Charcoal versus LPG grilling: A carbon-footprint comparison

Undoubtedly, grilling is popular. Britons fire up their barbeques some 60 million times a year, consuming many thousands of tonnes of fuel. In milder climates consumption is even higher, and in the developing world, charcoal continues to be an essential cooking fuel. So it is worth comparing the carbon footprints of the two major grill types, charcoal and LPG, and that was the purpose of the study this paper documents. Charcoal and LPG grill systems were defined, and their carbon footprints were calculated for a base case and for some plausible variations to that base case. In the base case, the charcoal grilling footprint of 998 kg CO₂e is almost three times as large as that for LPG grilling, 349 kg CO₂e. The relationship is robust under all plausible sensitivities. The overwhelming factors are that as a fuel, LPG is dramatically more efficient than charcoal in its production and considerably more efficient in cooking. Secondary factors are: use of firelighters, which LPG does not need; LPG's use of a heavier, more complicated grill; and LPG's use of cylinders that charcoal does not need.     

Black carbon particulate matter emission factors for buoyancy-driven associated gas flares

Flaring is a technique used extensively in the oil and gas industry to burn unwanted flammable gases. Oxidation of the gas can preclude emissions of methane (a potent greenhouse gas); however, flaring creates other pollutant emissions such as particulate matter (PM) in the form of soot or black carbon (BC). Currently available PM emissionfactors for flares were reviewed and found to be questionably accurate, or based on measurements not directly relevant to open-atmosphere flares. In addition, most previous studies of soot emissions from turbulent diffusion flames considered alkene or alkyne based gaseous fuels, and few considered mixed fuels in detail and/or lower sooting propensity fuels such as methane, which is the predominant constituent of gas flared in the upstream oil and gas industry. Quantitative emission measurements were performed on laboratory-scale flares for a range of burner diameters, exit velocities, and fuel compositions. Drawing from established standards, a sampling protocol was developed that employed both gravimetric analysis of filter samples and real-time measurements of soot volume fraction using a laser-induced incandescence (LII) system. For the full range of conditions tested (burner inner diameter [ID] of 12.7-76.2 mm, exit velocity 0.1-2.2 m/sec, 4- and 6-component methane-based fuel mixtures representative of associated gas in the upstream oil industry), measured soot emission factors were less than 0.84 kg soot/10(3) m3 fuel. A simple empirical relationship is presented to estimate the PM emission factor as a function of the fuel heating value for a range of conditions, which, although still limited, is an improvement over currently available emission factors.     

Experiences in Controlling Atmospheric Pollution Encountered in Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Processes

Smog aerosol can be related to sources, atmospheric transport, and particle growth through a Lagrangian model. Sample calculations indicate that the midday Pasadena aerosol is dominated by material produced in the atmosphere, and that the afternoon drop in aerosol mass is due to the advection of cleaner air. Numerical experiments suggest that control of primary particulate emissions without corresponding control of reactive gases would not substantially improve visibility.     

Screening Approach for Principal Organic Hazardous Constituents and Products of Incomplete Combustion

The body of information presented in this paper is directed to those individuals concerned with developing or implementing screening strategies for characterizing organic emissions from incinerators and other combustion sources. The need to characterize hazardous waste incinerator emissions for multiple organic compounds has been steadily increasing for several years. The regulatory approach makes use of a type of indicator compound procedure that concentrates on principal organic hazardous constituents (POHCs). In addition to continuing interest in POHCs, interest has been growing in the types and concentrations of products of incomplete combustion (PICs). Sampling and analysis methods have been developed previously for approximately 225 of the more important POHCs and PICs. These methods may be used as components of a cost-effective screening protocol aimed at maximum characterization of emissions, whether the project budget is large or small. This paper contains a discussion of fundamental principles of several kinds of screening strategies and recommends an approach suitable for incinerators and other combustion sources. The concept of a risk-driven analysis strategy is introduced and illustrated with a simplified example.     

Development,Calibration and Use of a Plume Evaluation Training Unit

The Bay Area Air Pollution Control District adopted a regulation limiting plume visibility in terms of the Ringelmann Chart and also in terms of obscuration of the observer’s view. Since both limitations were adopted in terms requiring the judgment of an observer, preparation for enforcement required development and calibration of a training unit, so that inspectors could be qualified to testify as expert witnesses under this regulation.

This paper summarizes the design, calibration and use of the training unit developed for this purpose.     

