Cowbird removals unexpectedly increase productivity of a brood parasite and the songbird host

Generalist brood parasites reduce productivity and population growth of avian hosts and have been implicated in population declines of several songbirds of conservation concern. To estimate the demographic effects of brood parasitism on Bell's Vireos (Vireo bellii), we removed Brown-headed Cowbirds (Molothrus ater) in a replicated switchback experimental design. Cowbird removals decreased parasitism frequency from 77% and 85% at unmanipulated plots to 58% and 47% at removal plots in 2004 and 2005, respectively. Vireo productivity per pair was higher at cowbird removal plots when years were pooled (mean = 2.6 +/- 0.2 [SE] young per pair) compared to unmanipulated plots (1.2 +/- 0.1). Nest desertion frequency was lower at cowbird removal plots (35% of parasitized nests) compared to unmanipulated plots (69%) because removal of host eggs was the proximate cue for nest desertion, and vireos experienced lower rates of egg loss at cowbird removal plots. Nest success was higher among unparasitized than parasitized nests, and parasitized nests at cowbird removal plots had a higher probability of success than parasitized nests at unmanipulated plots. Unexpectedly, cowbird productivity from vireo pairs was higher at cowbird removal plots (mean = 0.3 +/- 0.06 young per pair) than at unmanipulated plots (0.1 +/- 0.03) because fewer parasitized nests were deserted and the probability of nest success was higher. Our study provides the first evidence that increases in cowbird productivity may be an unintended consequence of cowbird control programs, especially during the initial years of trapping when parasitism may only be moderately reduced. Thus, understanding the demographic impacts of cowbird removals requires an informed understanding of the behavioral ecology of host-parasite interactions.     

Bioindikation mit Wanderfalken

Goal and Scope

The Stockholm convention bans 12 prominent persistent organic pollutants (POPs), and the pertinent global monitoring programme recommends birds’ eggs as bio-indicators for the terrestrial food web. As top predators, Peregrine falcons are uniquely suited indicators because of their accumulating power for persistent and lipophilic compounds. On the other hand, the Peregrine falcon as a sentinel species was closer to extinction than other birds of prey. Only unremitting efforts of private omithologists throughout the past four decades in conjunction with the timely banning of organochlorine pesticides like DDT succeeded in saving the Peregrine population of Baden-Wueriternberg from extinction, in contrast to the Peregrine falcons of other German states or other European countries.

Methods

See vd Trenck et al. (2006).

Results and Conclusions

New results confirm the findings of the past long-term bio-monitoring. The main pollutants are PCBs (ca. 20 μg/g) and pp′-DDE (ca. 11 μg/g), the latter contributing >96% of all organochlorine pesticide residues (all concentrations on a dry matter basis). Both substances have followed a slightly increasing trend since 2004. The sum of the polychlorinated diphenyl ethers (PBDE) has fluctuated strongly in the past four years, and in 2006 amounted to 0.6 μg/g (mean without outliers), just as the mercury contamination of the eggs. PCB-156 as the main dioxin-like PCB followed with an average concentration of 0.35 μg/g. Only 10 out of 23 eggs analysed contained hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) in measurable concentrations; the mean concentration of these eggs was 0.024 μg/g. Tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBA) was detected in all egg samples with a mean of 0.004 μg/g. Due to the many and diverse effects exerted by PCBs; the assessment of this group of compounds, with the aid of European and German regulations for food, proves to be a complex matter, which is currently in a state of flux. There is no doubt, however, that the mean pollution of the Peregrine eggs with toxic dioxin equivalents (WHO TEQ) has reached the no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) known for chickens and osprey chicks, and the most polluted eggs exceed this threshold considerably. The toxic profile of PBDEs is similar to that of PCBs. They are known to promote tumour growth, to interfere with the thyroid hormone system resulting in toxicity for the neuronal development, to suppress the immune system, and to trigger stress reactions. Tests with highly purified BDE-47 have ruled out dioxin-like effects via Ah-receptor binding for this congener and such effects are therefore very unlikely for the whole class of compounds. At the present time, quantitative criteria for the assessment of the risk posed by PBDEs are not sufficiently reliable, and less so for HBCD and TBBA.

Recommendations and Perspectives

It is necessary to continue the bio-monitoring of POPs and similar pollutants in the terrestrial food web and to establish NOAELs as quantitative criteria for their assessment. Possible sources of dioxin-like PCBs and PCDD/Fs are to be pinpointed, and abatement measures are to be considered where background concentrations are significantly exceeded.     

Three-way compositional analysis of water quality monitoring data

Water quality monitoring data typically consist of \(J\) parameters and constituents measured at \(I\) number of static locations at \(K\) sets of seasonal occurrences. The resulting \(I \times J \times K\) three-way array can be difficult to interpret. Additionally, the constituent portion of the dataset (e.g., major ion and trace element concentration, pH, etc.) is compositional in that it sums to a constant (e.g., 1 kg/L) and is mathematically confined to the simplex, the sample space for compositional data. Here we apply a Tucker3 model on centered log-ratio data to find low dimensional representation of latent variables as a means to simplify data processing and interpretation of three years of seasonal compositional groundwater chemistry data for 14 wells at a study site in Wyoming, USA. The study site has been amended with treated coalbed methane produced water, using a subsurface drip irrigation system, to allow for irrigation of forage crops. Results from three-way compositional data analysis indicate that primary controls on water quality at the study site include: solutes concentration by evapotranspiration, cation exchange, and dissolution of native salts. These findings agree well with results from more detailed investigations of the site. In addition, the model identified Ba uptake during gypsum precipitation in some portions of the site during the final 6–9 months of investigation, a process for which the timing and extent had not previously been identified. These results suggest that multi-way compositional analyses hold promise as a means to more easily interpret water quality monitoring data.