Mate retention and male polyterritoriality in the pied flycatcher Ficedula hypoleuca

Summary We studied pair bond maintenance in the pied flycatcher in an experiment on nest predation at the incubation stage. Males defending one or more additional nestboxes (i.e. polyterritorial) on the day of nest predation were significantly more successful in retaining their mate than were the monoterritorial males (54% and 13% succeed, respectively). We manipulated the number of nest sites available for renesting, and found that the females remained preferentially with those males that had access to a new site, regardless of the previous territorial status of the male. Thus, the success of the polyterritorial males in mate retention was related primarily to the resource defended (a new nest site) rather than to some quality of the particular males per se. When the females could choose between alternative nestboxes for renesting, they selected the one located at the greatest distance from the initial site (Fig. 1). Male polyterritorial behaviour has previously been interpreted as a means of achieving polygyny. Our results show that this behaviour may be advantageous even in the absence of polygyny, especially at high levels of nest predation.