface of the principal filaments is discussed in terms of the escape response of pectinid bivalves.     

Development of the pericalymma larva of Solemya reidi (Bivalvia: Cryptodonta: Solemyidae) as revealed by light and electron microscopy

Solemya reidi Bernard 1980 is a gutless protobranch bivalve known to possess intracellular chemoautotrophic bacterial symbionts in its gill. A light and electron microscope study on the embryology and larval development of S. reidi provides data for the bivalve Subclass Cryptodonta. S. reidi spontaneously spawned large eggs (271 m in diameter), which developed within individual gelatious egg capsules. The first several cleavages were equal and a distinct molluscan cross was formed at the animal pole of the embryo, features previously unreported in bivalve development. Lecithotrophic pericalymma larvae (similar to the larvae of paleotaxodont protobranch bivalves and aplacophoran molluscs) hatched at 18 to 24 h and remained in the water column for a further 5 d at 10°C. At hatching, larvae measured from 360 to 440 m in length and from 225 to 265 m in cross-sectional diameter. Definitive adult structures developed within an epithelial locomotory test entirely covered with compound cilia. The test histolysed at metamorphosis and was ingested throught the mouth into the perivisceral cavity. Length and height of the shell following metamorphosis was 433 m (±42 m, n=16) and 282 m (± 29 m, n=13), respectively. Primary data and data from the literature show that the type of larval development in both paleotaxodont and cryptodont bivalves cannot be reliably estimated from egg or prodissoconch sizes.     

Persistence,morphology, and nutritional state of a gastropod hosted bacterial symbiosis in different levels of hydrothermal vent flux

The limpet, Lepetodrilus fucensis McLean, is found in prominent stacks around hydrothermal vents on the Juan de Fuca Ridge. L. fucensis hosts a filamentous episymbiont on its gill lamellae that may be ingested directly by the gill epithelium. To assess the persistence of this symbiosis I used microscopy to examine the gills of L. fucensis from sites representing its geographic range and different habitats. The symbiosis is present on all the specimens examined in this study, including both sexes and a range of juvenile and adult sizes. Next, I aimed to determine if patterns in bacterial abundance, host condition, and gill morphology support the hypotheses that the bacteria are chemoautotrophic and provide limpets with a food resource. To do so, I compared specimens from high and low flux locations at multiple vents. My results support the above hypotheses: (1) gill bacteria are significantly less abundant in low flux where the concentrations of reduced chemicals (for chemoautotrophy) are negligible, (2) low flux specimens have remarkably poor tissue condition, and (3) the lamellae of high flux limpets have greater surface area: the blood space and bacteria-hosting epithelium are deeper and have more folds than low flux lamellae, modifications that support higher symbiont abundances. I next asked if the morphology of the lamellae could change. To test this, I moved high flux limpets away from a vent and after 1 year the lamellar depth and shape of the transplanted specimens resembled low flux gills. Last, I was interested in whether bacterial digestion by the gill epithelium is a significant feeding mechanism. As bacteria-like cells are rarely apparent in lysosomes of the gill epithelium, I predicted that lysosome number would be unrelated to bacterial abundance. My data support this prediction, suggesting that digestion of bacteria by the gill epithelium probably contributes only minimally to the limpet’s nutrition. Overall, the persistence and morphology of the L. fucensis gill symbiosis relates to the intensity of vent flux and indicates that specimens from a variety of habitats may be necessary to characterize the morphological variability of gill-hosted symbioses in other molluscs.     

A hydromechanical principle for particle retention in Mytilus edulis and other ciliary suspension feeders

It is generally thought that the laterofrontal cirri of the bivalve gill act as filters that retain suspended particles in the through current and transfer the particles onto the frontal surface of the gill filaments. In Mytilus edulis calculations indicated that if water passed between the branching cilia of the cirri that are assumed to constitute the filter the pressure drop needed would amount to about 10 times the actual pressure drop across the whole gill. Thus, instead of acting as filters the laterofrontal cirri seem to move water. Presumably, the cirri together with the frontal cilia produce the water currents along the frontal surface of the gill filaments. Particle retention in the bivalve gill implies the transfer of suspended particles from the current of water about to enter an interfilamentar space into a neighbouring frontal surface current. The complex three-dimensional pattern of flow that arises where the 2 systems of current meet is characterized by steep velocity gradients. Particles that enter such steep, steady velocity gradients become exposed to transverse forces that cause the particles to migrate perpendicularly to the direction of flow. Whether particles enter the surface current, i.e. are retained, or they stay within the through current andescape, depends primarily upon particle size, and upon the steepness and height of the gradients within the boundary zone between the surface current and through current. Further studies are needed to evaluate the capacities and relative importance of this hydromechanical particle-trapping mechanism in suspension feeding bivalves. It is suggested that in downstream particle-retaining systems, e.g. on the tentacles of polychaetes and entoprocts, velocity gradients between through currents and surface currents also act as the particle-collecting mechanism.     

