Breeding Birds as a Farm Product

Abstract: Since the 1950s, meadowbird populations have been under increasing threat from radical changes in farming practices. We studied the possibilities for conserving meadowbirds on modern, intensive dairy farms in the Netherlands. Here, the conventional strategy for the conservation of meadowbirds is to restrict farming intensity and compensate farmers for their production losses. To increase the breeding success of meadowbirds, however, dairy farmers can fine-tune farming practices to yearly and local circumstances. Because this fine-tuning is difficult to enforce by legislation, we propose that farmers be paid for clutches bred on their land. Thus, farmers are paid for what they produce, but not restricted in their farming practices. The results of the first small-scale experiments, in which breeding success was compared between farms where farmers were paid for meadowbird clutches and farms where farmers were not paid, are encouraging. Breeding success of meadowbirds was significantly higher where farmers were paid than where they were not ( breeding success of Lapwing    Vanellus vanellus ]: 64.7% on paid farms, 48.2% on unpaid farms; Black-tailed Godwit    Limosa limosa ]: 63.1% paid, 39.3% unpaid). The effects on meadowbird populations could not yet be detected. The per-clutch payment system is less expensive than compensation for income losses: paying for clutches costs 40 Euro per clutch, whereas compensating for income losses costs 100–400 Euro per clutch (1 Euro is approximately equal to 1 U.S. dollar). Farmers are enthusiastic, and the system encourages cooperation between farmers and nature conservationists.