Male choice and sperm competition as constraints on polyandry in the red-necked phalarope Phalaropus lobatus

Summary The mating system of the red-necked phalarope Phalaropus lobatus is usually classed as polyandrous, but studies show that the majority of females are monogamous. Polyandry appears to be constrained because later arriving males do not usually nest with females that have already laid a clutch that season (C1-females), despite the sexual receptiveness of these females. Rather they nest with females that have not previously laid a clutch that season (C0-females). Five potential explanations of this constraint on polyandry were tested. Two hypotheses, invoking female-female competition, were not supported as female agonistic success appeared to be unrelated to priority of access to males, and there was no apparent difference between C0- and C1-females in their ability to find unpaired males. Two hypotheses suggest that C0-females are preferred by males either because they can initiate a clutch more rapidly or because they lay larger eggs. Neither hypothesis was supported by the available data. The data upheld a third male choice hypothesis that C1-females are discriminated against because they have copulated previously with another male and this may compromise paternity. Secondary males copulated and attempted to copulate more often when paired with C1-females, suggesting that sperm competition was greater and confidence of paternity was lower. Corroborative evidence of active male choice showed that males were more aggressive towards associating C1-females than towards C0-females, although how males discriminated between the two classes of females was not determined.