Efficient taxation of resource income : The case of copper mining in British Columbia

This article continues previous research by the authors into the economic efficiency of two actual tax systems, one relying on a mining profits tax and the other on a gross royalty. The relative efficiency of the royalty-based taxation system is found to be conditioned by the share of resource income sought by the province: at low tax rates there is little difference between the two systems, while at high rates the royalty system is markedly less efficient. The efficiency comparisons are quite consistent over different expected price levels. However, they are influenced significantly by the flexibility of mining operations, which in practice is associated with the ability to produce ore systematically in order of diminishing quality. Curtailed flexibility renders the royalty-based system relatively less efficient.