Alabama Electric Cooperative Flue Gas Desulfurization Operating and Maintenance Experience

Alabama Electric Cooperative, Leroy, AL, has recently started up two 255 MW units, including a flue gas desulfurization system, at their Tomblgbee Station. The flue gas desulfurization system was designed by Peabody Process Systems, Inc., Stamford, CT. After 20 months operation, performance, in terms of start-up operations and maintenance, has been exceptionally good. This paper discusses those design factors which contributed to this successful performance.     

Minnesota Power’s Operating Experience with Integrated Particulate and SO2 Scrubbing

Minnesota Power currently has in commercial operation a 500 MW gas cleaning system consisting of a venturi particulate scrubber, integrated with a spray tower SO₂ absorber. The system was designed to achieve 99.7% particulate removal and 90% SO₂ removal based upon burning a 2.8 % sulfur coal.

Initially the concept of using a venturi for wet particulate collection was selected based upon a significant cost saving of $25 million compared to dry particulate collection devices. Subsequently, the Interaction of particulate collection with SO₂ removal provided additional operating cost benefits. Prior to start-up of the commercial system, a pilot plant was used to evaluate various modes of operation. Results showed that alkali contained in the fly ash removed with the venturi was sufficient to meet the alkali requirement for SO₂ removal.

Clay Boswell Station Unit No. 4 was started up during March 1980. Since initial start-up the system has exhibited almost 100% availability. EPA compliance testing has confirmed that the system Is meeting its emission standards. The unit is operating with fly ash as the only source of alkali. Since commercial operation started, no external alkali has been purchased.

This paper will discuss the design details of the system and performance of the commercial system.     

Statistical Comparisons between Teleradiometer-Derived and Slide-Derived Visibility Parameters

An automated scanning densitometer system developed to estimate visibility-related parameters from photographic slides was tested in comparison to similar teleradiometric measurements. Parameters such as target-sky contrast, visual range, atmospheric light extinction coefficient, and plume and layered contrast can be estimated using this system; however, only target-sky radiance ratios and standard visual ranges were compared. More than 1600 concurrent densitometer and teleradiometer data pairs from eight National Park Service air quality and visibility monitoring locations in the western United States were analyzed using the techniques of correlation, linear regression, average bias and difference calculation, and cumulative frequency distribution generation. Correlation coefficients were good, especially with middle-range camera vistas around 50 km distant. Regression slopes approached unity with intercepts near zero. Average bias introduced into the determination of radiance ratios from slides ranged from near zero to 6 percent, depending on target distance. Standard visual range data distributions compared favorably at the low end with some minor differences at the high end.     

Contributions of Acid Deposition and Natural Processes to Cation Leaching from Forest Soils: A Review

Methods of quantifying the roles of atmospheric acid inputs and internal acid generation by carbonic, organic, and nitric acids are illustrated by reviewing data sets from several intensively studied sites in North America. Some of the sites (tropical, temperate deciduous, and temperate coniferous) received acid precipitation whereas others (northern and subalpine) did not. Natural leaching by carbonic acid dominated soil leaching in the tropical and temperate coniferous sites, nitric acid (caused by nitrification) dominated leaching In an N-fixing temperate deciduous site, and organic acids dominated surface soil leaching in the subalpine site and contributed to leaching of surface soils in several other sites. Only at the temperate deciduous sites did atmospheric acid input play a major role in soil leaching. In no case, however, are the annual net losses of cations regarded as alarming as compared to soil exchangeable cation capital.

These results were used to illustrate the methods of quantifying the effects of atmospheric inputs and internal processes on soil leaching rates, not to draw broad generalizations as to acid rain effects on soils. However, there are predictable patterns in natural soil leaching processes which relate to climate, soil properties, and vegetation that may help in predicting the relative importances of natural vs. atmospheric acid inputs to soil leaching.     

1992 Environmental Software Survey

By some accounts, there are up to 1,000 different software packages on the market today. These range from specialized products that calculate releases from fixed roof storage tanks to comprehensive chemical inventory tracking and reporting systems. One of the positive benefits to this proliferation of software is that there is a wide selection of products available. The down side is that many times the hardest part of purchasing an environmental software product is figuring out which product to buy, and where to find it. The 1992 Environmental Software Survey is intended to fill this gap for those who rely upon computers as a tool to perform their job functions. This paper summarizes information on more than 600 environmental software products produced by over 200 vendors. Information includes environmental media addressed by the software, program functions and vendor information.