Mate fidelity of renesting pied flycatchers Ficedula hypoleuca in relation to characteristics of the pair mates

Summary After a nesting failure, individual pied flycatchers may renest with the same or a new partner. In a 2-year study, carried out in a homogeneous habitat, we removed the clutches of a total of 124 monogamous pairs to study mate fidelity. The chance of a male obtaining a new partner if the pair bond had been broken was very low, so it would be in a male's interest to retain his original mate. Females in good condition showed a greater tendency to break the pair bond, and moved longer distances for renesting, than females in poor condition. Females that had nested in the area in a previous year were more site-tenacious, though not significantly more faithful to their mates, than those that were nesting in the area for the first time. Males that succeeded in retaining their mate were characterized primarily by having black plumage, and males from which certain feathers had been removed (=handicapped) tended to lose their mates. Females preferred the same male characteristics when they chose their mates in early spring. Hence, the decision about mate fidelity is influenced by the condition of the female and the attractiveness of her mate. Some evidence was found that male parental quality was correlated with male attractiveness.