Problems in the assessment of the package effect in five small phytoplankters

The magnitude of the package effect in five small phytoplankters Thalassiosira sp., Clone 2601 (an unidentified eucaryote), Nannochloris atomus, Synechococcus Syn and Synechococcus WH 7803] was assessed by comparison of the absorption spectra of intact and disrupted cells. The package effect was considerably reduced with reductions in cell size and this was broadly in agreement with theoretical predictions based on Mie theory. However, the quantitative assessment of the package effect is confounded by an inability to assign attenuation (apparent absorption) measurements at =750 nm to either scattering or absorption. The magnitude of the apparent absorption at =750 nm was greatest with the smallest picoplankton species examined, and was reduced, but not eliminated, after cell disruption. Whilst the apparent absorption at =750 nm is commonly thought to be due to residual scattering losses, the available evidence does not exclude the possibility that this may be due in part to absorption by cells or cell constituents and this requires further examination. Although these difficulties are particularly evident with the small picoplankton species, there is no reason to expect that they will not complicate the assessment of the package effect in larger phytoplankton cells.