The structure of the latero-frontal cirri on the gills of certain lamellibranch molluscs and their role in suspension feeding

Photomicroscopy and scanning electron microscopy were used to determine the fine structure of the latero-frontal cirri on the gills of three species of bivalve mollusc: Mytilus edulis Linn., Barnea candida (Linn.), and Petricola pholadiformis Lam. The component cilia are seen to branch off alternately along the length of each cirrus. Each of these free, lateral lengths of the cilia are separated from the next on their side by a mean distance of 0.6 m. They extend to a mean length of 2.7 m in M. edulis, the species described in detail. It is shown that a complete straining mesh can be formed over the gill ostium during normal filtering and the aperture of this mesh correlates well with the previously recorded filtering efficiency for Mytilus.     

Responses of an estuarine population of the blue mussel Mytilus edulis to heated water from a steam generating plant

An entire bed of the blue mussel Mytilus edulis, consisting of 5,000 individuals/m², died during June, 1971 in the effluent canal of a steam generating plant when the temperature increased above 27°C. Similarly, the population in the intake canal disappeared when temperatures rose above 27°C in August. Laboratory studies showed that M. edulis could not tolerate continuous temperatures above 27°C, and feeding stopped shortly after the mussels were exposed to 25°C. Histopathological studies indicated that the cause of death of this bivalve was associated with degeneration of the frontal and laterofrontal cilia of the columnar epithelium of the gill filaments. In conjuction with this, there was necrosis and sloughing of the epithelium of the intestinal diverticula. Extensive amoebocytic infiltration was noted in the byssogenous cavity, gill filaments and stomach wall.This paper represents part of a dissertation by the first author, submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, University of Rhode Island, January 1973.     

Amino acid metabolism and protein turnover in larval turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) fed natural zooplankton or Artemia

The present paper studied the influence of different food regimes on the free amino acid (FAA) pool, the rate of protein turnover, the flux of amino acids, and their relation to growth of larval turbot (Scophthalmus maximus L.) from first feeding until metamorphosis. The amino acid profile of protein was stable during the larval period although some small, but significant, differences were found. Turbot larvae had proteins which were rich in leucine and aspartate, and poor in glutamate, suggesting a high leucine requirement. The profile of the FAA pool was highly variable and quite different from the amino acid profile in protein. The proportion of essential FAA decreased with development. High contents of free tyrosine and phenylalanine were found on Day 3, while free taurine was present at high levels throughout the experimental period. Larval growth rates were positively correlated with taurine levels, suggesting a dietary dependency for taurine and/or sulphur amino acids. Reduced growth rates in Artemia-fed larvae were associated with lower levels of free methionine, indicating that this diet is deficient in methionine for turbot larvae. Leucine might also be limiting turbot growth as the different diet organisms had lower levels of this amino acid in the free pool than was found in the larval protein. A previously presented model was used to describe the flux of amino acids in growing turbot larvae. The FAA pool was found to be small and variable. It was estimated that the daily dietary amino acid intake might be up to ten times the larval FAA pool. In addition, protein synthesis and protein degradation might daily remove and return, respectively, the equivalent of up to 20 and 10 times the size of the FAA pool. In an early phase (Day 11) high growth rates were associated with a relatively low protein turnover, while at a later stage (Day 17), a much higher turnover was observed. Received: 19 March 1997 / Accepted: 14 April 1997     

Clearance rates of the great scallop (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Pecten maximus</Emphasis>) and blue mussel (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Mytilus edulis</Emphasis>) at low natural seston concentrations

Great scallop, Pecten maximus, and blue mussel, Mytilus edulis, clearance rate (CR) responses to low natural seston concentrations were investigated in the laboratory to study (1) short-term CR variations in individual bivalves exposed to a single low seston diet, and (2) seasonal variations in average CR responses of bivalve cohorts to natural environmental variations. On a short temporal scale, mean CR response of both species to 0.06 μg L⁻¹ chlorophyll a (Chl a) and 0.23 mg L⁻¹ suspended particulate matter (SPM) remained constant despite large intra-individual fluctuations in CR. In the seasonal study, cohorts of each species were exposed to four seston treatments consisting of ambient and diluted natural seston that ranged in mean concentration from 0.15 to 0.43 mg L⁻¹ SPM, 0.01 to 0.88 μg L⁻¹ Chl a, 36 to 131 μg L⁻¹ particulate organic carbon and 0.019 to 0.330 mm³ L⁻¹ particle volume. Although food abundance in all treatments was low, the nutritional quality of the seston was relatively high (e.g., mean particulate organic content ranged from 68 to 75%). Under these low seston conditions, a high percentage of P. maximus (81–98%) and M. edulis (67–97%) actively cleared particles at mean rates between 9 and 12 and between 4 and 6 L g⁻¹ h⁻¹, respectively. For both species, minimum mean CR values were obtained for animals exposed to the lowest seston concentrations. Within treatments, P. maximus showed a greater degree of seasonality in CR than M. edulis, which fed at a relatively constant rate despite seasonal changes in food and temperature. P. maximus showed a non-linear CR response to increasing Chl a levels, with rates increasing to a maximum at approximately 0.4 μg L⁻¹ Chl a and then decreasing as food quantity continued to increase. Mean CR of M. edulis also peaked at a similar concentration, but remained high and stable as the food supply continued to increase and as temperatures varied between 4.6 and 19.6°C. The results show that P. maximus and M. edulis from a low seston environment, do not stop suspension-feeding at very low seston quantities; a result that contradicts previous conclusions on the suspension-feeding behavior of bivalve mollusks and which is pertinent to interpreting the biogeographic distribution of bivalve mollusks and site suitability for aquaculture.